Title: Unbreak My Heart - Turnabout

Author: Melpomene

Email:

Rating: R

Spoilers: Season 3

Keywords: M/O, MSR, S/O, Angst

Summary: What happens when you fall in

love with someone who doesn't love you back.

Author's Notes: Thank you so much to everyone

who supported me recently when I came close to

not finishing this story. I appreciate it more

than I can say. I hope you all enjoy this next

chapter.

Part 5 - Turnabout

Mulder checked the clock for the twentieth

time that morning--8:45. Five minutes later than

it had been five minutes ago. Scully was due back

to work that morning and he could hardly stand to

wait. Today, he would find out if Scully was

staying in the partnership.

He checked the clock again. 8:50.

It had been a long four weeks. He'd been suspended

from work for the first two because of his actions

in the Tilley case. He'd gladly served his time,

wracked with guilt over how Scully had been almost

killed.

His relationship with Ronni had spiraled down to

a series of meaningless sexual encounters. Maybe

that was all it had ever been and he'd just been

fooling himself that it was more. He'd come close

to breaking it off the previous Friday but

Ronni had begged him to give the relationship

another chance.

She argued that he'd hurt her feelings by calling

out Scully's name when he came. According to Ronni,

there was no worse insult to a woman then to have a

man make love to her and think about another woman.

Ronni had actually cried, which was something Mulder

had never seen and it had struck his old chord of

guilt. He'd agreed to try again, though he wasn't

sure that was the right thing.

God, he wished Scully would get there. Good news

or bad, he couldn't stand the waiting. Finally,

he heard the sound of high heels tapping their way

closer and closer in the hall outside.

"Good morning," Scully said from the doorway. She

looked more beautiful than he remembered, her hair

shinier and brighter, her skin creamier and her

lips fuller and riper. How could he have worked

with this woman for years and not noticed these

things?

Scully was wearing a trim navy suit and white

blouse. He didn't remember her waist being that

tiny. His hands could probably span it and

hardly leave her breathless. God, he wished he

could leave her breathless.

But Scully looked as calm and cool as a tall

glass of ice water. She looked relaxed and

happy. Maybe that damn Joe was leaving her

breathless.

"I made coffee," he said.

"Oh, good. I could use a cup," she replied as

she walked to the area in the back of the room

where the coffee pot was set up. She smiled to

herself, Mulder seemed as nervous as she was.

She had hardly slept the night before,

anticipating that she'd see Mulder again.

She brought her cup back to her desk, and watched

Mulder fidget in his chair. He cleared his throat.

"Scully, I...uh...I wanted to apologize about...

well, that night at your apartment."

"No Mulder," she began, shaking her head. "I'm

the one who should be apologizing. You've been

perfectly clear that you were never physically

attracted to me. Forcing myself on you..."

"You didn't."

"I most definitely did. I crossed the line and

my only defense was that I'd been through a

traumatic experience and was on a lot of

medication."

"I was just surprised by it, that's all. Scully...

I don't want this to come between us." Mulder

swallowed hard, glancing down at his feet.

"Skinner said you weren't sure if you could stay

in the partnership."

"I thought long and hard about that, Mulder."

She looked down at her hands, trying to compose

herself. She had so much to say, and things

could be made so much worse than they already

were if she said it wrong.

Mulder watched her, so afraid that she was

going to cut him loose. He wanted to beg her

to stay, to tell her that he was only now

realizing what a beautiful and desirable woman

she was--but he didn't have the guts to say

it. Not after the way he'd treated her.

"And what did you decide?" he asked, his voice

cracking a little bit.

"I'm staying," she answered firmly. "But Mulder--

some things have to change."

"Anything, Scully. Just tell me what you want."

She almost laughed at that. If Mulder got in a

panic over a little kiss, what would he say if

she told him she wanted him to make love to her?

Well, maybe she wasn't sure about that anymore

anyway. She'd spent so much time wishing Mulder

would look her way, and he'd never even given her

a glance. Now, someone thought she was pretty

and sexy. Joe Clancey saw her as a desirable

woman. That didn't stop her from wanting Mulder,

but it sure eased the ache.

Joe was a great kisser and he hadn't looked at her

after like she was the creature from the Black

Lagoon. No sir. After kissing her, he kissed her

some more and then looked at her as if she was the

most incredible woman he'd ever seen.

Maybe if she hadn't met Joe, she wouldn't be able

to stay in a partnership with someone she had feelings

for. But Joe's admiration gave her the confidence to

stay and to also speak her mind.

"I don't know how to say this without sounding

jealous of Agent Alain. I'm not...I mean, I have

no reason to be. She's the woman you've chosen to

be with and she comes first in your private life.

I know that. But Mulder, I have to come first

at work. If you can't keep your personal and

professional lives separate, I can't work with you.

I won't ever be put in danger like that again.

Understood?"

"Absolutely. I can't begin to tell you how sorry

I am about what happened Scully. I don't know if

you can ever forgive me--hell, I don't know if I

can ever forgive myself."

"Mulder," she said gently. "I don't blame you.

If you hadn't stepped out of the room, there might

have been two hostages instead of one and who knows

how long it would have been before backup got there."

His eyes remained trained on the floor. He could

barely breath as she spoke. She touched his hand

to get his attention and he looked up at her.

"But the phone did ring, and you let yourself be

distracted. You let your guard down as you dealt

with your girlfriend and I was almost killed.

That can't happen again."

"It won't. Ever. I promise."

He spoke with sincerity, and she believed he meant

it. The true test would be if he could keep his

promise when Ronni was around.

Over the next few days, Scully had wrangled with

the knowledge that Ronni was probably cheating

on Mulder. Should she tell him and risk hurting

him deeply? Would he even believe her, or would

he think Scully was just being jealous? Though

she sincerely didn't think so, there was also the

possibility that she was wrong about Ronni's

infidelity. Scully still wasn't sure what to do.

Mulder was on his best behavior, but Scully had seen

that before and found it to be only temporary. She

hoped that this time, he would be able to keep his

life separated properly.

Scully's biggest concern with coming back to work

had been spending time with a man who didn't love her

back. Watching Mulder at work--pacing the room while

trying to figure out a tough case, reviewing slides as

he'd been the first time she ever saw him, scratching

away at a legal pad as he covered it with case notes--

she did feel a painful tug on her heart.

But somehow, knowing that Joe Clancey thought she was

beautiful and sexy, went a long way toward making work

bearable. Mulder may not find her sexy--may never

look her way--but that didn't mean she was an ugly

drone. Not anymore.

Joe had been in New York for a few days to meet with

network news people. He was hoping to find something

news related to do while he completed his physical

therapy. Scully knew Joe hoped to get back to work in

the field as soon as possible. She'd miss him, but

no one understood the need to work more than Scully.

Mulder hadn't asked her about Joe. Scully was glad

about that--relieved in a way that there had been no

phone calls at work, no lunches out for either her or

Mulder. It allowed them to spend a little time

together and heal their work relationship.

A few days after coming back to work, Scully was

checking on some test results just before quitting

time. She'd been hoping that Mulder wouldn't mind

shelving the work until the morning as Joe was calling

her that night from New York.

It had been a good long time since Scully had seen

Ronni, and she'd hoped to extend that lucky streak but

her good luck was about to end. Ronni stood in the

doorway of the office, her strong perfume wafting over

the air. The other woman had stopped down in the

basement to collect her boy-toy.

"Why Agent Scully, you look so much better," Ronni Alain

purred. "You're so slim now." Trust the woman to

remind everyone in the room that she's looked so

much worse in the past.

"Why thank you," Scully said, ironically. She crossed

to her desk and opened the drawer to get her purse.

"So, what's Joe Clancey like?" Ronni asked, covetously.

"I'll bet he's fascinating."

"He is," Scully answered, cautiously.

"Joe Clancey," Mulder said, thoughtfully. He'd thought

the guy was familiar when he saw Scully with him, but

he hadn't been able to place him. Now, it came back

to him. "The foreign correspondent?"

"Yes darling, that's him. Isn't it exciting! Our little

Agent Scully has found herself a real celebrity."

"I'll be on my way," Scully said as she gathered up her

belongings. "Have a good night, Mulder...Agent Alain."

Mulder watched her rush out of the room. He wondered

if she had a date with Joe Clancey. She hadn't mentioned

the man since the night Mulder and Ronni had run into

them. He hoped his partner wasn't setting herself up for

a fall. A guy like Joe Clancey could bring a lot of

heartache.

He wondered if his partner was in love with this guy.

Men like Joe Clancey never settled down. What was

Scully thinking? She was never going to have a life

with a guy who travelled the world, always living on

the edge. Who the hell knew--maybe Clancey was one of

"them." A guy shows an interest in Scully out of the

blue--who knew where he came from anyway?

The last few days had been an excruciating rollercoaster

ride. He'd gone from seeing his partner as "one of the

guys" to being hyper aware of her as a desirable woman.

He'd become fascinated with her every graceful movement

--the way she tucked her hair behind her ear, or tapped her

fingernail against the table when she was deep in thought.

He found himself standing close to her, just to smell

the clean scent of her soap and cologne. If he thought

she wouldn't break his arm, he'd have put his hand on

the small of her back when they walked out of the room

together.

His date with Ronni went the way their dates always

seemed to go these days--boring conversation followed

by wild, but for him unsatisfying sex. Devouring him

sexually, Ronni was even more predatory in bed than

she'd ever been. It was Mulder who was changing. Afterwards,

he felt increasingly uncomfortable with the emptiness

of the experience.

The next morning, Mulder arrived to find Scully

already at work. The scent of coffee filled the air

and his partner was humming offkey as she typed.

"Hi Mulder," she greeted him. "Coffee's on."

"Somebody's in a good mood," he said.

"I guess I am," she answered. Joe was flying back

today. He'd called her last night and invited her

to dinner. She and Joe hadn't gone beyond kissing

and touching each other since they started going out.

Scully was wondering if tonight would be the night

things would change--the night they started making

love.

Apparently the news in New York had been good--he'd

be consulting on some news stories in Washington.

Granted, it was mild fare in comparison to what Joe

was used to, but for the stir-crazy reporter, it was

better than nothing.

"Hot date last night?" Mulder asked, sounding a

little crankier than usual.

"No actually. I had an early night. You?"

"Don't ask," he replied, annoyed. Damn it,

the scratches on his back hurt. Ronni had

been rough, raking her nails down his back and

leaving him raw and sore. "So, why weren't you

out with that reporter guy?"

"Joe?" she asked. "He's been out of town. He's coming

home today, though."

"Scully...how much do you know about this Joe guy?"

"What do you mean 'how much do I know about him?' All

I had to do was watch the 6:00 o'clock news to know

all about him."

"I know all about that. What I mean is..."

"You want to know his intentions? Mulder, you're

not my father. I can take care of myself."

"I know you can take care of yourself. But I just

don't want you to get hurt. Joe Clancey's not the

type to settle down."

"Since when are you an expert in Joe Clancey, or in

settling down for that matter? And who said that's

what I want?" she replied, laughing. "I'm not looking

for a lifetime committment, Mulder. It was just nice..."

She drifted off, shaking her head. She didn't owe

Mulder any explanations. Not after the way he'd

treated her.

"What was nice?" His voice was soft and gentle.

"It was nice to have someone think I'm sexy. Don't take

this the wrong way, Mulder, but working with you

just about destroyed my self-confidence."

"Scully, what on earth did I ever say or do to hurt

you?" Mulder asked, obviously upset.

"You didn't," she said gently, laying her hand on his

arm. "You've always treated me as an equal and that's

meant a lot to me. But, I'm clearly not your type,

Mulder."

"Scully--" he protested, fumbling for something to say.

What could he say--I never thought you were my type until

someone else wanted you? It was true--he'd written her

off as a sexual being until he saw her walk into that

restaurant in her clingy blue dress. On the arm of another

man.

"You can't change what attracts you, Mulder. I'm not

trying to make you feel guilty. But, well...after a

while, I started to feel invisible...as a women, that

is. With the hours we work, I had no time for a social

life, and the man I spent 90% of my time with saw me

as one of the guys."

At his look of shock, she shook her head. "I'm not

complaining--really. You've always been a perfect

gentleman to me. It's just that when I met Joe, I

realized how nice it was to have a man look at me and

see a woman and not one of the guys."

"Scully, I never knew...you felt that way."

"Honestly, it didn't bother me in the beginning.

But after you started seeing Ronni, I realized that

I wanted a man to look at me the way you looked at her."

"Scully, I don't know how to ask you this, so I'm

just going to ask. This guy came into your life

suddenly and wham bam--you're dating him. How do

you know he isn't...well...one of them?"

Her eyes flashed anger and the hands at her sides closed

up into fists. How dare he? It was okay for him to

go from zero to sixty with Ronni after one case, but

dumpy old Scully meets a nice man and it's a set up.

"What are you saying Mulder? No one except "one of them"

could possibly be interested in poor pathetic ugly Scully?"

Her voice got a little louder and shriller than she

liked but she was so angry.

"That's not what I meant," he said defensively. "I

just don't want you to get hurt."

"That's rich, Mulder. You're concerned about me getting

hurt. I wish you'd been a little more concerned about

that over the last few months."

The phone on Mulder's desk rang, and for a minute,

she thought he wasn't going to answer it--his eyes

seemed locked on hers. Finally, he broke away and

picked up th phone.

"Yes. Okay...yes...four o'clock...yes, sir."

"Skinner wants to see the report from the Crandall case

at four o'clock. Scully..."

"Then we'd better get to work on that report, Mulder,"

she said through clenched teeth.

It had taken all her energy to be as honest as she'd

been and now to have him insult her. She came so close

to telling him about Ronni and her reputation and her

lunchtime trysts. Maybe it was a good thing the phone

rang. No matter how angry she was, hurting Mulder on

purpose wasn't something she wanted to do.

They worked on the report, each of them sneaking looks

at the other. Mulder was miserable. He certainly

had put his foot in his mouth over Joe--hard to

believe a size 13 foot could make it, but then again

his mouth was way too big for his own good.

At four o'clock, they went up to Skinner and presented

their report. Their boss looked the report over,

asking questions from time to time. He was checking

more than just their work--he was reviewing them as

a team. The events at the Tilley farm had seriously

damaged the best partnership he'd ever seen and he

wasn't about to let that go.

Skinner thought there was still a lot of tension

between his two agents. Too much maybe for them to

work effectively. He'd have to watch them carefully

for the next few weeks.

The meeting ended and Mulder and Scully returned to

their office. It was after 5:00 o'clock, so Scully

grabbed her purse.

"I'll see you tomorrow," she said.

Mulder opened his mouth to speak, but he'd probably

only screw things up further, so he just waved

goodnight as she left. How did he get in such a

mess anyway?

He'd fallen in love with his partner, who now wanted

nothing to do with him and had found someone else.

Mulder was stuck dating a sexual vampire who was

bleeding him dry. How could he put things right

again?

He knew Scully was going to get hurt by this Joe

Clancey guy--he just knew it. Joe would romance her

and then leave her when his wounds were healed and he

got sent to another danger zone to report the news.

And then Scully would be heartbroken and Mulder

didn't think he could stand that.

Meanwhile, Scully was getting ready for her date.

Joe was due to come over for dinner. She knew he'd

be really tired after flying to New York, so she'd

offered to cook dinner at her apartment.

The steaks were marinating, the salad was fixed and

dessert had been picked up on the way home from work.

Well, with a little luck, dessert would wait until

morning.

Tonight was the night, Scully thought. Tonight she

was ready to take things to the next step with Joe.

They'd kissed and made out like teenagers, but she'd

held off on taking their relationship further because

she was still unsure. Her conversation with Mulder

today had irritated her enough to throw caution to

the winds.

Scully took a quick shower, paying special attention

to shaving her legs and underarms. It wouldn't be

very sexy to have bandaids on her legs tonight. After

she dried off, she applied her favorite scented body

cream.

She put on silky slacks and a lacy sleeveless top

that clung to her every curve. Strappy sandals completed

the look. She smiled at her reflection in the full

length mirror. A few weeks ago, she never would have

worn such a sexy outfit. She would have felt ridiculous--

like an ugly little duck masquerading as a beautiful

swan. Thanks to Joe, she knew she was that swan.

The doorbell rang and after peaking through the spy-hole,

she smiled and answered the door.

"Hope you're hungry," she said as Joe walked into the

apartment. He handed her a large bouquet of roses.

"I'm starving, and not just for dinner. God, you look

absolutely amazing."

He took her in his arms and kissed her, her mouth opening

under his like a little baby birds. With one hand full

of roses, Scully still managed to curve the other hand

around Joe's neck. His hands were on her, touching her,

cupping her bottom as he fed on her lips. The both ended

up laughing and gasping for air.

"I missed you," she said, as she led him into the kitchen.

She brought the bouquet to her nose and inhaled the

flower's heady fragrance. "These are just beautiful, Joe."

"They pale in comparison to you," he said, laughing. "I

can't believe how cheesy that line sounded."

Scully laughed too, but secretly she loved when Joe said

stuff like that, no matter how cliched or cheesy it might

sound. It had been far too long since anyone complimented

her and she wasn't about to give it up anytime soon.

"Sounded fine to me," she said, sliding her arms around his

waist. "I should probably get dinner started."

"I could wait," he said, sliding his hands under her top.

Her breath caught at the feel of a man's hand on her

bare skin. God, she'd almost forgot what that felt like.

"I thought you were starved," she said, her head swimming

as he cupped her breast through the lacy fabric of her

bra.

"I believe I said I was starving, but not just for dinner,"

her replied. "One of my appetites is far outweighing

the other."

He pulled her closer to him, so she could feel the evidence

of his appetite poking hard and hot against her tummy.

"Come on," she said, laughing and taking his hand. "I

wouldn't want you to go hungry."

"Wait, wait," he said, scooping her up in his arms. "I

wanted to do this since I first met you."

"Joe!" Scully cried out as Joe carried her in the direction

of the bedroom. "I'm too heavy--you'll hurt your leg."

"Nonsense," he said, laughing. "You don't weigh anything

at all. Now, prepare to be ravished, wench."

Continued in part 6...