Omg I loved thisss ahhh I really liked the plot line and how u wrote all the settings in and everything!

I loved it honestly one of my favourite jily fics

This is absolutely brilliant!
I usually do not read Jily AU and specially the pirate ones. Somehow i was never able to accept them in pirate stories. But your story has hooked me up. It was brilliantly written with incorporated HP details. I loved it. And i suppose i am gonna start reading more of pirate stories from now on, all thanks to this story.

PS- I really hope you write a sequel some day with Jily and group facing Thomas Riddle, Peter's secret coming out, Snape's confrontation or may be some of their sea adventure on some "Mysterious Island".

my favourite jily pirate au tbh! this is the third time ive read this and i love it just as much as i did the first time! Lily & James are just absolutely perfect!

How old are the marauders in the story?

This has undoubtedly been one of the greatest fanfictions I've read in a long ass time. I was hooked instantly and utterly captivated by the world you built. I spent all night reading it and I don't regret it one bit. I'm going to be tired as shit at work today but I'll also be able to look forward to rereading this the moment I get off :)

Thank you! What a ride that was! I was completely immersed! Enjoyed it all.

That kiss was a big FINALLY moment (ღღ)
Glad that the part of James that wanted to be with her finally won out, especially after seeing Lily with her heart on her sleeves like that (ʃƪ)

Ahhh the UST is strong in this. James and Lily are too far gone and I'm enjoying every second of it
（ﾉ）

I really love how James and Lily's relationship develop
(ʃƪ)
And I enjoy Remus and Sirius teasing James about Lily, they can see it from a mile away lmao

Not usually one to comment but this is by far my favourite jily fic.

Get some sleep :)

This was such an enjoyable read and I read it nonstop start to finish!

I should have reviewed before now, but I got so caught up in this story I kind of just binged on it. I wish I had the appropriate words to describe how well this was written. You had fitting descriptions of all of the characters, and the relationships between all of them were impeccable. I love how Frank and Alvie tied in, I love that we know Peter betrayed them but they don't, I love that Dumbledore walks around with no shoes. Every single detail was just perfect. Now I'm headed to stalk your page and hopefully find other JL stories.

I discovered this story just a few days ago and I honestly could not stop reading it. If it hadn't been for school and work, I would've finished this within a day. Thank you so much for sharing with us. You wrote this story beautifully and I loved the banter and imagery you created in this universe of James and Lily. It was perfect because I was looking for an AU James/Lily fic as well and am so happy I stumbled across your story. It was truly amazing and I'm so sad it ended.