Author's notes:

This story is a sequel to The Creepy Costume Exploration, and it's not necessarily an obligation to read it before this one, but it would make things clearer.

It's going to be a short one though, just a few chapters.

I hope you enjoy it!

I own nothing.

Chapter 1

Her fingers met his on the top of his lap, gingerly intertwining, her thumb playing with his. Amy smiled at him, in his gorgeous striped black and white suit. He returned the smile to her, with his fake mustache itching on his face every time his facial muscles moved.

"Amy, the light is green."

"Oh, sorry." At the same time the car behind them honked its horn loudly and she started moving the car again. The way from his apartment to Raj's building was not so long and soon they arrived at the party. Amy was pretty anxious about how the gang would react to her costume. She knew the effect it had on Sheldon.

When she parked the car, Sheldon grabbed her hand and pulled her for a kiss. "You look gorgeous, ya know?" Amy blushing was not hard to notice, even behind all the white pancake makeup she was wearing. She gave him a small peck on the lips and she reached to open the door when Sheldon stopped her, holding her arm.

"Wait, let me do it properly." He stepped out of the car and moved to the driver's side, opened the door and offered his hand to her, bending slightly. "Ma'am?"

Amy placed her hand on the top of his, and after she stepped out he brought it to his mouth, kissing her knuckles. He offered his folded arm to her, which she grabbed immediately, with a huge smile on her face. "Wow, you've been such a gentleman today, Sheldon!"

"Don't you mean Gomez?" He blinked an eye to her, walking them to the entrance.

The floor was decorated with candles, guiding the guests to the pool area, where the party was being held. They could hear the loud music playing on the background, and as they approached the area they saw a Nightcrawler waving at them.

"Amy, I can't believe my eyes! You look amazing!"

"Thank you, Rajesh!" She accepted his hug, feeling a tug in her hand from her jealous boyfriend. "What is your costume about, by the way?"

"Amy! I can't believe you don't remember the movie we watched two weeks ago!"

"Oh, sorry, I remember the movie, but I can't remember all the characters, there were so many!"

Raj laughed, and patiently explained to Amy who his character was. He gave each of them a bracelet with a number in it. "This is for the costume contest. There will be a voting and we will have three different rewards: the creepiest costume, the best couple's costume and the most creative one."

They both placed the bracelets on their wrists, and Raj opened the black curtains behind him to allow them to enter the party. "Enjoy yourselves!"

Raj's party was planned to the smallest detail. All the tables were decorated with candles on the top of frightening skulls, laying on spider web crochet tablecloths. The pool was covered with floating jack o'lanterns, giving the water an orange hue. The deck had spiders, bats and small ghost figures hanging from the pergola, and the floor was covered with natural dry foliage.

In a corner with big stones being used as seats, a Joker and a Harley Quinn were resting, talking to a gorgeous Scarlet Witch. Sheldon and Amy recognized a familiar Zombie Princess Leia and a Zombie Han Solo slow dancing among other couples.

"How long has it been since we've waltzed?"

"Oh, Gomez... hours." Amy blinked at him, and they joined the couples on the dance floor. Sheldon held her close, with his arms on the small of her back, while hers enlaced his neck. She rested her head on his chest, while they danced slowly to the song.

I don't care if it hurts, I wanna have control

I wanna a perfect body, I want a perfect soul

Sheldon smiled at the lyrics, pulling Amy even closer to him. He gave her a small peck on her forehead, feeling her arms tighten around his neck.

I want you to notice when I'm not around

So fucking special, I wish I was special

I'm a creep

I'm a weirdo

What the hell am I doing here?

I don't belong here

Amy lifted her head and stared at Sheldon's eyes. The place was dark enough for them to have their own privacy, and she felt brave and brought his lips to meet hers, in a passionate kiss. They stopped dancing as their mouths were pressed against each other. Sheldon broke the kiss and after taking a deep breath he leaned again to kiss her. This time their tongues found each other, in their own waltz.

They didn't notice the Zombie Star Wars couple staring at them with mouths agape. "Am I dreaming, Leonard?" Penny whispered to him, still in shock.

"No, that's quite a real Shamy kiss."

"Wow, that's a really hot one."

"You think that's hot? You don't know what they've been doing in the bedroom."

"WHAAAAAAT?"

Penny shouted so loud that Sheldon and Amy broke their kiss and turned to her direction. The other couples also stopped dancing and looked at her. Penny realized what she had just done and apologized, leading Leonard out of the dance floor. Sheldon and Amy just shrugged, and started dancing again.

"Why didn't you tell me anything before, Leonard?"

"Well, I'm not really sure about what exactly they were doing, and Sheldon scolded me for knocking on his bedroom's door last Saturday."

"Was Amy there with him?"

"I'm pretty sure she was, I saw her purse in the living room when I arrived with the pizzas, but I didn't see her at all. After that he shooed me from the apartment and I took the pizzas to your place, so..."

"Oh my God! I can't believe you didn't say anything then!"

"What for? Did you want to receive a strike and a class?"

"No..."

"Well, be glad I saved you from a good one."

Penny looked at the couple on the dance floor, dancing so close to each other. She was disappointed that Amy didn't mention anything during the last girls night! She wondered if Bernie talked to her about it, and grabbed Leonard's hand again and went to the other side of the party, near the pool, to find the little Harley Quinn having an argument with the mini Joker.

"Hey guys, what's up?"

"This putz here ruined my makeup!"

"What, am I now prohibited to make out with my wife in a party?"

"Well, I don't know about you, but there's a quirky Gomez sucking Morticia's breath on the dance floor!" Penny pointed to the couple, giggling.

"WOW! Is that Amy?" Howard's eyes popped out in her direction, until he felt Bernie's elbow hitting his ribs.

"She really looks incredible." A Jack Skellington stared at them too, taking a sip from his red punch. "Sheldon is a lucky guy."

"Do you think they are doing it?"

"Howie! Don't be so indiscreet!"

"Well, I bet fifty bucks they are!" Leonard smirked, taking his wallet out of his pocket.

"Wait dude, do you know anything we don't?"

"Maybe one or two things."

"Well, I'm pretty sure I'm gonna lose this, but I bet they hadn't done anything yet."

"Howie, since when you can go betting money without asking me?"

"Come on, Bernie, it's just a little bet for fun!"

The couple started arguing again, and Stuart decided to leave the group and stuff his face in the candy table. They just stopped when Penny announced that Sheldon and Amy were approaching the group.

"Amy, you look fantastic as Morticia! That dress is impressive!" Bernie whistled and gestured to take her hand and spin her around.

"Of course she looks impressive, we rehearsed the costume preparation three times!"

"Costume rehearsal, is that how it's called nowadays?" Howard smirked, giving Leonard a light nudge on his arm.

Sheldon stared at him. "What do you mean?" His eyes feared Howard's answer. How could he know anything?

"Well, well, it's pretty obvious you're doing the deed, isn't it?"

Amy's eyes widened, she released Sheldon's hand and ran away from the group. He turned to catch her again, but she was already far. "Great, you always have to say something insensitive in front of Amy, right Howard?" And he turned to go after her, but it was too late. Amy had stumbled in her own dress losing her balance and fell on the pool, screaming right before her body reached the water.

"AMY!" Sheldon screamed, and all the gang approached the pool as he ran and jumped to help her. He panicked when he realized he didn't really know how to swim in a real pool, but as he grabbed her by the waist and lifted her he realized the pool was not so deep, in fact it was less deep than his own height. With his head off the water, he calmed down and hugged Amy.

"Are you alright?"

She nodded, but her body was shaking a little and her costume was ruined.

"I'm sorry, Sheldon, I ruined our costumes!"

"Shhhh, you didn't ruin anything." He held her closer, until he saw Leonard's hand offering to help them out of the pool.

"We're all sorry, buddy, we shouldn't have said anything. Let me help you."

He accepted his help, but first he raised Amy in the water and placed her sitting on the border of the pool. When he finally was out of it, he helped Amy stand and reassured she was fine. Then he turned to Wolowitz and yelled at him. "That's all your fault!"

"Sorry, Sheldon, I didn't know that Amy would react so badly!"

"You should be!"

"How would I've known, it was not the first time I ask you that, and I also bet with Leonard that you haven't done anything!"

"You two are betting over my private life with Amy?" Sheldon's anger was evident in his face. Howard's Joker smile on his face made it even worse. He closed his fist tight and punched his smile out of his face. The tiny man fell on the floor, and Bernie knee beside him to help his nose to stop bleeding.

"Sheldon, you're overreacting about this, it was just a stupid joke, let go!" Penny yelled at him, trying to fix things.

"Maybe it's stupid for you, whose sex life is in the public domain!"

Nightcrawler and Scarlet Witch approached the group to calm things down.

"Hey, Sheldon, relax, ok? Why don't you take Amy to the restroom and the two of you get dry?" He pointed to the restroom sign on their right.

"I left a pile of towels there just in case someone decided to jump into the pool... Help yourselves." Emily said.

Sheldon took Amy's hand and dragged her with him.

"Come on, Amy, we'd better get dry before these greedy perverts ask if we're having public wet sex in a public restroom!"

... to be continued.

BTW: I don't own the lyrics to the song.