I have loved the story so far and hope you update, but given that its been years since the most recent chapter came out, I doubt it will continue. I will continue to hope nonetheless!

Love the story, hope you get back into it.

Ahhhh this is such a refreshing and original read. Interactions I have never seen in all my HP/FMA trawling: Edward and the bloody Baron. Surprisingly large amount of crossover that was wonderfully explained with internal monologues and a very rewarding mini character arc. Next, Ed and a house elf. Very unique and also laden with the depth of Edward's own gray moral stances. Eve is a very loving and caring character who DOES things in the plot which really endears her to me. Lastly, Sirius and Ed. A nuanced, gradual relationship that has massive payoff in the end as we finally see their communal suspicions come to head. This is a relationship between two men who are very afraid of many things. It's mature and characterized by their prejudices and shortcomings of personality. All three of these relationships are ones that I have never seen and consequently this has become the most enjoyable read I've had in a long time. Also, that Dumbledore builds trust in Edward over time, and that Edward is deft at keeping his larger secrets has fully convinced me that this is a mature piece of writing that is far more clever than it's given credit for.

Thank you so much for the amazing read~

Ok. So, I found this story and didn't check the update time as I usually do and didn't realize it'd been 3 years. Sadly, I'm now hooked beyond measure, with little hope for a continuation :p Anyways, despite the apparent abandonnement and the minimal chance that you actually read this, I wanted to thank you for writing the story and plead you for more, if you're up to it!

Best of wishes in your endeavours, be they writing this story or not...
~ Caibb

Please come back this is amazing! I need to read more, black finds out by chance while Ed suspected for a long time that is so funny, just like the anime!
Please don't stop this it is godly

This is a great story! I wouldn't have known that English wasn't your first language, except that you mentioned it. You're a great writer, and I'd love for this fic to be updated. I want to see where Ed's research goes. And now that Sirius and Ed know each others secrets, I want to know how their friendship progresses

This is an interesting departure from the usual Harry Potter crossovers. I like it and would very much desire to read more. It has been over year since your last update. I am worried this story has been abandoned.
:(

YEEEEES, THIS! Keep up the good work!

This fic has been super enjoyable and interesting to read, thank you for writing it :3

I absolutely love this fanfiction and I can't wait for the next chapter!

This was great! I can't wait to read more!

This is so interesting and very well written! Please update again!

Awww I can't wait to read more...BTW couldn't the ministry use a pensive to prove what the most saw about Sirius and Peter?

This fic is awesome beyond words. It's well written and the plot is fresh and not repetitive, the characterization seems to be on point. And each chapter is nicely paced too. Overall, excellent work, will read again 10/10. fav

This fic is awesome. I am a big fan of Ed in HP, but what you said at the beginning was true - usually he just follows the trio around their stories more. That's fun but this is really refreshing and makes sense too. I love seeing end of manga Ed as well, it's rarer than it should be. The story is really well-written and I like seeing the different character POVs too. I'm especially excited about the prospect of Ed becoming friends with Sirius properly now... really this is just awesome and I'm excited to see the next chapter.