Reviews for Roses
chibiukyou chapter 14 . 8/10/2004
"Instead, he had donned a long forest green walking dress that came just above his ankles and had tons of ruffles. It really was more of an evening gown but he didn't seem to mind."

Didn't mind? DIDNT MIND! Pft... I hate dresses... *grumble* Damn formal wear... why couldn't I have been born a guy. u_u On the upside, it does sound like a gorgeous dress which I'm sure looked FABULOUSO on him :D! Hell, he'd look good wearing nothing... 9.9 Now that IS an idea... n_n

*blink* Oh yes! HI! I wonder if you still remember me... ;_; Its me! Your ever so faithful (if misguided) and adoring Numbah One reviewer: Chibiukyou! :D I know its been a while... hell, almost a year I think. Sorry about that! I didn't mean to disappear! But that's not to say I didn't keep reading your fic! I just didn't have it in me to review like I had been. You know, things come up. But don't fret, I promised myself I'd come back and review them all right and proper, and VOILA~! I have arrived! :D!

Audience: Bo~ *tosses rotten fruit*

Chibi: Hey hey~! I don't appreciate that sort of behavior! *shakes fist* Damn hooligan kids~!

Hooligan kid: *runs up*

Chibi: Oh hi there little fellow! Aren't you cute! *pats it on the head*

Hooligan kid: you suck *kicks shin*

Chibi: ._. *in pain*

Ahh, the joys of an adoring public. *coughs delicately* ANYWAYS! I hope the uh, time has left you well, and uh... oh yeah, this is supposed to be a review, not the (sad sad sad) story of my life...

"Don't scare them, Mr. K."

*bwahaha* Its a little late for that in al universes isn't it. Gotta love Mistah K! He always has such BIGU NUZU! *strikes pose* Ah hah hah hah hah!

Mr. K: *cocks gun*

Chibi: hah ha- *choke*

Eh heh... I guess I'll just leave the bad engrish up to the professionals... or you just might not hear from me for another long while... *eyes K* Down boy.

"I can't imagine you with a bald head, walking around chanting. It'd be funny, actually."

No~! NOT MAH TATSUHA! O_O Shave his head, I shave your back! *threatens* Er, nevermind. I kinda like the rug look on you. *squints* ... *tilts head at an angle* M... fluffy.

... .;; *cough* Anyways~! M... fic. I *LOVE* this fic! I missed it way bunches! And I STRONGLY suggest you continue it! :D! BECAUSE ME LOVES IT! And you know, my will is the word of god, so I supposed you'd better get after it now shouldn't you.

...

...

*taps foot* Well? What are you doing reading this? YOU SHOULD BE WRITING! *glompu* I love you. ._.
Saiyana Pissed at FF.net royally chapter 1 . 1/6/2004
Continue or die.
kitty-nickle chapter 17 . 12/26/2003
I just have...no words. This is possibly the best fic I've read off ! You'll continue...won't you?
~nickle-chan~
Rosa Aquafire chapter 10 . 12/22/2003
Aw! The move in scene! I wonder how exactly theyre going to explain that one ...

Hurray for Tatsuha! I LOVE Tatsuha! Hes so great! I so hope youre going to do the scene where Shuichi comes home and hes there intead of Yuki! Sure we dont see Timothy that much this chapter, but hes here!

I want to see Ayakya, too, Im curious as to how youll handle that part of the plotline, and it actually fits in REALLY well with the timeframe. Honestly, though, I hope youre not TOO hard on her. I dont love Ayaka all that much myself, but she gets it way too hard in fanfiction. I think there could be an interesting relationship between Edward and Anna, and she could be a very interesting character.

"No... I want to write a song for Edward. He keeps saying how bad my writing is, maybe if I add music he’ll like it more."
"I don’t see what that has to do with the writing."
"What rhymes with dysfunctional?"

I LOVED that bit! GOOd work!

Yay for this fic! Im going on to read the next cahpter now!
Rosa Aquafire chapter 9 . 12/22/2003
Opium. Opium, opium, opium. Its usually smoked, but I THINK it comes in a pill form.

I like this chapter. There are times when the setting seems to fade away, but its natrual since youre concentrating on the characters rght now and theyre basically the same. Which is actually a good thing.

Oh, one thing I forget to say in my rehash of my eaten review for the pervious chapter, I like how youre trying to use time accurate language! If you still need suggestions, I have a few. The words daft for stupid, silly, or unright in the head and bloody, which we all know were used a lot. Thats all I got, Im out of inspiration p

Love this fic, onto next chapter, please dont give this thing up again!
Rosa Aquafire chapter 8 . 12/22/2003
Boo! I wrote this MASSIVE review for this chapter but then my computer ATE it! Okay, Ill rewrite it *grumble*

I talked about a small point of contention with me and this fic that you should know about. You mentioned earlier that you were aware of the fact that homosexuality was looked down on in the 1910s. The penalty for being found out was usually something called excommunication, which essentially meant that you could never live as a normal person ever again, because the church had disstanced you from the rest of society figuritively.

Now, Im glad you knew this, but there is a LOT of shounen-ai in this fic consdiereing the time frame. Saunders has a crush on Tohmas, Hugh has a crush on Stuart, Stuart has a crush on Edward, Youve promised Reece and Timothy will have a something later on .. really, I cant see it all for the timeframe.

In the citrusy scented section, for example, you say that Edward "hadn’t slept with many men, maybe just two or three, but he had to admit that he liked them much better". IF Edward could have admitted, even to HIMSELF, that he liked men, the possibility of finding another man to practice on is .. slim. To find two or three? I know that its generally thought that Yuki is more experienced than Shuichi and thus actually knew what he was doing the first time, but I think, realistically, Edward would have been just as inexperienced as Stuart in this respect. (They probably would have had to think a bit to plan where to "put" it, I doubt it was as well knwon then as it is know.)

So maybe watch it on the amount of shounen-ai in it? I mean, its GRAVI, so its all in character, but its not really .. in setting, you know? Whatever.

Oh, and you called Reece Swift Reece Savage once this chapter, near the beginning. Understandable. You basically have Gravitations chracters and a whole knew cast of names.

BUT, all constructive critisim aside! This is a really great fic! Its still, like, my favorite Gravi fanfiction! So, so good! I love the way the situation between Stuart and Ask is going ("they called themselves Ask for some god-forsaken reason" lol). Very appropirate, once again, the parrells between writings musicals and music are very, very good and time relevant! I love this! I do! Im wondering when Suguru is going to show up, I love that uptight oldman-boy.

I loved the scene where Reece was playing with the teddy bears on Mariannes bed and calling her Annie! So cute! So Ryuichi! And when he was feeding Teddy the chips! So, has Kumagarou been replaced with "Teddy"? If so, I kind of like it. It gets across the same feeling, has a catchy name, and is way more likely for a guy in England to name his rabbit. Poor, poor opium addicted Marianne ..

And despite the line about his level of experience in the field, you did very, very good at the limey part. Still very in charatcer, although this was a lot more like the manga version of how it worked than the anime version. I alwyas preferred the anime version of this scene .. Yuki was SUCH a jerk in the manga. Can anybody say "rape?"

Very awesome! I still love this fanfiction so much! PLEASE dont let the critism go to you head becasue I SO LOVE IT! Yay!
panatlantic chapter 17 . 12/21/2003
i remember this fic... vauely... yes...
OF COURSE I REMEMBER !
it's one of the best gravi AU's ever written! of course i remember!
Rosa Aquafire chapter 7 . 12/20/2003
"Oh, Smith. That was very unfortunate, no one knew how that ladder could have fallen when it was bolted to the ground..."

I sense Tohmas might have had something to do with this. Oh, how dearly I love you, you awesome manipulative bastard.

I REALLY like your interpretation of ASK. Mr. Anderson is a perfect Victorian Aizawa! Once again, youve done a great transition! I love it! I love it! Huzzah! Hip hip hurray! (Its late and Im sick, give me a break p)

I dont know if it was on purpose, but .. Anderson .. Bailey .. Clarke .. ABC?

And the introduction of the Noriko/Natalie! The famous pianist! Once again, I LOVE your professions for them! This is a REALLY great parallel!

Love how you still manage to get in the parallel between Ryuichi and Shuichi. Great to have it there, it was an important part of Shuichis canon success, so it should be part of Stuarts!

Edward chuckled – Thomas would love that headline. "Famous Romance Novelist Killed in His Sleep by Runaway Tree." That would just make his day. Maybe he’d keep the tree after all.

For some reason I LOVE this line. It is so Yuki. Very cool, I really like it.

The scene with the two men sitting alone with the candlelight, though, was the best of the chapter. I could see it in Gravitation, I really could. The dialogue, the atmosphere, the characterization .. it was perfect! I hope Stuart keeps calling him Young though .. it had kind of grown on me.
bakayaro onna chapter 17 . 12/20/2003
I just spent the day, taking breaks for shopping and meals, reading this great fic. Noticed at one point my good friend TalonSage reviewed you!
YES! You need to continue this! It is a wonderful a/u, inventive with your own personal and original inventions yet still following the anime storyline.
You provide a lot of nice details as well, painting the interiors, exteriors and charas with words.
Hope this review will spark your muses to complete this tale!
Atarii chapter 17 . 12/20/2003
I'm Almost glad I haven't seen this fanfic before today..it means I had 17 wonderful chapters to go through...
Anyways..forgive me for that. I've read a ton of the gravi fandom, but this one was one of those that stick out in my head, instead of the standard stuf you generally tend to see. I really like how this is all Yuki's writings in a book (Or should I say Mr. Youngs? *laughs*)
It's interesting to see how closely this story sometimes follows the original story, while at other times it takes so many liberties. I must say, I also really like the England setting, too. It's just so..out there.
I'm not sure I like their names being changed, but I understand why they were, obviously, so *shrugs* Other than that minor detail, I'm absolutely Loving this story! *waves little flags*
Hm...If it's not too late to change your mind, I'd vote Hiro and Suguru. I'm not really into Hiro and Noriko, and there's the two facts that 1: You've already created Hiro's character to be at least bi, if not gay, and 2: Noriko's married, both in the original storyline nad this one. However, it's your choice, not mine. Other than that, I'm enjoying all of your pairings. . Maybe, if you'd be so kind, we could see some Tohma/Seguchi action, too? *puppy eyes*
Ah! Another thing! I love how long your chapters are! Too many authors will have 40 chapters, but each chapters only a page or two long. *pouts*
Ack! Sorry to just keep rambling away like this. x.x;; *gives lots of strawberry stuff for inspiration* Keep up the awesome effort!
jmccall93 chapter 17 . 12/20/2003
Thank you for picking up this story again! I look forward to seeing the updates again!
Rosa Aquafire chapter 6 . 12/20/2003
Ahaha! The poor, poor maid! So traumatized! Honestly, I would be to, if I were living in 1910 and my employer was making out with some other guy right in front of me!

I still hate all the Hiro/Shuichi stuff, but whatever, once again, I can deal with it.

I think the transition from Ryuichi to Reece was actually very well done. True, a lot of Ryuichis specific blend of humor relies on the Japanese language to abck it up, but I think youve done a very good job with it! Hes still all cute and clingy and stuff! And random! Like the carriage part! I loved that! How Tohmas couldnt tell is he liked carriages or hated them.

If Im right that the reason K has a british accent even though he was raised in New York refers to the fact that K has a Japanese accent even though he was raised in New York in the anime, then youre brilliant. OR I could just be hallucinating and looking way too deep. p

"Mr. K – "
"I’m not giving him anymore charcoal."
"Thank you."

This is also brilliance. I love you.

I see you decided to have him yelling "Young" after all. I actually kind of like it. When you first made fun of the idea, I was like "Haha. yeah, that would be funny." But now that its already written down .. I kind of like it. For some reason.

Poor Stuart .. Edward just keeps on rejecting him. So sad.
Rosa Aquafire chapter 5 . 12/20/2003
OOh! France Kyoto paralell! Very, very nice! I like it! And the family church .. so great! I guess that would make Yukis Popa a priest.

Which could be REALLY bad for the relationship.

This chapter was, like, exactly like the anime in a majorly cool way. I was worried over how you were going to handle the whole "This is Shuichi, we have a date, isnt he a CUTIE?" thing, since Marianne would probably drag Edward to a confesional for penance instead of just walk away like Mika did. But you did it very well! Im glad! Youre being very, very respectful to the time period and I really love it.

I cant say I really like the Hugh/Stuart undertones, though, mostly because Im, like, the only Gravi fan who will argue into the grave that Hiro never loved Shuichi, and that he is 100% straight. Still, it doesnt take away from the story at all.

Nice kissing, by the way. I liked that part p The poor, poor maid.
Rosa Aquafire chapter 4 . 12/20/2003
Another great chapter! Stuart is so cute! Hes Shu-chan through and through! The hitting in the head with the pillow and the orange were so classic and awesome! I love it!

Im glad youre not having them just LEAP into their relationship. Its really mature, espeically considering the time frame. So many authors would have them making out at the beginning of chapter 1.

Honestly, I think that you keep Edward/Yuki very, very well in character. Hugh, too. They are all acting exactly as a bunch of Victorian versions of themselves would act! Its a good! Very good! I like it!

(And if all else fails, lube, Vaseline and all aside, theres always plain old soap p)
Rosa Aquafire chapter 3 . 12/20/2003
I continue to adore this fic p

Its so great! Awful part to leave off at, Im glad I started late, so I can just move right on to the next chaper!

I like the way that youre setting up the relationship between Edward and Stuart, its a lot like the anime version, only .. you know .. different. Ye gods, that was articulate.

And Saunders is so loveably paincky! A perfect Sakano! I love it! The way hes all mooning over Tohmas is awesome! So in character.

Oh, and I thought Id say, I love the names and the professions, they are, once again, a really great reflection of the Victorian Gravitation thing.

On to next one!
135 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »