This is so beautiful it gave me chills. Thank you.
-Terry

Why have i never read this masterpiece before? Why did we never get discussions like that on the show?
That was so beautiful.

This is a beautiful story.

Beautiful!

I absolutely love this story! It's truly beautiful! I've always felt that Kate was Castle's first true love. If he thought he was in love before, now he realizes that those times didn't really compare to his love for Kate. The first woman he was in love with that he brought to the Hamptons. Yes, I'd have to agree.

Beautifully written.

I really, really love this. You captured their voices beautifully and this scene feels like a natural extension to both the 0608 episode and Murder He Wrote. Escaping into your story made a yucky Monday much better. Thank you!

Got to this one at last. lovely :)

Just so gorgeous. So well thought out and well told. I love how that day/trip stands out so clearly in both their minds and held so much meaning for them. All the way back to when they were just getting started, or rather, given in to those feelings. So beautiful. My two favourite parts were his recollection of the little breathless noise she made when he kissed her, and the idea that it's the imperfections that make them beautiful. Loved this so much. Thank you for writing it xx

Beautifully written - well done! I wish we could have seen this scene in 6x08.

Love those tender moments! Wonderfully sweet story!

Beautifully Done! Thank You!

This was fantastic! Thank-you.

This is a very good story. It is fun to imagine Caskett having this conversation. I know the TV show doesn't have time to allow these type scenes so good fan fic can give satisfaction otherwise denied. So excellent story. I enjoyed reading it.

This is so beautifully written. I love how you took us to the beach with them that day at the Hamptons. I loved seeing it through their eyes - Rick's words. *sigh* They're so in love.

Brilliant comparison to the imperfections of shells. You're a genius. A talented genius. Thanks for sharing!