(The next day, Andy is talking to Phoebe before her punishment)

Andy: Why did you get drunk?

Phoebe: I was missing Prue a lot and I we'll the pain was too much. Also I wasn't planning on drinking, (crying) but then the pain of losing Prue was just too much to bear. I'm so sorry Daddy. (Phoebe is now bawling because she is sorry and because she misses her sissy so much)

Andy: (is shocked by the fact that Phoebe called him daddy, but he realizes that she needs comfort not a punishment. He pulls Phoebe in a hug and rocks her back and forth) Shh Pheebs, it'll be ok because Prue will always be with you in spirit and in your heart. I know how much you love her, because I have felt your love and when you love, you love with your whole heart. I know you can cope with Prue being gone because you are the strongest girl I know.

Phoebe: (calms her sobs to hiccups) Everyone tells be that I am strong, but how can I be strong when I am in so much pain. Some days I just want to die. I almost killed myself before, but I heard Prue's voice and she told me not to. I was at that bridge that she took the picture of and...(starts crying again because she regrets thinking about jumping)... I was thinking of jumping. I'm so sorry daddy. I should have even thought about that.

Andy: Pheebs, it's ok to think of committing suicide when you lose someone you love as long as you doing actually do it. I thought about killing myself numerous times, but I didn't because you, Piper, Paige, Charlotte and Penny mean everything to me. I love you.

Phoebe: (crying) I love you too daddy

Andy: Pheebs, does it comfort you to call me daddy or do you want to?

Phoebe: (crying) I want to daddy. I have something that I regret, that I told Prue and I wish I could tell her it wasn't true. After I found my birth mom I told Prue I didn't want to live at the manor anymore because I wanted to live with my mom and mot someone who is like a mom. Which wasn't true, Prue was at much my mom as my birth mom. I used to follow Prue everywhere when I was little and then I started to drift away. When Patty died, Prue was the first one I called mommy, because she looked just like Patty, whom I thought was my mom.

Andy: She knows, it's ok you can forgive yourself now. It's ok, it may have hurt her feelings when you told her that but she still loves you. You know the doctor told me that Prue said she was hanging on to the last strand of life so she could say goodbye to you and Piper.

Phoebe: (crying) I didn't know that. (Pauses because she remember the real reason Andy came in her room) Daddy, are you still going to punish me?

Andy: No, Pheebs not this time. You weren't thinking straight when you took that first drink, because you never really dealt with losing Prue.

Phoebe: (sniffling) Thanks for talking with me, Daddy. I love you

Andy: You're welcome and I love you too Pheebs