What, Will, I, Have, Left:
This is my second Klaroline story. I hope you all like it^^ This time this is a Human AU. If you like this story fav it, follow it or comment it^^ If you like it, guys I will keep updating it. Thank you for all your support.
Ships: Klaroline, Kalijah, Kennett or kolvina (which one you like the most?), Stebekah, Hayley x Freya, Delena and Finn x Sage.
In this fic Caroline and Hayley are sisters. Hayley is the oldest sister.
Ps: there are some mentions of abort discussions, alcohol and drugs and bulimia. Nothing to explicit but if, you're offended or something don't read it.
I will update "Where You Left Your Heart" next week. ^^
Ps 2: The originals had the worst ending I've ever seen. They end up in dust like in infinity war instead of burning alive. Ew, the only good thing was the Klaroline kiss. Horrible ending.
If you want me to continue the story leave a comment ^^
Summary: Klaus and Caroline were together in high school. However, when they finally slept together he completely ignored her. A few months after she finds out she is pregnant and he tells her to abort the child. What will happen when they meet again twelve years later? Will Caroline ever forgive him?
Chapter one:
The Forbes Residence, Mystic Falls:
Christmas was Hope's favourite time of the year. Christmas meant seeing all her family together again. Their grandma Liz is the sheriff of Mystic Falls, she's a very important part of the town, she barely had holidays, which is why Christmas is so important. It's the only time of the year when she doesn't work.
Even though the twins loved Mystic Falls, the ride it was horrible. Thirteen hours in a car, only stopping once or twice to sleep and get some food. It was exhausting. Their aunt Kat always suggests to take a plane but since their aunt Hayley is afraid of them they always have to drive from New Orleans to Mystic falls.
They arrived to Mystic Falls yesterday, December 12th. It was a cold snowy day and they were very tired form the trip. The first thing they did was hug their grandma and then they went to see a movie in the living room, drinking hot chocolate.
"Mom, where's aunt Kat? She said she would watch a movie with us tonight." The eleven year old blonde girl asked.
"She went to see her sister." Her aunt replied covering herself with her grey wool blanket.
"But I thought they hated each other. She always calls her twin the evil doppelganger." The honey haired girl replied.
"They have a complicated relationship. Aren't you girls tired?" Their mother asked.
"It's not that complicated mom, aunt Kat was dating her boyfriend Damon and then he cheated on her with her twin sister Elena. And no mom we're not tired. Right, Hope?" Lizzie replied sassily.
"How come we've never meet Elena?" Hope asked.
"Because we live in New Orleans with aunt Kat and she hates Elena." Lizzie told to her sister.
"Why did aunt Kat's ex boyfriend cheated on her? I mean I seen pictures of Elena and aunt Kat and they look the same." Hope asked once again.
"Why are you girls suddenly gossiping about Katherine?" Hayley stared at her nieces curiously.
"Isn't it obvious? We're bored. We saw this movie at least 20 times. Besides we won't get the Christmas gifts until 24th."Hope rolled her eyes.
"We want new cell phones mom. And a new piano and more art supplies and clothes..." Lizzie kept telling all the things they both wanted.
"Okay, okay… First of everything it's a tradition to watch 'Home Alone' in Christmas, and second of it I won't buy you girls new phones, I won't buy you a new piano either but yes to the art supplies and clothes." Caroline smiled at her daughters.
"But mom the new phones are a necessity!" The twins said at the same time.
"Your phones aren't even a year old and they work perfectly fine." Caroline stared at her daughters amused.
"Okay fine… But mom I wanted to ask you something." Hope shyly said.
"Tell me, baby." Her mother sweetly smiled at her.
"You see… You know Lizzie and me are artists right? True she prefers playing the piano rather than painting like I do but… My favourite artist ever is here in Mystic Falls he is going to have an art exhibition tomorrow. Can we please go?" Hope gave her the puppy dog face to make her mom say yes.
"I love painting as much as I love to play the piano, Hope. Besides I don't get why you like Klaus Mikaelson so much, yes he does paint really well but there are other artists better than him!" Lizzie innocently said.
"But Klaus Mikaelson is the best artist of this century Lizzie!" Hope defended her favourite artist.
"Just wait until I grow up, I will teach them what art is truly about." The blonde girl sassily replied.
Caroline went pale when her youngest daughter mentioned Klaus. The last time Caroline saw Klaus she was only sixteen and they didn't end up in the best terms. Actually, the things between them were horrible. She never wanted to see his face ever again, he was dead to her.
Twelve years ago:
Caroline was madly in love. She had a crush on Klaus for years and when she was sixteen, he asked her out which she immediately accepted. He had a bad reputation, he barely spoke to anyone from school except Damon Salvatore and his two siblings Rebekah and Kol. But he was one of the most popular guys from high school. He was very handsome, mysterious, he liked art, his British accent was really attractive and he had the cutest dimples every time he smiled.
After seven months, together Caroline and Klaus had sex for the first time. It was a very important moment for Caroline. Since she was fourteen, she has been dealing with bulimia but she managed to keep it a secret from everyone. She had a very low self-esteem even though she was a cheerleader and one of the most popular girls in the high school. Everyone always choose Elena and Katherine before her, she was always the second choice until Klaus. He made her feel wanted and special but most importantly, when she was in his arms she felt loved.
On their third month, Klaus found Caroline vomiting in her bathroom. He was shocked when he saw his girlfriend doing that. He pulled her hand away from her mouth and kneeled beside her still holding her small hand. With his other hand he pulled her to him, hugging her while she cried in his chest.
"Why?" Klaus softy asked.
"It's nothing important let's just forget it." Caroline whispered not looking at him.
"For how long you've done this, Caroline?" Klaus ignored her last answer and asked again.
"I don't want to talk about it, Klaus. Just forget it happened." The sixteen year old teen snapped at her boyfriend.
"For how long Caroline?" He kept questioning her until she told him the truth.
"Since I was 14. I stopped when we started to date but…" She covered her face and cried once again.
"It's okay sweetheart you know I'll always be by your side just tell me what happened." Klaus played with her golden locks.
"It's my dad Bill. After saying I was not enough and constantly be remind me that I was nothing to him, he made me live a living hell until he finally left my mom. And you want to know the best part? He isn't my father. My entire existence is a lie." Caroline confessed.
"Most fathers are worthless, love. You deserve so much better than him. One day he'll pay for everything he did to you I promise you." Klaus darkly whispered.
"It's seems Hayley and I are full sisters. Which makes me really happy, it really does. But my real dad is dead. I will never be able to meet him not even once." Caroline cried harder.
"Don't cry, love. If he was still alive he would be proud, Caroline. Does anybody know about what you do?" Klaus kissed her forehead.
Caroline shocked her head whispering once again. "No one knows. Or they are just too busy and choose to ignore it."
"Promise me you'll never do it again." The eighteen year old guy begged.
"I promise." Caroline swore to him.
However, their perfect relationship took a turn to the worst after Caroline slept with him. The day after he completely ignored her and he evaded her at all costs. She had been trying to talk to him for hours but he ran way before she could talk. But when the classes were over she saw him walking towards his car.
"Klaus!" Caroline ran after him before he could escape again.
The dirty blonde haired guy turned around rolling his eyes. "What do you want Caroline?" He curtly replied.
Caroline's eyes winded at his angry voice. "What's the matter with you? You've been ignoring me all day long! Have I done something wrong?"
"Caroline love, I'm busy right now. We'll talk tomorrow." He tried to leave her all by herself but she grabbed him by his arm.
"Why are you treating me this way?"
"God Caroline you are so suffocating. Just leave me alone. It's over." Klaus said without any emotion.
"Are you breaking up with me?" The blonde haired cheerleader asked.
"Yes, Caroline. Look sweetheart, it was fun while it lasted but I already got what I wanted." The dirty blonde haired Mikaelson smirked.
"You only wanted to make love to me?" Caroline's eyes started to water.
"Make love to you? Caroline this isn't some 80s cheap romance. I only wanted to fuck you. Come on now don't start to cry. See this is why you bore me so much you spend the whole fucking day crying." Klaus angrily spat tired of his now ex girlfriend constant drama.
"You are a p-pig." The blonde girl managed say between her cries.
"I've been called worse, love. I just don't get how you bought all that 'I will always be by your side'. The thing is I've never loved you. You are a weak, stupid girl. The only reason I was with you was that Damon and I made a bet. Do you want to know what the bet was about? He dared me to seduce you and have sex with you. Which I already did both of those things. Now you are just completely and utterly useless to me." Klaus smirked at her hurt expression.
"Everything you said everything you promised was all a lie… You lying bastard!" Caroline screamed at him.
Hearing Caroline's screams her best friends Katherine, Elena and Bonnie ran to her side. Most of the students were watching them as if they were in a theatre, some of the students started to film their fight.
"Care. You okay?" Bonnie asked.
"Bon-Bon does she look okay to you?" Katherine sarcastically replied.
"Care, let's go. We'll take you home." Elena kindly said.
What absolutely no one expected was that Caroline slapped Klaus across the face as hard as she could. She even scratched his handsome face with her nails when she slapped him. Katherine and Elena were shocked to see their best friend acting like this.
Something truly fucked up he must had done to make her react that way. Katherine thought, she always disliked Klaus Caroline was far too good for a guy like him.
"I hate you." Caroline spat at him, running towards her car to go home.
She left him alone with everyone staring at him. Tired of the unwanted attention he screamed to everyone scaring them off. Then he just went back to his home acting as if nothing happened.
The cheerleader ignored Klaus for the next month, acting as if he never existed. Sometimes he stared at her but he didn't dare to talk to her. However, she's been feeling sick lately. Firstly she thought it was the flu but after a month she was still sick. Katherine suggested her to take a pregnancy test and unfortunately for her, it was positive.
Caroline was terrified only Kat and Hayley knew she was pregnant but eventually her mother would have to know. She just needed to talk to Klaus about this whole situation.
After the lunch break, she saw him in the corridor. She shyly tapped his arm making him turn to look at her.
"We need to talk…" Caroline whispered.
"Why would I want to talk to you, love? Unless… you're feeling lonely." He smirked at her.
"Gross… Just please this is important. Come to my house at 6:00pm my mom is working so we'll be alone." The blonde girl didn't looked at him.
"I'll see you later love." He said leaving her all by herself again.
Later that evening he was almost an hour late. But he went to her house. He knocked on the door, his gorgeous ex girlfriend opened the door. He could see how nervous she was, scared even.
"So, what is it love? You've been crying again? Stop being so weak Caroline." Klaus said when he saw her eyes were red.
"Shut up, Klaus. Sit down there's something yo-you need to know." She said.
"Very well love. Please do tell me the reason why you wanted me here." Klaus replied curious to see what she wanted.
"Remember when we made lo- we had sex."
"How could I forget? You are very elastic love. Want to repeat?" He seductively asked invading her personal space.
"I'm preg- pregnant." She whispered so lowly Klaus almost didn't hear her.
"You what?" The shocked teen asked.
"I'm pregnant… I've been sick for almost two months and Kat said I should take a pregnancy test, it came out positive. I wasn't completely sure because it could be a false positive, but then last week Dr. Fell confirmed it. I-I'm five weeks pregnant." She explained him.
"Caroline love stop joking. You know I hate jokes." Klaus muttered.
"I am not joking I'm pregnant and you are the father." Caroline said.
Klaus sat on the couch with his hands covering his face. He tried to steady his breathing but it was impossible. He was furious. He had a nice future full of success and fame. He had his whole life planned. Once he graduates from high school, he will go to Yale and then he will prove to Mikael how wrong he was about him. He was going to make him pay for everything he's done to him.
However, if Caroline told to anyone who was the father of that kid. His brother Elijah and his mother would make him take the responsibility for his actions. And if he raises that kid he won't be able to focus on his future. Therefore, Mikael would win once again. That's not going to happen, not again…
Besides that child would be better without a father like him. He darky thought.
"Please Klaus say something." Caroline's soft voice whispered to him.
"I want nothing to do with it. Besides, how do I know if it's mine?" He amusedly replied.
"You knew I was a virgin! You are the only man I've ever... done it." Caroline angrily spat.
"Very well… Let's say I believe you. What do you want?" He questioned her.
"I-I we-well I would just want your support and be there for our child." The sixteen year old was shaking.
"You want that thing to be born? Why? It's only going to ruin our lives. Just get rid of it." The dirty blonde haired man couldn't look at her shocked expression full of pain.
Caroline tried to talk but no words came out it was as if she could not speak. She sat down on her loveseat across from Klaus and she started to cry.
"Caroline love. I'll pay for everything. You abort that thing and our lives can be the same again." Klaus said softly.
"Don't call our child It. Look Nik I know you are scared of becoming like you-"Before she could finish he interrupted her.
"Bloody hell. It's nothing but a bunch of cells. I don't want it! Abort it, kill it. I don't want nothing that's going to link me to you until the day I die."
"I will not kill an innocent baby, just because you hate me. You used me, manipulated me and now you want me to kill an innocent baby. Our baby." The cheerleader screamed with all her anger.
"Stop calling it our baby. It's not ours. IT means nothing to me. Caroline love you are just sixteen I just turned eighteen. We can't raise a child. I have to go to Yale and you have to finish high school. Caroline it will ruin us." Klaus tried to convince her.
"lf we work together Klaus we can still do all we wanted to do. Please, don't do this. Don't act like Mikael." The blonde girl pleaded.
"Caroline you are bulimic. You can't even eat whole meal without vomiting it. How the hell you will raise a child here in Mystic Falls while I'm in collage?" Klaus sarcastically laughed.
"We could work it out. Nik, please I'm terrified. Don't leave me." Caroline stood up and walked towards him wrapping her small arms around him.
He closed his eyes and returned the hug. He kissed her head inhaling her scent one last time. "You will abort it, you won't tell anyone from my family you're pregnant. I want it dead."
She immediately broke the hug. Feeling furious at him. "You are a coward. How could you want your own baby to die?"
"BECAUSE YOU ARE NOTHING TO ME CAROLINE!" He screamed will all his fury for the first time scaring Caroline.
"I think it's time for you to leave Klaus." A voice behind them interrupted the teenagers.
"Mom?" The teen girl was surprised to see her mother.
"You don't have to worry Caroline won't get in your way. You have my word." Liz Forbes said to Klaus.
"Thank god." He muttered relieved.
"Now get lost before I shot you. Coward." The eldest woman threated the teen boy who immediately left.
"Is there anything else you've been hiding me Caroline?" Liz asked.
Present time:
"Mom? Mommy? Mama?" Lizzie tried to get her mother's attention.
"What is happening to mom?" Hope asked.
"Nothing is happening to your mother. She is just exhausted." Their aunt Hayley replied.
"Sorry girls. My mind was elsewhere." Caroline nervously smiled at them.
Lizzie gave her a suspicious look not completely believing her mother's reply, the youngest blonde wrapped her small arms around her neck with her head resting in her mother's chest. Care pulled her youngest daughter to her.
"So, can we go tomorrow mom?" Hope asked.
"No." Her mother replied.
"What? Mom please! Lizzie help me!" Hope said but noticed her twin was already falling asleep in their mother's arms.
"I forbid you, both of you. I don't want you to go, understood?" Caroline sternly said.
"Why mom? Aunt Hayley, grandma give me a little help please!" The dirty blonde haired child begged.
"Sorry little wolf, your mom is the one who makes the rules here." Hayley smiled.
"Because I am your mom. I don't have to explain myself to you Hope."
"That's not fair! I always explain myself to you mom." Hope made the three eldest women in the room laugh, which only made her angrier.
"You have to explain myself to me because I am your mother." Caroline sweetly explained kissing Lizzie's forehead.
"Tomorrow, we can go to the grill to see Uncle Matt, how does that sound?" Hayley asked.
"Boring. I want to go to the art exhibition." Hope crossed her arms angrily.
"Well sadly for you, you won't go." Her grandmother Liz replied.
"Lizzie wake up! She says she is not tired and look ten minutes later she fell asleep." Hope rolled her eyes annoyed.
"You've slept though out the whole ride but Lizzie was awake. I am actually surprised she lasted this long without falling asleep." The brunette smirked at her niece's angry expression.
"It's almost midnight. It's time to sleep Hope." Caroline stood up holding Lizzie in her arms walking towards their bedroom.
"Please mommy. Let me go tomorrow." The little girl begged once again.
"I said no Hope. Tomorrow you'll go with aunt Hayley to see your uncle Matt and then we'll do the Christmas shopping." Caroline tried to distract her to make her stop begging.
"We will put up the tree and the decorations tomorrow! Yeah!" Hope started to jump excited.
"But now you have to sleep or you'll be tired for tomorrow." Her mother laughed at her enthusiasm.
"Okay, mom. But I am still angry." Her eldest daughter sassily said.
Hope opened the door from her bedroom while Caroline was holding a sleeping Lizzie in her arms. The eldest twin jumped to her king sized bed while her mother tugged her twin sister in. Lizzie was peacefully sleeping while Hope was staring at the celling because she wasn't tired enough.
"Mommy tug me in." The blue eyed girl smiled at her showing her cute dimples.
"Of course my baby."
Caroline went to her side tugging her in and giving her a soft kiss in her cheek. Hope hugged her mother's neck giving her a kiss in her mother's blonde hair.
"Now it's time to sleep my little princess." Caroline whispered.
"I am the little wolf, Lizzie is the little princess."
"Both of you are my little princesses." The woman smiled.
"I love you, mommy." The eleven year old yawned.
"And I love both of you more than anything in this world. Goodnight Hope." Caroline stood up walking towards the door turning off the lights of the bedroom.
"Night Mommy." Hope whispered closing her eyes.
When Caroline left the room, Hope grabbed her tablet and played some games. Waiting for her mom aunt and grandma to fall asleep. One hour later, everyone was sleeping. When she stopped hearing noises, she tried to wake her twin up.
"Lizzie wake up." Hope whispered shaking her sister.
"hmmm… Stop." Lizzie muttered covering her head with the blankets.
"Lizzie, Lizzie!" Hope whispered her sister's name until she turned around.
"What? What!" Lizzie yelled whispering. She pulled off the blankets facing her twin.
"We have to go tomorrow to the art exhibition. Kla- Klaus is a super famous artist Lizzie! He travels around the world but now he is in the same town as us." Hope explained to her sister who didn't look very interested.
"Look Hope I love you. I would do anything to make you happy. But if we go and mom finds out we will be grounded and being grounded in Christmas means no gifts and I asked for lots of gifts this year." The blonde girl whispered.
"You're absolutely right, mom would be furious if she finds out. That's why she won't find out. Remember what aunt Kat always tells us." Hope tried to convince her sister.
"Shoes are a girls best friends? Especially the limited edition ones."
"No, not that Lizzie."
"Don't ever trust men, even less if his name is Damon."
"No, not that either."
"Be successful and use man like toys. Until you find the right man just use the rest of them to buy you more shoes."
"For goodness sake Lizzie. NO." Hope yelled frustrated.
"It's three in the morning you woke me up. I'm tired. Just let me sleep." Lizzie yelled back.
"Please, please Lizzie it's my dream to meet him." The eldest twin gave her a sad look.
"Fine. We can sneak out tomorrow when we are with auntie Hayley. We both know that mom would find out if we tried to sneak out while she is with us. She always knows everything it's like as if she had telepathy." Lizzie replied.
"Thank you!" Hope jumped wrapping her arms around her twin.
"If mom catch us we will be grounded forever." Lizzie whispered once her sister let her go.
"I will take full responsibility if mom catches us. Remember what aunt Kat always say 'Girls will always win in the end'" Hope whispered.
"I won't let mom ground you, if we go down we will go down together like sisters. Always together." Lizzie pressed a kiss in her fingers and Hope did the same before interlacing their fingers.
"Just like auntie Hayley taught us. I hope Niklaus Mikaelson is worth it. Night Hope." Lizzie closed her eyes trying to sleep.
"Night Lizzie." She closed her eyes waiting for tomorrow.