A/N: This story takes place after the events of "The New Kid", "The Fairly Loud Halloween", "Popular vs. Unpopular" and The Loud House: Lola vs. Lana. They're not essential to this story, but I figured it should mention it for continuity reasons.

It's almost Valentine's day, which means one thing for the students of Dimmesdale Elementary, it's was time to get ready for Valentine's dance. Timmy Turner and Chloe Carmichael walked into the school and made their way to their lockers.

"The Valentine's dance is almost her. I can hardly wait!" said a very excited Chloe.

Chloe noticed Timmy wasn't nearly as excited as she was and wondered why.

"How come you're not excited, Timmy?" asked Chloe.

"I don't exactly have the best Valentine's Days," said Timmy. "They typically suck."

"They can't be that bad."

"One resulted in me getting so embarrassed by every girl in Dimmesdale laughing at me that I wished that I lived in a world without girls. With that said I'm not going to enjoy the dance because I never can get a date."

Timmy and Chloe made it to their lockers and Chloe reassuringly said, "Don't be so down Timmy. I'm sure you can get a date this time."

Timmy opened his locker and a flood of cards poured out, burying him in the process.

"See? Look at all these Valentine cards that were in your locker," said Chloe.

Timmy's head popped out of the mountain of cards and thoroughly checked some of the cards.

"These aren't Valentine cards," said Timmy. "They're rejection cards. The girls in the school rejected me before I even got a chance to ask them to the dance."

Timmy looked through all the cards and noticed that a certain someone didn't give him a rejection card, giving him hope.

"Wait a minute… Trixie didn't give me a rejection card," said the hopeful 10-year old. "Maybe she wants to go to the dance with me."

Cosmo and Wanda poofed next to Timmy in the form of bees.

"Actually, Timmy, she gave you the biggest one of all," said Cosmo.

Cosmo poofed up a photo and handed it to Timmy. Timmy was shocked to see it was a photograph of his house and a rejection card towering over it.

"I even wrote what the card said on the back," said Cosmo.

Timmy looked at the backside of the photo and read aloud, "I will never go to the Valentine's dance with you ever, Timmy Turner."

"Cheer up, sport!" said Wanda. "I'm sure there's someone who will go to the dance with you."

"You're right, Wanda!" said Timmy. "I won't this giant representation of my failed love life stop me. Timmy Turner will have a date!"

Timmy jumped out of the rejection cards and ran down the hallway. Later, at the end of the school day, Chester, AJ, and Chloe found a dejected Timmy slumped in front of his locker.

"How'd your date hunt go, Timmy?" asked Chloe.

"No one said yes and asked everygirl in school," Timmy said in a dejected tone. "Well, except for you and Tootie."

As if on cue, Timmy heard Tootie call his name.

"AJ! Evasive maneuver alpha!" Timmy yelled.

AJ pulled out a switch, flipped it and hole opened in the floor. Timmy jumped down the hole, which closed soon after. Tootie ran up to his friends and asked, "Do you any of you know where Timmy is?"

Chloe, Chester and AJ shook their heads and Tootie ran off to continue her search for Timmy.

"Where does that hole lead anyway?" asked Chloe.

"The Anti-Timmy Turner club," said Chester.

AJ flipped the switch again and the hole in the floor opened up again. Timmy was raised out of the hole as he finished the tea in his teacup and said, "The sad thing is they're nice to me during they're club meeting then during the regular school day."

"Did you join them for a tea party?" asked Chloe.

"N-No!" Timmy stammered as he threw the evidence away. "Well, at least I'm not the only one without a date, right guys?"

"Actually, Timmy, I have a date," said AJ.

"What?! Who?!" asked Timmy.

"A synthezoid I made," said AJ.

AJ noticed the confused look on Timmy's face and explained, "It's an artificial person."

"Oh. Well, I guess it's just you and me, Chester," said Timmy.

"Actually I have a date with this rat that's been asking me for a weak," said Chester. "She wore me down."

"Are you two serious?!" said Timmy. "You're bailing on me like on Halloween?!"

"Sorry, Timmy," said AJ. "See ya, tomorrow."

AJ and Chester walked away leaving Timmy to feel even more dejected.

"I'll show them!" said Timmy. "I'll go with my backup friends."

Timmy was then shocked to see Sanjay and Elmer walk by with girls that look exactly like them. Even Elmer's boil has a date.

"Unbelievable!" Timmy said in an agitated tone. "Chester has a girlfriend, AJ has a girlfriend, Sanjay has a girlfriend, Elmer and his boil has girlfriends, Jimmy Neutron has a girlfriend, Lincoln Loud has a girlfriend. Why does everyone has a girl but me!"

"I thought this was just about a date to the dance," said a slightly worried Chloe.

"This isn't about the dance anymore! This is about how no girl in the world will ever love me!"

As if on cue, Tootie hugged Timmy from behind which further enraged him. Timmy escaped her grip and shouted, "NOT NOW TOOTIE!"

Timmy angrily stomped out of the school and Chloe followed moments later. Chloe watched everyone, including Francis, move out of Timmy's path. Cosmo and Wanda poofed next to Chloe and a worried Wanda said, "I never seen Timmy so angry before."

"Well, getting rejected over and over will do that to a guy," said Cosmo. "Like when the Tooth Fairy rejected me over and over."

"I feel really bad for Timmy," said Chloe. "Everyone wants to be loved. If only we could find him the perfect girlfriend."

Suddenly, Chloe got an idea.

"That's it! I'll just wish Timmy a girlfriend," said Chloe. "I wish Timmy had the perfect girlfriend. Someone who will always love him!"

"Now, Chloe, let's think about this wish," said Wanda. "Timmy made a wish like that once and it kinda backfired on him."

"Done!" Cosmo said as he waved his wand.

Later that day, Timmy was on his computer explaining his problem to Lincoln.

"Wow. The girls at your school can be pretty harsh," said Lincoln.

"Yeah, that's what happens when you're an average kid who no one understands," said Timmy. "But what am I'm going to do about my girl problem?"

Timmy then heard Lori's voice from off the screen who said, "I bet you wouldn't have any girl trouble here."

"What is she talking about?" asked Timmy.

"Nothing," Lincoln answered quickly. "Anyway, uhm, I'm sorry Timmy, I wish I could do something to help."

Upon hearing the word wish, an idea immediately popped into his head.

"Wish! That's it," said Timmy. "Thanks, Lincoln."

Timmy and Lincoln said they're goodbyes and Timmy ran to Cosmo's and Wanda's fishbowl. To his surprise, Cosmo and Wanda weren't there.

As Timmy pondered where his fairies are, he heard the doorbell. Timmy ran to the door, opened the door and when he locked eyes with the girl on the other side. She brushed her chestnut hair off her face and adjusted her glasses. Her smile made Timmy go weak in the knees and he couldn't stop himself from staring into her crystal blue eyes.

"Hello there. I'm Isabella," the girl said. "I'm your new neighbor."

Suddenly, Dad's head popped out of a nearby bush and optimistically asked, "New neighbor? Does that mean Dinkleberg's gone?"

"I'm sorry. I didn't move into Mr. Dinkleberg's house," said Isabella.

Dinkleberg walked by and noticed Dad in the bush.

"Hi Turner," Dinkleberg said with a wave.

"Dinkleberg…" Dad angrily muttered.