Oh good, I was wondering how you'd resolve that. And Sherlock gets to keep some of his hoard via John, so that's nice.
Where are they going to live?!

It's a wonderful story.

Thank you for this amazing story! It is so well written and gave me lots of warm fuzzies. A wonderful story of true friendship and I love all the Sherlock and Watson interactions in the dreams. Thank you, thank you!

I want to see Gandalf's view on this...and possibly the war with a dragon in it.

Next chapter please! Lol

Well, good thing armies and fun-times destruction is ahead lol - they could do with a little more adventure :)

Great! Thank for the reading :)

*Squee* this is exactly the John/Sherlock/Bilbo/Smaug story I have wanted to read where they have their memories of their previous lives. I love it :) and I have really enjoyed your writing.

Aw:) are you going to update next? Perhaps an epilogue?

Loved it!

You! Yeah, you there! Come here! You have just ripped my heart to pieces and scattered them all over Middle-Earth! What do you have to say for yourself, you genius, you!?

This is a friggin' beautiful story! Why does it have to end?! ;_;

Oh, hell, this is boss!

Oh, another thought, do you think you can weave some deductions in the plot? Just like without protectiveness of treasure, Smaug is not himself, without deductions, Sherlock isn't quite Sherlock.

Amazing! From the moment when Bilbo told Gandalf about Sherlock, I was hooked. This is by far the best Hobbit/Sherlock crossover around, so thanks for writing it, and please update soon!
PS: Loved Smaug referring to Bilbo as his most valued treasure!