Hey...just enjoying a reread and loving it, as usual and wanted to say hi! (And I KNOW you'll see this...if I haven't already posted a comment on this one, LOL)

What a great fix it! I like how you emphasized the impact that those words had on Sam through the years, and I also like that you mentioned that Dean had also been hurt that Sam had ignored his heartfelt apology. Both of them needed to know that they had both been played as well as the extent of the manipulation. Having it written down in a book and having Charlie be the one to see it and share it with them was such a great idea!

Awww!

This was awesome! I miss Charlie!

:) I wasn't the show to bring that moment up and have the brothers find out the truth of it all

One of the many Supernatural moments that made me cry to watch, fixed in this short awesome story that I can now imagine is what happened next. Thanks!

This was so completely awesome. I would have loved to seen a storyline like this on the show. The brothers, especially Sam needed to know just how badly they were played. And as for Charlie, you wrote her to perfection!

Loved this, it is pure genius how you had Charlie find the hard copy of the book and show Dean and Sam what really happened and how they had been played. Loved the emotional responses on reading it from both Dean and Sam and perfect how it healed doubts and hurts in both of them. And you wrote Charlie perfectly, love her character and this story was pure gold.

Wouldn't it be nice if all that could be resolved. They still have no idea the truth of what happened. Oh, and, also get the amulet back.

OK, totally agree with K Hanna Korossy with this one - SO GOOD!

That stupid message needed to be dealt with, and having Charlie force them to read it, and understand what the other one lived through ... I loved this. Thank you thank you thank you for getting every nuance right with all "3" Winchesters.

Peace out, bitches!

aww love her for showing dean the book...

Thank you Charlie, I've been wondering if they'll ever address that and this gave me my fix. Thank you.

I enjoyed this Supernatural story you posted. Thanks for doing it.

Thank you, thank you, thank you! Jesus, I needed this so badly. I think there are one or two others out there, but not nearly enough, and you are my favorite author of Supernatural fic by far.

Everyone seems to ignore this entire thing and it KILLS me! I never seem to stop thinking about those stupid voicemails and the fact that as far as we know in canon, neither of the brothers ever found out the truth. And I've thought up about a thousand possible fixes for it, but it's always better to see them written down, and I can't seem to put mine down quite as smoothly and eloquently as you can. So thank you again!

What a great story! I have often wondered what would happen if the boys knew the truth about that voicemail. You wrote the perfect scenario.