Now for the question: does Luke deserve redemption? There were only 2 responses for this one but they are both a different opinion so it works.

HarmonyHarpshine7: Yo! Thanks for choosing my question! I've wanted to share this ever since people started talking about it. I think no. He doesn't. I don't believe a last-minute decision to change sides warrants the kind of redemption people are giving him. I don't believe he deserves punishment. But I feel the best he can get is asphodel fields. It was his fault Kronos came back in the first place, he turned his back on everyone who loved him for power. Yes, he was being manipulated, but everything Kronos told him was true. He decided to do those things. He tried to run away with Annabeth, not because he changed his mind, but because he was scared. Yes he did save the day, but that doesn't mean he gets redemption for the three years of fright and misery he inflicted, let alone the deaths. So no, he doesn't deserve it.

MidnightBunny: Yes luke deserves redemption! He was doing what he thought best. Hermes left him with a crazy lady for a mother, even if he tried to stop her. He thought he was left with a father who didn't want him, didn't love him, and a crazy person screeching about his fate! Why wouldn't he join the titans? And, let's not forget, he gave his life to stop Kronos. If anyone could (or should) have a second chance, it's him.

I think that HarmonyHarpshine7 has solid reasons for believing Luke doesn't deserve redemption but I still agree with MidnightBunny on this matter.

Think about it: Luke was a BABY when Hermes left him with May Castellan. 9 years of hiding in closets from his MOM, not knowing what is going on, and scared half to death. He ran away when he was 9 years old. He had to go from Connecticut all the way to Long Island. He met Thalia on the way and since she was younger, he technically helped take care of her. And then came Annabeth, a 7-year-old, that he also had to help take care of. That's a lot of pressure and they were a family. Then Thalia died and she was turned into a tree. Imagine seeing someone you cared about as a tree, a reminder they died to save you. He was emotionally overwhelmed and he was humiliated on his quest. His dad sent him to do something that someone had already done, and wasn't really a big deal.

He is already having a hard time so it is easy to manipulate him because he already did hate the gods. He hated Hermes for leaving him and humiliating him. He hated Hades for cursing his mom and killing Thalia.

He couldn't just LEAVE Kronos because Kronos would punish him and he had already gone too far. I believe he deserves redemption because he didn't do anything wrong in my opinion. He was hurt and no one was helping him. Kronos was the only one offering him anything so he took it.

If people had really cared about him, he wouldn't have ended up like that. It also wasn't his fault anyone died. It was always a monster or Kronos. Luke had every right to hate the gods because they never did anything for him or any of their children. So Luke wanted to do something.

Next question! "Who is better/which camp is better? Greek or Roman/Camp Halfblood or Camp Jupiter?"