Welcome to Lucy's Harem! This will be a Lucy x Erza x Lisanna x Levy story and it's my first attempt at a story like this. I hope this works out well. Also one of the four girls is a Futanari, but I won't reveal who it is until it's time for the first of many lemons.

It was a normal day in Fairy Tail, barring the occasional brawl started by Natsu, Gray and Gajeel. Lucy was watching the brawl as she was eating some yogurt. Erza put a stop to the fight, like she tended to do a lot of the time. Lucy had a lot of respect for Erza and even had a bit of a crush on her. She didn't know when she should confess her feelings to Erza but she wanted to confess soon, but she didn't know that both Lisanna and Levy had feelings for her. She soon finished her yogurt and decided to head home since it was getting late, she had a feeling that at least one of her guild mates would be in her apartment. When she walked into her apartment she was a bit surprised to see no one in there, which was kind of a relief to see since pretty much everytime she entered someone from the guild would be there. Once she got done eating, she walked over to her bathroom and started her shower. She stripped her clothes off and stepped into the shower, feeling the warm water hit her body she let out a sigh. While Lucy was showering Erza had sneaked into the apartment and sat on the couch. Soon Lucy finished her shower and put a towel around her body as she left the bathroom, she walked to put her sleepwear on when she noticed Erza sitting on the couch, eating a slice of strawberry cheesecake and wearing slightly revealing clothing.

"Erza!? When did you get here!?"

"I got here a while ago." Erza finished her slice and sat the plate aside. Lucy just sighed and put her sleepwear on.

"Mind if I stay the night here Lucy?"

"Aren't you the head girl of Fairy Hills?"

"Yeah I am. Maybe I could get you a free room at Fairy Hills after tonight?"

"Are you serious Erza? You could get me a room there?"

"Yup. You're an amazing friend and you deserve a nice place." Lucy had a wide smile and hugged Erza.

"I will miss this place though."

"Well you can make your room at Fairy Hills look like this apartment if you want." She just kept smiling.

"Thank you Erza. And I don't mind if you stay here for the night." Erza smiled and hugged Lucy back, requiping into pajamas once their hug ended. She got a spare blanket for Erza and layed down on her bed. However almost halfway through the night Erza sneaked into Lucy's bed to sleep beside her, just like she did at the Grand Magic Games. Erza felt comfortable next to Lucy and had a interest in the blonde Celestial Spirit mage, hoping that she had the same feelings she had for her, not knowing that her feelings were shared.