| Reviews for Whether Cheerful Or Somber |
|---|
EvelynWn chapter 1 . 1/26/2015 Favorited solely for the Mike Stamford chapter, not that the others aren't good, but that one was great. |
Fudge7000 chapter 4 . 12/30/2013 Lovely final chapter, very good characterisation! |
HarnGin chapter 4 . 12/27/2013 Merry Christmas, Happy New Year, and thank you so much! |
guest chapter 4 . 12/26/2013 I just stumbled upon this, so I apologize that I haven't reviewed each chapter individually. Great stories! I loved the last one the best. Thanks! |
NeverMessWithTeddyBears chapter 4 . 12/25/2013 Thank you for another marvellous story! Merry Christmas, sweetie. :) |
brothermine chapter 4 . 12/24/2013 aww that was sweet! Have a wonderful Christmas! |
EmporerFabulous chapter 3 . 12/18/2013 A dark Christmas story is always welcome and a truly good one is a rare find. Thank you for giving me something deeper to think about then the gifts I need to buy. Happy Christmas and many more great stories. Andrea |
Olympus97 chapter 3 . 12/17/2013 More about the change in Sherlock! Please? |
brothermine chapter 3 . 12/17/2013 I love this, you are a very talented writer! Looking forward to the next chapter! |
HarnGin chapter 2 . 12/10/2013 I did like. It brought Mike into Sherlock's life in a believable way and still kept to your theme. Good job. |
Fudge7000 chapter 1 . 12/5/2013 I do love a good Donavan story, especially post Reichenbach, am very intrigued how Moffat etc will do her part in series 3... Hopefully somewhat like your Sally, I think she would regret being part of what led to his suicide. Am looking forwards to further chapters! |
EmporerFabulous chapter 1 . 12/5/2013 I have wanted to see a Sally and Sherlock story for so long, this was just perfect. Love it immensly, totally put me in the Christmas spirit. I am going to go get some eggnog right now. Andrea Happy Christmas |
cary chapter 1 . 12/4/2013 i liked very much. I like Donovan-and you have written her very well. Thanks |
Heather Snow chapter 1 . 12/4/2013 I almost never cry when reading a fanfic. This is one of those very few. I felt you captured Sally extremely well. It was consistent with what in the series, but the character development you showed was natural. Her remorse was palpable, and her thoughts so well-portrayed. The early part of the interaction with Sherlock was very poignantly written, and I began to tear up. I also felt you wrote Sherlock very in character, but with some natural changes as a result of his experiences. The tentative efforts on both of their parts to act differently were very well handled. And I loved the end of the story. I look forward to more chapters in this story, but also to future Sally fics outside of the relationship series. I like that series, but it's really great to see good colleague/friendship pieces. |
SeductivelyDeductive13 chapter 1 . 12/3/2013 I LOVE THIS. I LOVE THIS SO MUCH. Good Donovan stories are hard to come by. I think you really nailed her character here and Sherlock's as well. Less cold than he was before, less ready to be cruel after 3 months/years/howeverthehelllongMoffatfeelsliketorturingourbelovedcharactersfor of a loneliness he's found he no longer wants. I adore that Sherlock calls Lestrade by his first name now. I've wondered if he would and I think that would definitely be significant should Moffat choose to incorporate that in the series ( and I so hope he does!). Your writing is great! It's simple, but it has plenty of depth and as I've already said, the characterization! With very little words you managed to bring it all together perfectly. Well done! Thank you! Maxine. (: |