A/N: So I'm back once again, so lately my new obsession has been Glee and I am obsessed with the Rachel and Noah/Puck relationship/friendship (I was a massive Puckleberry Shipper the first time round and this time round tbh!)

A/N: Inspired from a friend of mine.. A Series of 'What If's?' (One-shots possibly longer depending on the plots)

Plot: What if it was Puck that Mr Schuester found in the Shower instead Of Finn?

Mainly Puckleberry, but will contain other Glee Pairings.

To say Will Schuester was disappointed was an understatement, he had tried to recruit more teenagers to join his Glee Club and failed, he had five members in The New Directions already but he needed to double that number and plus some if he wanted to enter The New Directions into any Show Choir competitions, he's annoyed that Sue seemed to one-upping him at every opportunity recently, she actually read the Show Choir Guidelines.

As he walks through the boy's locker room, his head slung down in defeat, he sees, well more like hears a light at the end of the tunnel, as he hears a male voice belting out the chorus of REO Speedwagon's Can't Fight This Feeling...

And I can't fight this feeling anymore
I've forgotten what I started fighting for
It's time to bring this ship into the shore
And throw away the oars, forever

Cause I can't fight this feeling anymore
I've forgotten what I started fighting for
And if I have to crawl upon the floor
Come crashing through your door
Baby, I can't fight this feeling anymore...

The person singing does shock Will, the boy in question has talent for sure he can't deny that, but is he right for the Glee image, Will shakes his head what is he saying? There is no way he could get Noah Puckerman, a jock none the less, to join The New Directions unless...

And it was in that moment he sunk low, it's the lowest thing he has done in his teaching career, as he is sitting in his office and Noah Puckerman is sitting across from him, in the middle of them is a pack of Weed that Sandy had given to Will after he saw him in Sheets and Things.

"Look Mr Schue, this isn't mine,I've never seen this before in my life" Puck says once Mr Schuester his Spanish Teacher asks if he knows why this was in his locker, when all really Puck had been thinking was since when did the school do locker checks?

"Noah" Mr Schuester started to say before the boy in front of him looked angry.

"It's Puck dude" The teenager gritted his teeth.

"Fine, Puck, you might have made a mistake and i want to help you, Puck you have to be honest, if this was Coach Sue or Mr Figgins, you'd be suspended, you could lose your football scholarship" Mr Schuester says trying to get the severity of this situation to the boy in front of him.

"My football scholarship?" Puck echoes what Mr Schuester had just said to him.

"Yeah, this will stay on your permanent record, as well as six weeks of detention, but if you let me help you, we can get taken off your permanent record, what do you say?" Puck looks up at the teacher in front of him there's no way he can take six weeks of detention his mother would find out, he was already a screw up, he didn't need her finding out about this, even if he hadn't done it, but it's his word and against the school he already knows who his mother would believe.

"What do I have to do Mr S?" Puck's voice sounds quiet so unlike the loud, brass and crass teenager.

"Well Puck, I know you are failing Spanish, which means you could potentially be dropped from the football team and I know you don't want that, do you Puck?" Will continues knowing he has the teenagers attention.

"No Mr S, please I will do anything!" The teenager says immediately.

"Puck, if you join Glee, I will make sure you had enough credits to pass Spanish so you can stay on the football team, what do you say?" Will says staring right at the boy, and he can see the wheels churning and turning in Noah Puckerman's head before he responds.

"When and where?" Puck says roughly.

"3PM in the Choir Room, don't be late" Mr Schuester answers before the tall, teenage boy storms out of his office.

Will smiles, he now has six members in The New Directions, if he can get someone as popular as Noah Puckerman to join, he can get anyone to join, he is so proud of himself for helping someone realize the potential they have, it's why he became a teacher in the first place.

To say that the other members of The New Directions reaction to Noah Puckerman joining Glee was surprising, it wasn't, they all out right hated the idea, Kurt was the first member to speak up, "Mr Schuester, you can't be serious, just this morning he threw me in a dumpster!"

"Mr S, in my defense I let him take his stupid Marco whatever thing off first" Puck responds.

"Hell to the no white boy, it's Marc Jacob! and can you even sing?" Mercedes asks him.

"Would I be here if I couldn't?" He says rolling his eyes.

"You P-p-pushed me and A-a-Artie into some lockers earlier" Tina stuttered as she looked him in the eye before looking away, "In your defense Puck you probably didn't see me"Artie says, almost as if he's making excuses for this Neanderthal's behavior, because he is scared of the jock.

"Can we just get on with the rehearsal please?" Puck looks across the room to find the crazy, Jewish Midget known as Rachel Berry tapping her foot looking impatient, he can't help but smirk, another way he can piss Rachel Berry off, if the slushies weren't enough he thinks.

"Sure" Mr Schuester says, trying to elevate the tension in the room, passing out sheet music for "You're the one that I want" from the musical Grease.

"So Rachel, you can do the female lead, Puck you will take the male lead on the first run through" The smirk drops from Puck's face as he sees Rachel Berry smirk across at him, as they stand at different sides of the room, in the formation Mr Schuester put them in, it's when Rachel first starts singing, he gulps, his nervous singing his part, he's a BAMF why was she scared of Rachel Berry?

You're the one that want...

As their hands meet, he knows he's screwed.

Damn Mr Schuester.

A/N 2: Please Read And Review x x x