So amazing

That fic was beautiful. A bit slow to start, but once it got going-! I love what you did with Nyota, and Spock, and Sam. I think they all grew from this. Fantastic fic, thank you for sharing.

That is one hell of a first chapter, especially the last sentence! Well, I can’t stop reading there!

That was good.

I love this story it made me cry and laugh at the same time

Perfectly written! I wished that you'd made it a little more Spock/Kirk related though...sigh

That's was a good story.

This was a super cute/feely fic, and i love it.
But; imagine this:
All of Jim's crew leaving him lil notes all over the place titled "Reason #_ that James Tiberius Kirk is a Good Captain". The notes say things like, "He always makes us feel like we make a difference on board." "He always makes sure we get out of trouble first." "He is always steady." and so on and so forth. Or the notes just retell things he's done for his crew; like taking a bullet in his arm for that Cabet on that one planet.
Jim find him on his chair, on his door, and his lunch tray, people pressing notes on his back at random times during the day, and Jim keeping everyone he finds, and being able to tell Spocks hand writing from Scotty's.

Very well written. Good job.

Amazing writing! Really great plot line, good pacing, and on-point characterization.

Oh my gosh this is amazing I've enjoyed reading it so much.

Wow. Such an amazing story. So many things and so much emotion. I love how you've written his crew taken everything and Uhura helping Jim figure out his emotions and supporting him. Than how his brother came in and Jim accepting him and -him- finally getting what he should have gotten. I love how you wrote Spock's testimony. It was amazing and so Spock. I think the epilogue was just wonderful. I am glad there's a sequel to this amazing story. My twin is going to love this story. You're a wonderful author and writer. Cheers and ta for writing and posting this intriguing story.

Love it! Super sweet there at the end

You absolutely NAILED Spock. It was just perfect. I was laughing so hard when he started defining the word 'no' and I was touched when he defended Jim's character and all of it was done with Spock maintaining perfect character.

This is the second story of yours that i have read so far and i wasn't really sure about reading a Star Trek one, dont get me wrong i have read crossovers of Doctor Who and Star Trek.

Loved the story, i would have liked to have seen Kirk and Carol get together.

Great work can't wait for more of your Trekkie stories