Hi all, thanks so much for all the support I have had with this fanfiction. I know my chapters are short and I want to make them longer, I just wanted to update fast for you all. Thank you to tobyequalshottness and caitycaites for your reviews and I'm glad you two are liking the idea. This story won't have Spencer pregnant sorry as I like the romance side for this idea. :)

Chapter 2:

After Toby left, Spencer could finally let out her tears. As she curled up in a ball in the chair Toby had made her when they first broke up she just wanted to go to him and hug him, have it all be okay. But she knew this was for the best and that they needed to be apart for now. Suddenly, mid-thought her phone rang, it was Emily.

"Spencer, what is this I hear about you breaking up with Toby, isn't this what you wanted, him back?"

"Of course, I wanted him back but this is best for now Em…"

"Best for now! Spencer are you crazy, you and Toby have been through so much, why are you stopping now?" Emily pleaded.

"He abandoned me when I needed him."

"Can't you forgive him for that Spencer, he did it to try to help you and your parents stopped him from being near you so he tried to help you in another way."

"Yes and I do forgive him, it's just with this new, stronger A and Alison back, it would be too hard for us now. I don't want him to get hurt." Spencer had tears forming in her eyes again.

"Spencer he's hurting right now, together you can get through all this."

"No, sure he's hurting now but if I stayed with him he will just hurt more in the future and I don't want that for him. He deserves better and he deserves someone who will be open with him."

"Did you tell him any of this?"

"Of course not, it's easier this way."

"Maybe you should let him choose that, I'm coming over and I'm bringing the girls with me, we will have a night together again to help each other through everything. Hopefully Aria can make it but she may just want to stay with Ezra tonight."

"Thanks Em, I'll see you soon."

With that the girls hung up and Spencer got ready for their sleepover.

Meanwhile at Toby's Loft

"What do you mean she just broke up with you?" Caleb asked.

"She said that she can't be with me because I left when she needed me most and I feel terrible. Her parents wouldn't let me be there for her so I thought if I got Melissa to come back it might help her."

"Maybe just give her some time and she'll forgive you. If not, I'll get Hanna onto her."

"Yeah, I guess and Hanna is a good persuader."

"Don't worry man; you'll have her in your arms again soon." Caleb comforted.