What's mine is yours

Title: What's mine is yours

By: ItReignsJustice-619

Rating: NC-17, sexual content, adult themes, language

Characters: Dean Ambrose x OC, Roman Reigns x OC

Summary: It once was just a stupid idea, a fantasy even. But how do things turn out when a fantasy becomes a reality? Dean, Karolina, Roman and Shannon definitely want to find out. – Two-shot to "Please protect me from injustice", "The eye of justice is always watching", "Will justice prevail?!", "Justice has been served", "The sweet taste of justice" and "Justice always wins".

Disclaimer: I do not know or own any of the people in this story who are not born of my imagination. The characters of the WWE superstars are based off of their TV personas. I actually use their gimmick names and not their real-life names as this seems to be easier for everyone to read.

...

I'm bahaaaack...kinda haha! Okay guys, you knew I couldn't stop writing about the lovely people of my so-called 'Justice series'.

So, in order to understand why I'm writing this, please check out chapter 2 of 'Justice always wins'. That'll explain a lot lol

Please note that this is just a WHAT IF scenario that didn't really happen in the story. I just had this idea stuck in my head for quite a while and was totally excited to write it. I know some people were interested in reading it as well, so here we go.

This is pure and utter smut. So if you can't deal with that, and if you don't want to see any 'partner swappings', then you'd better stop here :D

Ohh, and before I forget: this would of course take place before Karolina got pregnant with Siaki.

...

Here you can find the links to the original stories:

"Please protect me from injustice" ( s/9046424/1/Please-protect-me-from-injustice),

"The eye of justice is always watching" ( s/9483245/1/The-eye-of-justice-is-always-watching)

"Will justice prevail?!" ( s/9572393/1/Will-justice-prevail)

"Justice has been served" ( s/9856895/1/Justice-has-been-served)

"The sweet taste of justice" ( s/10139709/1/The-sweet-taste-of-justice) and "Justice always wins" (s/10274034/1/Justice-always-wins)

Thanks so much for the support you've given me for all the stories of this series. I hope you stick with me through this one as well ;-) You know I always give you my best :)

...

"You know your parents are the fucking best, right Roman?" Dean slurred, clinking his bottle of beer with the one of his Samoan friend, smiling at him happily.

"You're damn right they are," Roman replied with a chuckle, taking a huge gulp of the cold beverage before wrapping an arm around Karolina's shoulders, kissing her temple softly. "We should definitely do something crazy tonight. They don't take the kids for a sleepover too often."

"It sucks that Seth can't be here. Fuck this family get-together they're having in Iowa. We're his family,"Karo mumbled to herself, sipping on her Tequila Sunrise lazily. She really missed Seth tonight. Maybe the fact that she was totally shit-faced didn't help matters.

"Oh come on, stop whining," Shannon admonished, shoving Karo slightly while giggling before turning her attention to Roman. "But you're right, big man. We really should get wild tonight."

Being a WWE wrestler definitely had its benefits, allowing Roman, Karolina as well as Dean and Shannon to get a so-called VIP booth on a balcony of the club they were staying in that even gave them a perfect view down onto the dancing floor that was fully crowded that night.

"Hey Karo, remember the last time we were here?" Shannon shouted over the music, giggling when Karo looked back at her with a big grin on her face. How could she forget? They had one hell of a night back then. "We made a deal."

"A deal?" Roman asked curiously, looking back and forth between Shannon and Karo, the latter having a frown on her face as if she was thinking hard about something.

"Yeah, what deal?" Dean butted in, finishing his bottle of beer in one draught. God, was he thirsty tonight.

"You can't remember? Seriously?" Shannon asked Karo, completely ignoring the two men next to her.

"God, Shan, I'm glad I can remember my own fucking name right now," Karo slurred, placing her now empty glass onto the small table in front of the couch they were sitting on.

"Spill the beans, sweetheart. We're curious now," Roman groaned, trying to look deep into Shannon's eyes but he had trouble keeping them fully open due to all the alcohol he had already consumed.

Shannon looked at Karo for reassurance, but the German native only shrugged her shoulders unknowingly, absentmindedly rubbing up and down her husband's thigh.

"Well, fine, it seems that once again I need to be the one to take matters into my own hands," she said, sighing exaggeratedly. "So, Karo and I decided to swap partners one day."

Roman choked on his beer at how nonchalantly Shannon blurted this out, not sure if he had understood her correctly. Partner swap?

"What the fuck?" Dean more or less asked, no one in particular though. It was no secret to Shannon that he had once wanted to bang Karo, way before he knew that Roman was interested in her. But he never would have thought that their women would agree on swapping partners. He was astonished.

"Yeah, we somehow ended up talking about sex and your performances and came to the conclusion that we're very curious about our respective others. So we said, why not swap for a night?" Shannon replied, shrugging her shoulders innocently as if it was no big deal.

Roman looked down at Karo with a stern look on his face, the smile he was trying so hard to suppress now gracing his features when seeing that his wife was blushing. "Is that right, babygirl?"

Karo nervously waved at the waiter that was serving drinks to the booth next to them, desperately needing more alcohol in order to get out of this situation without dying of a heart attack.

"I'm talking to you, beautiful," Roman whispered into her ear, making her whole body shiver.

"I wouldn't mind fucking Karo, to be honest," Dean horned in, wiggling his eyebrows at Shannon when she giggled. That was what he loved about his girlfriend. She was so easy-going and open-minded sometimes. He just had no idea she was that open-minded that she would even agree on doing something like this. She probably wouldn't have accepted it with any unknown woman though, he was sure of that.

"Roman...," Karo said, trailing off. She had no idea what to say. Would Roman be upset? "It was just a stupid idea..."

"I kinda like the idea," he admitted, licking his bottom lip seductively. "We just have to come up with a few rules."

The last part of his sentence was directed at Shannon and Dean, knowing that they couldn't so easily get into bed with each other.

"No worries, I'm not gonna fuck her in the ass," Dean slurred, gasping when Shannon swatted his chest playfully.

"You'd better not, man," Roman said sternly, definitely not letting his best friend go that far. "I was talking about some general things. I mean, we need to make sure that this doesn't affect our relationships in any way. Not with our respective partners and we can't let this affect our friendship either. No strings attached, no guilt-trips. I don't ever want anybody to bring this up in any fight we might have in the future. This will definitely be a one-night-thing. Have I made myself clear?"

They all nodded their heads in silence, letting it sink in that they were really taking that big step.

"You're sure you wanna do it?" Karo asked Roman, a frown on her face.

"If you want to, then I want to as well. We're still young, Karolina. Let's enjoy this night before we go back to trying for a baby," Roman said, giving her a reassuring smile before turning back to Shannon and Dean. "Use of condoms is mandatory, ladies and gentlemen."

"Well, I don't have to wear one when she sucks my dick, right?" Dean asked curiously, smirking at his Samoan friend mischievously.

"Whatever," Roman replied, rolling his eyes. "It's a deal then? Everybody 100% okay with that?"

"Hell yeah," Dean and Shannon both shouted at the same time, making everybody burst out laughing.

"Alright, let's get going then," Roman announced, quickly standing up to let his friends know that he was ready to go now. Damn, he was fucking horny now.

...

"Weeeell, here we are," Karo babbled, giggling when Dean looked at her with a stupid grimace on his face. "You sure you even get this thing hard?"

She pointed at his crotch, doubting that he would get a boner after drinking that much beer.

"Well, it depends on how well you can suck me off, sweetheart," he said in a raspy voice, making her insides quiver with lust.

They had decided to go to Roman's and Karo's place while Shannon and Roman went to Dean's house, both women feeling more comfortable in their own bed with a partner they weren't used to.

"I'm the goddess of blowjobs," Karo teased, making her way over to him slowly, yelping when he grabbed her wrist and pulled her towards him, his lips almost touching hers.

"You are, aren't you?" he whispered, his lips now on hers slightly, letting her feel his breath on her skin. "Stop being so tense, princess. We don't want this to be awkward, do we?"

Karo swallowed hard, her heart pounding hard in her chest. She closed her eyes for a brief moment, trying to regulate her breathing but it was to no avail.

"It is awkward, Dean," she whispered back, breathing heavily when he wrapped his arms around her waist, his hands wandering down slowly until he placed them on her ass, squeezing softly.

"It's just sex, babe. I'm not gonna kill you," he reassured with a smile, knowing that Karo would be the one to have the biggest problem with this whole partner swapping thing, but he was sure that he would make her forget all about her concerns very soon.

He quickly spun her around, her back clashing with the wall behind her, making her yelp.

"Dean..." she said in astonishment, lowering her gaze when she sensed that he was working with his hands frantically, seeing how he was trying to unbuckle his belt desperately.

"Just to make sure that you know I'm not doing it the gentle way. I'm not gonna make love to you," he stated simply, air quoting the words 'make love'. "I'm gonna fuck your brains out, sweetheart. It's gonna get a little rough tonight."

Just hearing him talk to her like that made her panties dampen. She didn't expect him to be gentle with her. She didn't even want him to. All she wanted was Dean to give it to her good and she was sure he would do just that.

"Go down on your knees," he demanded after a minute when she didn't answer, chuckling when he saw how she looked at his erection wide-eyed, not having noticed that he had pulled down his jeans and boxers so that they were now dangling around his ankles. "Like what you see?"

Karo could only nod her head in approval, looking up at him with these big, beautiful blue eyes that reflected pure innocence. This alone made Dean even harder.

"Suck it, baby," he said hoarsely, taking his shaft into his right hand, stroking it slowly before slapping her still closed lips with its head. "Open up now."

Karo immediately did as she was told, slightly parting her lips, letting her tongue slide out, her piercing tracing his slit that was already leaking with pre-cum. He moaned out loud, still stroking himself while her tongue licked around the tip of his cock, making him a little impatient.

"Is that all you got?" he teased, looking down at her with lust-filled eyes, swallowing hard when she all of a sudden engulfed his erection completely, taking him fully into her mouth. She hummed quietly, the vibrations she was making driving him insane.

She never broke the eye contact, looking deep into his eyes while bobbing her head up and down fast. She moaned when she felt him grab her hair, forcing her onto him even harder.

"That's right. Let me fuck that pretty little mouth of yours," he groaned, the grip of his hand in her hair even tighter now, a hiss escaping his lips when he felt how he hit the back of her throat, the sounds of her slightly gagging turning him on even more although he knew he should be a little more gentle with her. "God...Karo..."

Both of his hands were keeping her head in place now, her back pressed against the wall so that she couldn't even move. He was thrusting into her mouth mercilessly, the feeling of his balls tightening stopping him just in time before exploding in her mouth.

"Fuck...," he panted, letting go of her head so that he could support himself on the wall with his hands, trying to get his breathing back to normal. "Shit...Karolina...I'm sorry."

He felt extremely guilty when he saw a few single tears escaping her eyes, frowning when she waved her hand, smiling at him before getting up.

"Don't. It's okay...these are just tears of not getting enough air," she shrugged it off, without needing him to tell her taking off her shirt. "I enjoyed it, Dean. No need to apologize."

He immediately felt better, relieved even. But he also couldn't even think about being guilty any longer when she kept undressing herself in front of him, her jeans quickly following her shirt that was in a pile on the floor, leaving her only in her bra and panties.

"Somebody seems to be a little impatient, huh?" he asked with a smirk on his face, eventually stepping out of his jeans and boxers, quickly throwing his shirt over his head, leaving him completely naked in front of her.

"You bet your sweet ass I'm impatient. I want that dick now, Ambrose," she replied sassily, the awkwardness finally gone after sucking him off a few minutes ago.

"Well, you've gotta have a little more patience, princess. I'm not done with you yet," he retorted, raising both of his eyebrows when she very self-confidently took off her underwear, surprising him with her attitude as Roman always told him how self-conscious she was of her body, especially after the pregnancy. The things alcohol did to you... "Get on the bed now...don't make me tell you twice."

She loved this dominant side of Dean. Roman sometimes acted like that as well, but with Dean it was so much more different. It was natural to him, it simply was in his nature. She loved being ordered around by him.

She once again did as she was told, crawling onto the bed seductively, letting her hips sway from one side to the other, her round ass in full display for him.

"On your back now," he demanded when she reached the middle of the bed, not wasting any time by getting right next to her, propping himself up on one of his elbows, letting his eyes wander all over her body. "How I have longed to touch those tits."

His still free hand moved upwards slowly, cupping one of her big breasts tightly, squeezing and kneading it, making her moan out loud. She had her eyes closed now, enjoying the way he was touching her, wanting more of him. "Suck them...I want your tongue on them, Dean."

Dean had hoped she would say that, his year-long fantasy finally coming true. He had no idea what it was about Karo's boobs but he had always craved them. It's not that he didn't like Shannon's, no, his woman had perfect tits, but Karo's had always been fascinating him.

He leaned down a little, his mouth immediately attacking her left nipple, engulfing it. He let his tongue run around her sensitive skin, turning it to a hard nub, begging for him to suck it in between his lips.

"Fuck yes," she moaned, arching her back when Dean started rubbing her other nipple in between his thumb and index finger, making it even harder.

He alternated between licking and sucking on her nipples, first paying attention to her left and then her right breast, the moans that were escaping her lips being music to his ears. God, he really wanted her now.

"Are you ready for me, princess?" he asked after letting her right nipple go with a loud, wet pop, smirking up at her mischievously before moving to be next to her again.

He looked at her surprised when she took his free hand into hers, guiding it over her breasts, to her stomach, only to end up between her legs. "How about you find out yourself?"

Dean raised a curious eyebrow at her when she let go of his hand, silently letting him know that she wanted him to touch the most intimate of her body.

And so he did.

"Jeez, girl...you're dripping wet," he rasped out when he touched her for the very first time, his index and middle finger rubbing her clit in circles slowly. If her clit was that wet already, how much wetter would she be even deeper down there?

Karo looked deep into his eyes when his hand slowly moved even lower, running a few fingers along her slit, moving them up and down agonizingly slow before all of a sudden pumping two of them into her, making her scream in pleasure.

"Shit...Dean...oh god," she panted, loving the smacking sounds that came from the friction of Dean's fingers pumping into her dripping wetness.

He slightly curled his fingers inside of her, knowing that he found her g-spot right away when she once again arched her back, even holding her breath for a few seconds.

"Hmm, you like that, don't you? You're so wet, baby," he whispered into her ear, retreating his index and middle finger from her pussy, pumping into her once more, very slowly taking them out again so that he could get them as wet as he could.

Karo watched in awe as he raised his hand, holding it just mere inches away from her face, scissoring his fingers to show her how her wetness was getting stringy in between them.

"Look at that...look at how fucking wet you are," he said in a deep voice, smirking when she looked at him wide-eyed as he was moving his hand towards her mouth. "Open up. I want you to taste yourself."

She reluctantly parted her lips, letting Dean stick his fingers into her mouth, letting her taste herself.

"Lick them clean, baby...yeah...just like that," he encouraged her, feeling her tongue swirl around her fingers.

He all of a sudden kissed her after retreating his fingers, tasting her juices on her tongue, this being the first time they kissed each other. She was completely taken aback.

He moaned into her mouth before moving swiftly so that he was now hovering over her, his erection aching painfully. He had to have her now and he couldn't wait any longer.

"Dean...we need to use a condom," she stopped him breathlessly when he spread her legs wide apart, moving in between them, his dick almost touching her pussy.

"Fuck...I almost forget...damn protection," he hissed, moving back to get his wallet out of his jeans, quickly finding what he was looking for.

He impatiently ripped the foil packet open, throwing the wrapper away aimlessly so that he could cover himself as fast as possible. He was so horny that he thought he was about to explode.

"You ready for me, sweetheart?" he asked, not really expecting her to answer since he would fuck her anyways.

As soon as she nodded her head, he entered her in one swift movement, completely filling her to the hilt. They moaned out in unison, his penetration giving them both a feeling of relief.

"Fuck...you're so tight," he groaned, holding still for a few brief moments as he didn't want to cum right away.

He had already been close when she was sucking him off earlier that night.

"Move," she pleaded, looking up at him with dark eyes. Dark from lust.

"What do you want, babe? Tell me what you want me to do," he encouraged her, knowing from Roman that she had a hard time expression herself when it came to the bedroom. "Don't blush. Just tell me..."

"I want you to fuck me, Dean. Fuck this pussy," she said through gritted teeth, closing her eyes in pleasure when he did just that, thrusting into her forcefully, a small yelp escaping her lips when he grabbed her throat with his right hand, putting slight pressure on it but not enough to choke her.

He wouldn't even start off slowly as they both didn't need a long-ass lovemaking session. All they wanted was a release, a good fucking. So it was only natural for him to speed up minute by minute, his balls slapping against her ass, her ever-growing wetness making it easy for him to slide in and out of her.

"You feel so fucking good, Karolina. God yes," he groaned, in one quick movement grabbing her ass, moving them around so that she was now straddling his lap, never losing the connection between them. The yelp that came from her mouth made him smirk.

"Come on, baby. Ride me...ride this dick," he encouraged her, slapping her ass forcefully while she let her hips rotate, taking him even deeper.

"Fuck yes...slap that ass," she panted, remembering that fantasy she always had of Dean spanking her.

"Ohh yes, you like that...you like it when I spank you, you dirty slut," he hissed, slapping her over and over again, spurring her on to go even faster. "Press your tits together...come on..."

She didn't even question him, grabbing both of her breasts and squeezing them together, even rubbing her own nipples. She watched him as he buried his head in between her boobs, letting his tongue slide over her nipples once in a while, groaning when he felt the softness of her skin on his.

"Dean...," she trailed off, bouncing up and down on him frantically now. "I'm about to cum."

"Then let go...let go, Karo. Cum all over this dick," he urged her, gripping her hips tightly so that he could thrust up into her. "I'm right behind you...come on."

The moment he felt her walls tighten around his cock, he completely lost it. It took him only a few more thrusts until he erupted into the condom, spurt after spurt of his seed shooting out of him as she milked him for all he was worth.

He immediately collapsed back onto the mattress, his hands still on her hips. He looked down at how they were still connected to each other, loving how her juices were flowing out of her, coating his condom-covered dick and running down her thighs. But as much as he loved it, it was over now.

"Okay sweetheart, let me get that condom off of me," he said, silently asking her to get off of him without sounding too harsh.

She only nodded her head in understanding and cautiously climbed off of him, holding his shaft so that she wouldn't take the filled condom with her. She fell back onto the bed, watching him get rid of the rubber, throwing it into a trash can that was next to the bed.

"Don't expect me to cuddle with you now, princess," he quickly said when he felt her eyes on him. "I'm not that kind of guy. Especially not with a one night stand."

Without waiting for her to answer, he searched for his clothes, dressing himself in an uncomfortable silence.

"You ok?" he asked when he buckled his belt, sitting down on the edge of the bed to tie his shoes. "You're very quiet."

"I am. I had a mind-blowing orgasm and feel completely satisfied," she replied, taking one of the blankets to cover herself up. "It's still pretty awkward though."

He chuckled when she giggled, turning around to face her when he was done with his shoes.

"It was amazing, Karo. And I really enjoyed myself. But cuddling would make this even more awkward now...so, let's just do what we said we would do and let this be what it is. Just sex, no strings attached," he explained, bending down to grab her clothes and hand them to her.

"What do you think we should do now?" she asked, throwing a shirt over her head, not even caring about putting on her bra again.

"I'm gonna text Ro, telling him that we're done. As soon as he texts back, I'll make my way over to the house. I'm kinda hungry though...how about a sandwich?" he asked, shaking his head in amusement when Karo giggled.

"You're such a hungry man," she commented, putting on her jeans.

"Yeah...I always am. It really is a shame I didn't eat you out, sweetheart."

And with that, he slapped her jeans-covered ass hard, slipping out of the bedroom and making his way down to the kitchen.

That was one hell of a night.

…

A/N: Part 2 coming soon.