The Good Girl
Chapter 28: The Right Choice
Here it is – the last and final chapter of the Good Girl. It has truly been a privilege to write for you and you don't realize how much everyone's follows, favorites, and reviews have truly meant to me. Look for my next story, tentatively called "My Prerogative" coming soon – starring Roman with a little bit of Dean! Again, many thanks!
Natalie took a deep breath and walked into his hotel room, with Jon shutting the door and walking behind her.
"I thought you said what all you had to say last night." Jon said in a sort of angry voice. She couldn't blame him – she told him to leave, right after he told her his feelings – the same thing he had done to her, months earlier.
"I asked you to leave because I needed to think."
"Think about what?"
"What you said." Natalie took a deep breath, she promised herself she wasn't going to cry. "I have waited for so long to hear you say those words."
"And then you asked me to leave."
"Damnit, J, lemme finish. I asked you to leave because I needed to catch a flight. I needed to tell Stu."
"You had to tell Stu what?"
"It was over." Natalie smiled at him, and the smile creeped onto Jon's face. "I love you, Jon."
"I love you, too." Jon said as he came over and kissed her passionately.
"I have waited so long for this." Natalie exclaimed. "You were only supposed to be a one night stand."
"And I told you, sleeping with me would change your life."
"God did it ever." Natalie laughed and then turned it seriously, with her eyes filled with lust and love. "Make love to me, J."
Those five words was all it took. Jon put his hands in Natalie's face and kissed her passionately. He picked her up bridal-style and carried her over to his bed. He stripped off her shirt and her bra. He kissed down her throat and nipped at her earlobe, which elicited moans from his girl.
"God, J. Please." Natalie arched her back.
"Nah." Jon smirked. "We have plenty of time before the house show." He continued his oral attack on Natalie, kissing down to her chest. He rolled her left nipple with his tongue and pinched the other one with his skilled hand. He switched breasts and he could tell that Natalie was beyond excited. He dove his mouth lower, pecking down her abdomen, down her navel and started to tease her thigh, placing short kisses on her thigh. He slid a finger down her slit and put his finger in between her lips and could tell she was excited. He pulled out his wet finger and licked it clean, which almost sent Natalie already over the edge.
"Fuck, Nat. You still taste incredible."
His mouth finally found her clit and Natalie had to clench the sheets. This feeling was incredible, and she had truly missed it. His mouth continued to nip, lick and suck on her clit until he knew she was ready to orgasm. He abruptly stopped.
"I'm not letting you finish yet, babe." Jon smirked and stood up, pulling down his jeans and boxers, letting his hard dick spring free. He quickly ripped open a condom and slid it on. Jon started nipping at her earlobe again, which he knew was one of her spots. "God, I've dreamt about this."
He inserted two fingers inside of her, and knew she was ready. Quickly, he thrust himself into her, and instead of going rough and aggressive (which he usually did), he took his time thrusting in and out of her. Natalie met his thrusts, thrust for thrust. This was slow, steady, and gentle. Eventually his anticipation took over, and he began going faster and faster. Both of their moans were filling the room; both of them were ready to go over the edge. One last hard thrust triggered Natalie's loud, screaming orgasm which rippled over and affected Jon's orgasm. Natalie was in heaven, or at least that's what it felt like.
Jon collapsed on top of Natalie. Once the both of them collected their breaths, Jon slid out of Natalie and laid beside her. He noticed she was crying a little.
"I didn't hurt you, did I?" Suddenly worried that he might have been too rough.
"No." Natalie wiped her tears. "I never thought I'd feel you like that again. I never thought we'd be here. These are just happy, extremely satisfied tears."
"Thank God. I thought I hurt you." Jon said, relieved.
"But there is one thing…" Natalie smirked.
"What's that, Nat?"
"I think you need some more practice." Natalie smirked and kissed him on the nose.
"Shall you join me in the shower?" Jon sat up and took her hand. Natalie immediately grabbed it and headed towards the bathroom.
Six Months Later..
Jon was a little nervous, tonight was a big night for him and Natalie. It was their six-month anniversary and he had planned for it to be something special, even though Natalie was content just laying around. He picked out a special red dress and some new heels and left it in a special box, in their hotel room with special instructions.
Natalie was at the gym with the girls when she headed back to the hotel room. They were off tonight and Natalie knew that Jon was planning something special. She arrived back at the hotel room. She noticed a large red box sitting on their bed, with her name on it.
Hope you remember this dress! I know I sure do. Meet me down at the ballroom at 7pm.
J
Natalie opened up the dress box and it was the exact same dress that she wore to the first Hall of Fame ceremony, when it was the early stages of their relationship.
"How did he get this?" Natalie whispered to herself. Natalie jumped in the shower and got ready, doing her hair and makeup. By that time, it was 6:50 and she headed down to the ballroom, where she walked in and saw Jon dressed in a black button-up and black slacks.
"Wow. Who's the sexy guy?" Natalie kissed him, admiring him dressed up which doesn't occur too often.
"Wow, that dress looks even more incredible now than what it did then. This dress took my breath away when I first saw you in it."
"I picked it out just for you that night. Something red, and something sexy."
"I still love it."
"Do you remember this ballroom?"
Natalie looked around at the ballroom and the atmosphere. It all clicked.
"This was the Dance." Jon smiled and nodded his head. "Where I knew I made the biggest mistake of my life."
Jon cued the sound guy and a song started playing. "Dance with me."
"You don't dance."
"I do now."
I'll never settle down, I don't dance, But here I am Love's never come my way, No, I don't dance, but here I am Ooh I don't dance, but here I am I don't dance, but here I am Oh, Oooh…
That's what I always thought
Yeah, I was that kind of man,
just ask anyone
Spinning you around and around in circles
It Ain't my style, but I don't care
I'd do anything with you anywhere
Yes, you got me in the palm of your hand
Cause, I don't dance
I've never been this far
Cause you took these two left feet
And waltzed away with my heart
Spinning you around and around in circles
It ain't my style, but I don't care
I'd do anything with you anywhere
Yes, you got me in the palm of your hand, girl
Cause, I don't dance
Ohhh
I don't dance
Spinning you around and around in circles
It ain't my style, but I don't care
I'd do anything with you anywhere
Spinning you around and around in circles
It ain't my style, but I don't care
I'd do anything with you anywhere
Yeah, you got me in the palm of your hand, girl
Cause, I don't dance
No..
"Jon Good, being a little country?" Natalie said wiping the tears from her eyes. "That song was beautiful."
"I thought it fit the situation. I got you two gifts, let me go get them." Jon broke their hold and walked over and grabbed two small boxes. "Open this one first." Jon said handing her the larger box. She ripped open the bow and opened the box; when she opened it, it had a group of papers and a key. Natalie covered her mouth in excitement.
"This is my dream house. How did you know?"
"I talked to the girls." Natalie laughed, he wasn't known to be one to talk to the Divas. "And it's..?"
"Ours." Natalie smiled and kissed him. "J, this is the best. Thank you so much, I have dreamt of this house."
He handed her the next box, which looked like a ring box. She opened it and took out a one-carat promise ring.
"I don't want you to be disappointed." Jon said noticing the look on her face.
"I'm not."
"First off, I'm not proposing here where Stu did. So unoriginal." Natalie laughed at the expression on Jon's face.
"And, I'm waiting for the perfect moment. I started this thing with you because I thought it was going to be a challenge – a quick fuck and be done with you. Clearly, I can't get you out of my head, my heart or my system. You've taught me so many things about myself but most importantly, you've taught me about love. When you first told me you loved me, I was scared. Not only because at that time, I was in love with you and I didn't know what I was feeling, but more importantly, it's a feeling I had never experienced from something, or someone other than wrestling. God, you are absolutely incredible and I really don't know what I did to deserve you, but I promise, with this ring.." Jon stopped and slid the ring on her finger. "I am going to do whatever it takes to keep you, whether that means losing my shirt when I'm wrestling in the ring, letting you watch me sleep when inside I'm awake or showing how much I love you every single day. I hope you made the right choice when you picked me, and I hope to make you never regret that decision. I love you."
Natalie was blown away by his speech and she was in tears. "J, that's the most romantic thing anyone has ever said to me. I would never regret the decision because I never had to make one – when you told me you were in love with me, it was already over. I have waited for so long to hear you say those words to me and when you did, it was one of the best moments of my life. I love you too, J and please try harder losing your shirt in the ring." Natalie smiled as Jon kissed her again.
And the two of them lived happily ever after. The End.
A/N: There you have it! I hope it was worth it and I hope you enjoyed it! The song lyrics were from Lee Brice, "I Don't Dance," heard it in the car one day and knew it was perfect for this story! Again, thank you all again for everything and keep looking out for my new story – My Prerogative.