YOU'VE MADE ME CRY WITH YOUR BEAUTIFUL WRITING AND I DON'T KNOW HOW TO DEAL WITH IT

Wow. That was... I don't really think I can put it into proper words but I do know I just sat down and rethought my entire existence after reading that.

OMG... That ripped my heart out... So sad...

A friend turned me onto this. It was so different, and so sad. I wondered about the impact Bad Wolf must/could have had on Rose, enough of a loophole to give some fans some solace I suppose. It seems so perfectly tragic that it could be canon. Rose and the Doctor, essentially immortal, living on the opposite ends of a parallel barrier in time and space.

I read this so long ago, but just as I was about to recommend it to someone I realized I had never reviewed. It's lovely and haunting. Very, very good work. Thank you for sharing this with us.

curse you I went into this thinking it would be funny and smutty and now i'm all sad and considering my place in the universe. it was brilliant but so so sad.

Oh wow, This was breath takingly beautiful and painfully sad at the same time. Ya'know, I always wondered why there where no repercussions of Bad Wolf. And this, well, this just opened my eyes to so many things.

I think I just found my new favorite author.

This was so beautifully written. I had to go really slowly to let things sink in, which I appreciated. This is such a wonderful, sad concept. It shows how the Doctor must feel about everyone he loves, which is heartbreaking. I also love your characterizations, especially seeing Rose and River interact and describing Eleven as a boy. Just lots of amazing things. Thank you so much!

Completely beautiful. Thank you.

I don't even...know what to say. This was just so plaintive. Quietly heart-breaking, 'not with a bang, but a whimper' sort of way.

I didn't even realize I was crying until 520.