This was a good start of a story. It was well written and detailed. I would have liked more complexity to it, though. What happened to Vivienne's body? Seems like a plot hole to me. Please add more to this story...it has potential.

(gasps in awe and amazement)
Oh, wow...

Thank you. I have not read a phanfic in a long while and had only recently felt the urge to find a story to curl up with. This is exactly the type of story i was looking for and i have enjoyed it immensely. Looking forward to another update on Metamorphosis soon!

This is an amazing story! I love how you portrayed the characters!

Wow, I spent an entire sleepless night reading all 50 chapters. I'm terrible at writing reviews and truthfully I usually don't. But I really loved this story with all the twists and the intense moment while keeping it PG but most of all giving the Phantom a happy ending/story. I've never read the POTO but from what I know about it you definitely had consistant characters and the Phantom is exactly as I would imagine. Anyways, thanks for writing it and I'll definitely be checking out your other stories. Consider this 1 favorite/follow because I'm gonna bookmark you on my ipod :)

Oh my. I love the fluff in this chapter. Reading on..

It's past 3 a.m. and I cannot stop reading this fantastic story. I'll read one more chapter.. Lol.. yeah right.

Very sweet and romantic and yet some of your plot devices had me gasping (in a good way!). I didn't see any of the plot twists coming, which delighted me. Alinah was a very well thought out character. Erik was very in character as well, though my opinion on this is somewhat negligible since movie!Erik isn't my Erik and I don't know him as well, though he's Erik all the same. I quite liked the level of detail there - though sometimes the repetitive cycle of Erik not trusting Alinah and misunderstanding her was a little, well, repetitive (though probably extremely realistic given the situation). All in all, it was a good read, and you are a good writer. I'll definitely be checking out your other stories! :)

Oh no!

Yes! FINALLY! I have been waiting for this! How will she react!? You writing is phenomenal!

I read this entire story in 3 days and I loved it. The last few chapters made me cry a bit, and right now I am wondering what I'm going to do now that I've finished such an amazing story.
This was the first phantom fanfic I've read, and it was awesome!

I loved it! Sorry I haven't reviewed haven't had the time. But I loved it all!
I saw you post your new story and look forward to reading it too. You developed story and characters brilliantly. Your ending was fan-oh no 'phantastic'!
I'm hoping to put up a new story soon. This time, an E/C which will be a challenge for me because I usually have done only E/OC. For reviewing 'My Silhouette', I thank you. Hope the best for your new story.
Your reader,
Anonymous by Preference
PS. If you are interested, look for the title 'The Moon Does Smile' ;)

Oh snap! Alinah is so sassy in this chapter! I like it when she's sassy! Erik deserved her sass lol

your story has really given me much enjoyment showing how damaged people can come together and have a happy ending. very well done

The way you write Erik is just amazing! This is how I pictured he would act as well! :D