To echo others, I've thoroughly enjoyed all of your stories (frantic and original), but it would be wonderful if you could just wrap this amazing adventure up with a brief outline of where the story would have gone. Even just who Harry is! Regardless, thank you for sharing your writing. When life isn't sunshine and rainbows books and great can fix like your make everything ok.

I’ve had “Crimson” favorited for the longest time but couldn’t remember ever reading through the whole fic so I did so this past week. In four days. Or less.

Though it confused the hell out of me at some points, I don’t think I’ve ever read a more comprehensible AU fic. You left no loose ends and somehow managed to make sense of everything by the end of that fic. I knew that you had written a sequel but when I came upon this fic to see that there were only 7 chapters, I knew that it was left unfinished.

Though disappointed, I quickly consumed these 40k words in mere hours. I know that real life probably caught up with you and either left you with no muse or no time to finish this fic but I’d love nothing more than to know just how you were going to finish this series. A mere summary of what you had planned in your head would make me the happiest person.

I’ve read most of your OUAT fics but this series is certainly my favorite out of all of them. I hope you revisit this verse one day in the future but if not, thank you so much for taking the time to write these fics.

Well I just spent the last couple weeks tearing my way through Crimson and then went straight onto Scarlet without noticing the story was unfinished. It is a really fantastic action packed story and I love how intense these Killian and Emma versions are. Killian's unending internal fight to not turn back into Hook is riveting. I was really looking forward to seeing how Emma would give him his hand back. Please take up this story again.

Nooooo! I'm all into this and it's not finished! I don't suppose it will be since it's been a few years:(

If you're still reading feedback, count mine in with countless others in begging you to finish this one!

is there a sequel for this story?

Holy Shit! I just discovered your writing and I am obsessed! Please tell me you're not giving up on this story. I am dying to know what happens next, love love love this plot line. So unique and different, cannot wait to read what's next!

Oh my gosh, I have yet to submit a review for Crimson, which I absolutely LOVED by the way, but this continuation with Scarlet just keeps getting better and better! All the different nods and integration of so many characters and stories has been amazing, you are such a talented writer! And this last chapter had me not only squeeing about the OUAT reference scene, but also the potential of more piratey action cross-overs! I share the sentiments of many reviewers wondering if/when this story may be picked back up again. It's been such an amazing journey that I'm hoping to not have to leave this amazing universe you've created so abruptly. Thank you so much for sharing your wonderful writing with us, and again I hope to be reading more of Scarlet in the future!

I seriously just spent an entire day reading Crimson and then Scarlet; these stories are so incredibly amazing, I just couldn't stop reading. You're an amazing writer. I hope you eventually return to Scarlet, because after becoming immersed in this world, I really want to know where the story goes!

Ahhh! This story is stupendous! Who is the other ship? Who is Harry, is it David Jr all grown up some how or maybe Henry? Where is Liam I so want him to stay alive. Poor Killian always getting the shaft. Damn Cora. I love your stories and Crimson and this are by far my favorites. I wish you would finish this, I feel like I have a hole in my chest without knowing what happens.
I love your writings and I hope you continue, you are quite clearly a genius.
Cheers

Just read all of Crimson and Scarlet. Hope you continue this, as I love your writing style, and a plot that always keeps me on my toes.

Loving the sequel so far! You have to have to must must must update!

I religiously check this story and your tumblr for updates! I hope your muse returns soon, because I desperately miss Scarlet and would love to have it back in my life! :D

Bloody update will you!? I am fucking tired of waiting, darling.

When you first mentioned Crane I smirked a little and wondered if that was a Sleepy Hollow reference. Then I read further and I couldn't contain my laughter. Working that allusion into a Once Upon a Time lit me up from the inside. A wonderful little Easter egg and still appropriate to the story line.

Liam showing up at the end, however, just near knocked the wind out of me. It was only in the briefest of glimpses of the dark memory haunting him and it not being possible that I wondered, fleetingly, if it was his brother since that was about as "impossible" as I could come up with save perhaps his father. But still. To actually hear/see/read it. My mind is still reeling. Of course, that could also be attributed to the late hour as well, I suppose. Either way. Nice twist.

I just wish he would have called Emma. Bah.

Hey we're missing you here! I hope you update soon!