| Reviews for Thanks for the Memories (even if they weren't so great) |
|---|
A Blair fan chapter 1 . 9/1/2013 I'm confused, why would Blair commit suicide? I know it wasn't over a man because she is way stronger than that (she wouldn't commit suicide over Chuck or Dan). So that would be really out of character if that was the case. I'm dying of curiosity as to why did she kill herself, could you provide the back story? Right now the only way I would see her committing suicide is to escape a even more painful and encroaching illness. |
Cascia chapter 1 . 4/2/2013 Estoy llorando como una niña pequeña... gracias por tan conmovedora historia! Sigue escribiendo, please |
Guest chapter 1 . 4/1/2013 that was so sad, but i liked it |
elizabeth.mary.stark chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 So sad! I am now in tears! Please do not update this, leave this as a one shot because more chapters would ruin the power of the story! Thank you very much. |
Guest chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 As beautifully written as it is, it's so sad and I seems so completely out of character for Blair. Also Chuck Bass has been through enough. This story made me angry and sad and well, you are a very good writer, but I think that for the sake of the fandom, write something lovely and happy about the Basses. |
Nicole chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 I thought your story was amazing. Really touching! If anything I'd like for you to explore more in depth the subject and how everyone is handle Blair's death throughout their lives. Keep up the great writing. |
Guest chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 I liked it, and I'm a blair fan, I could seriously see Blair killing herself after the finale. I know you're a chair fan, but it's hilarious how Chair fans are criticizing your work. It's amazing to read Chair fans turning against each other. I personally thought it was well written. If we were truly honest with ourselves, the show left us with horrible couples. If Blair chose Dan, she would have married a stalker so I see the same outcome as Chair. The suicide didn't affect me because the Blair I loved died after the Season 4 finale. Then died again after the Season 5 finale. Thank you for writing this because it was beautiful. Ignore all the haters. |
chairilove chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 I cried after reading this story. it was touchy. but i do have to say it was not the blair we know from the show. In this story she was like claire from Dan's book. I have a feeling that dan would write a story like this after loosing blair to is the most powerful woman. And even ur story cant ruin chair happy ending |
Michelle dontcare chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 A lot of stories seem to kill off Blair. Never read one with suicide, wish it was explained a little more but i was good. |
Kate chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 I've read this over a few times and I really love it. Will have to disagree with the other reviewer and say that it seemed pretty obvious that Blair had mental health issues as opposed to just missing Dan. A few people in my family have had depression and even though they love their partners or their kids or their friends, the two are separate. Being with the right person doesn't cure you. That's how I saw this, anyway. Although that doesn't explain why Chuck sent Henry to Dan, so what do I know? |
anon chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 Well, I am a tiny bit sad that you butchered the happy ending, but oh well, this was great. haha I love Chair angst and it was interesting seeing Henry as a teen. |
Guest chapter 1 . 3/30/2013 This was an interesting fic. I'm a dair fan and I take it that you're a chair fan but I got the feeling you were a little conflicted about why Blair would commit suicide. For me, the line where chuck tells Henry if he wants to understand his mother, he should ask Dan really touched me. I do think Dan understood Blair best. I think chuck and Blair loved each other but it changed. It's a difficult topic to broach (suicide) because as a Dair Dan I can read it as Blair being unhappy without Dan. I'm not sure how a chair fan would take this. However, at the end of the day, regardless of ships and otps, you wrote a very good story. I hope my preference for dair hasn't offended you or upset you. I really did enjoy this fic. |