| Reviews for A Different Sorting |
|---|
Irhaboggles chapter 3 . 7/12/2018 Ooooh, nice! This house fits her really well. And I like what you sorted her mother and grandfather into. Those were really fitting too. This was a good little series. Do you think you'd ever do the other characters? Or was it just the main trio? I see you haven't updated this in awhile, so I understand if your inspiration is dry. But anyway, this was a really creative fic and I liked your reasoning behind every house. |
Irhaboggles chapter 2 . 7/12/2018 Ooooh, nice! Very in-character. Brooding, bitter Ky... I like it. Though I have to admit that his hatred towards Slytherin bothers me. I understand why he has it, but for a guy who understands what being judged and outcast feels like, you think he'd be a bit more open-minded and realize that Slytherin DOES NOT equal automatic villainy. IDK, I maybe a "Huffle-claw", but I think Slytherins deserve better than what they got. But that's just a personal tic, the rest of this story was perfect! It was very in character, like I said before. Good job. |
Irhaboggles chapter 1 . 7/12/2018 This is a neat idea! This was a nice little start! And I like how you had that reference to the HP Carrow twins, I totally forgot about them. It was a cool callback to see the Hat reference them, albeit a bit unfair for it to automatically assume Xander would be related to them by name alone. Anyway, good start! (What house are YOU in? I'm either Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw. I've taken a bunch of tests and asked all my friends and it's a pretty split decision over H and R). |
LongLiveThorn chapter 3 . 9/1/2014 This is COOL! I've read the matched trilogy three times, and I still don't know what it's about tho... |
Patronus12 chapter 3 . 8/2/2014 The houses are perfect, and so is the Sorting Hat! -Breeze |
Princess Unikitty chapter 3 . 9/26/2013 interesting set of stories so far. |