This is really good! I love the action.

Thanks for this story. I've always wondered how Moody lost his real eye and then got his magical eye. You've kept everyone else in character too, which I also appreciated.

Love it.

omg so much fun!
Pettigrew really got on my nerves, and the Dumbledore making the eye for Moody was amazing! Never came across it before. Moody's head is not an easy place to get into, but you did it well - congratulations.
xx

Found this story by its inclusion in the C2: DLP 5-starred & featured...
Quite like it. I like the idea that Dumbledore created Moody's Eye - more interesting than the various versions of "Moody loses his eye and goes on a treasure hunt for _ rumored magical artifact" - and you implemented the characters well.

Lovely, lovely fic! Your portrayal of Moody is amazing.

How do you upload nonfiction on this site can you do it on your phone?

An excellent fic with effective action and well nuanced characterisations.
Well told.
Regards,
unlikely2

This story is bloody brilliant!

Im in awe in this beautiful story...thanks.

Wonderful.

This was fucking epic. A hell of a read. You should bring it to the attention Rowling herself, I am sure should would be thrilled with writer's such as yourself who add to her world in such a positive way. This story and the story adding to the history of Dolohov. You should read that, I wish I had a link for it.

this is so freaking awesome!

great oneshot :)

Simply splendid.