Summary: Five years after the end of "The Jerkinators", all is calm in both Dimmsdale and Retroville. That is, until Tootie finds an old picture of Timmy with Cindy at the inter-dimensional dance. This leads to Tootie nearly swearing vengeance on an innocent Cindy. Tootie and Timmy make their way to Retroville, where Jimmy and Timmy do something that gets them in a lot of hot water with their respective girlfriends! All I can say is that may Fate or God or whatever have mercy on those two boys!

Disclaimer: I'm only gonna say this once…so here goes: The characters used herein and the shows they are on are the property of Butch Hartman, John Adams, and Nickelodeon. I own nothing here but the plot I decided to put them into. With that now out of the way…on with the story!

Dimmsdale, California

In an upstairs bedroom of the Turner residence, two fifteen year olds sit comparing notes for an upcoming History quiz. The two teens in question are none other then Timmy Turner and his girlfriend of one year: Tiffany McDonald, better known to her friends and family as "Tootie".

"Geez, do you think McCormick could have made this any tougher?" Timmy groaned.

"What do you mean "tougher"? I thought you were a History whiz hon." Tootie replied, going over his notes.

"I am, but even this is ridiculous babe, I mean besides the fact that I don't normally study before a test and still ace it, this one is going to be brutal." Timmy called from across the room.

Tootie just giggled at that last comment, everyone in their class knew full well that Timmy never studied and still was getting an "A", and just how much it drove their teacher up the wall.

Tootie sat back down and began to study, when a pen came whizzing by about an inch from her ear. She looked up in shock to see Timmy with a freaked out look on his face.

"Oh geez, sorry Toot. It ran out of ink, and I normally whip it when it does that. Could you grab me another pen please?"

Still a little bit rattled by the near miss with the pen, she cautiously got up.

"Where are they honey?"

"They should be in the upper…no lower right hand drawer of my computer desk." He said without even looking up.

She just rolled her eyes and began to rummage through the cluttered drawer. She pulled out an old, wore out piece of paper and let out a little laugh.

"What's so funny?" Timmy asked.

"This, I can't believe that you kept your old restraining order against me. Ah memories!" she replied with a smirk. Timmy just giggled at it.

"I never know when I'm gonna have to have it reinstated you know." he replied, before ducking out of the way of the now wadded up document that Tootie threw at him.

"I was only kidding!" Timmy whimpered, flashing her the "sad puppy dog" eyes that always made her melt.

Tootie sighed, knowing that even she couldn't resist that look, and went back to looking for a pen.

"I don't see any pens in here. Are you sure that…" she cut off when she found an old, slightly faded picture of Timmy with a blonde girl at what looked to be a school dance.

"…What…the HELL…is THIS!" she finished, yelling at him. Timmy took the picture from her (remaining at arm's length, just in case) and looked at it.

"Oh this, remember me telling you about the three times I got sucked into another dimension?" Tootie shook her head yes, "Well, this is the girl I was telling you about." Tootie looked first at him, then at the picture of the blonde.

"What's her name Timmy?"

Timmy gulped, then replied "Cindy Vortex."

Tootie just stared at the picture for what seemed like an eternity, before she finally spoke.

"So this Cindy Vortex is yet another in a long line of chicks trying to take MY man away from me!" Timmy shook his head and grabbed her by the shoulders.

"No it wasn't like that Toot. We just flirted, in fact I believe that she did it only to get under the skin of the boy she really liked: Jimmy Neutron." Tootie looked at him strange for a moment.

"Wait a minute…you mean, that guy that we all thought was you in another "reality avoidance costume" was really someone else?" she asked, looking pale. Timmy just shook his head yes.

"Oh God! I tried to kiss someone other then you!" she said gagging a little.

Timmy looked at his freaked out girlfriend for a few moments, then just burst out laughing, tears streaming from his eyes.

"What's so god dang funny Timothy?" Tootie asked with a serious tone.

"You thought….he was…me! You probably…freaked him out…to no end!" Timmy cried between deep guffaws. Tootie just rolled her eyes and punched him in the arm…hard.

"I'm sorry babe, it's just that I really didn't like her that much. I really only flirted with her to get back at Neutron for being Mr. "High and mighty boy genius" all the time." Timmy said, rubbing his sore arm.

Tootie, still a little freaked out at nearly kissing someone other then Timmy, looked at him sheepishly.

"So you never had feelings for this Cindy girl?"

"Not really, remember back then I was more into Trixie then anybody. Besides, it would've never worked. Other then the fact that the whole "being in two different dimensions" would've made dating next to impossible, I got the distinct feeling that Cindy's friend Libby didn't like me too much. Either for portraying myself as a genius or because I was supposedly going after Cindy."

Tootie sighed in relief, then something that Timmy said hit her.

"Hold on, you portrayed yourself to be a genius?" Timmy nodded his head, and this sent Tootie into a fit of laughter.

"It's not that funny Tiffany!" Timmy groaned, getting a dose of his own medicine.

"You…a genius! Oh that's rich!" Tootie snorted after calming down a little.

"You know, I can always dump you and go after Veronica or Trixie right?" Timmy said with a serious edge to his voice. He never meant it, but it was still a good threat to use against her.

"You wouldn't dare!" Tootie snapped.

"Of course I wouldn't, but since you fall for it every time, I like to use it!" Timmy said, wrapping his arm around her waist and kissing her.

After they broke the kiss, they went back to studying. Even with all of his assurances about not only this Cindy girl, but also her friends Trixie and Veronica, that little paranoid voice in the back of her head that sounded like her as a ten year old rang out.

He could possibly go through with that threat you know. How do we know that he is totally over Trixie? The voice called.

Shut up, I know full well he is over Trixie, and he never had a thing for Veronica anyway. I don't doubt that he never had true feelings for this Cindy Vortex either. She shot back.

We'll see. In fact, let's talk Timmy into taking a trip to this Retroville and find out. The voice answered.

Works for me! She snapped back.

She gazed up at Timmy, who was concentrating hard on the section about the Texas Revolution.

"Hey sweetie?" She asked.

"Yeah Toot?"

"I was wondering, do you think that we could possibly…"

"Possibly what?"

"…go to this Retroville? Just so I can meet this Cindy girl. Also to apologize to Jimmy for almost glomping him by mistake."

Timmy mulled it over for a moment. "Sure, I've been meaning to contact Neutron for awhile now. I kinda miss him and his crew."

She waited for him to pull out some kind of device, but when he went back to his homework, she got antsy.

"I meant, like contact him now?"

Timmy just shook his head, "No can do. At the moment I can't find the device he gave me." He swept his hand across the trashed bedroom.

"As you can see, that would take a lot of time, plus we got this quiz to study for. I'll find it by tomorrow…I promise." He said with a tiny wink to his goldfish bowl. She gave him a small smile,

"Ok Timmy." Timmy smiled back, then looked at the clock.

"Oh crap, it's already 10:30!" Tootie looked in shock at the digital alarm clock on his nightstand.

"Well, I guess I better get going, my parents said no later then 10:45, and since Vicky left for college in Florida, they have gotten their backbone back. They'd ground me in a heartbeat."

The two got up, and they went downstairs. They paused at the front door to make sure that his parents weren't eavesdropping on them.

"I'll see you tomorrow morning babe." Timmy said.

"You know it, remember to try to find that device sweetie." Tootie replied. They kissed and Tootie began to walk home. I will be calm when I meet this girl. I will be calm when I meet this girl. Tootie chanted in her mind.

Once the door was closed, Timmy rushed up the stairs to his room.

"Cosmo! Wanda!" he called.

"What is it sport?" Wanda asked as the two poofed into their fairy form.

"I wish this room was spotless, and that the device Neutron gave me was in my hand!"

"You got it Timmy!" Cosmo yelled as they waved their wands. POOF! The room was neat and tidy again, and what looked to be an old Game Buddy with a weird looking pen (his old "Auto Poofer") sticking out the top of it appeared in Timmy's right hand.

"Thanks guys, I'll wait until after school to try to talk to Neutron. Good thing he modified it to make it an all in one communications/teleportation device." Timmy said.

"Are you sure you should take Tootie to Retroville?" Wanda asked.

"I'm sure Wanda. It's not like Tootie actually wants to do harm to Cindy. Plus if I remember right, Cindy is into Tae-kwan-do and karate, so Cindy can defend herself." Timmy replied. They waited on Cosmo to say something, but since he recently recovered his "long lost" nickel Phillip, Cosmo was cuddling with "her".

"Who's a good nickel? Yes, you are aren't you? Oh Phillip, I hope we never lose each other ever again!" he cried out suddenly. Wanda rolled her eyes and poofed them back into the fishbowl while Timmy got ready for bed.

"Good night guys." Timmy said as he switched off the lights.

"Good night Timmy!" they both called back. The next day was sure to be full of surprises, Timmy could feel it.

A/N: Read and Review please. I hope that y'all like the start of this story!