| Reviews for A Rose By Any Other Name |
|---|
Rosebud on Royal Icing chapter 3 . 4/17/2014 You need to continue! I love this fic! Rhaegar is just sooooo loveable here and Lyanna is just wonderful! I need more! |
tsevca chapter 3 . 1/30/2014 i think youll agree with me, you went little too far in this. rapers get to choose knife or the wall. do you think her brothers would let him get away with this? benjen was too young to do anything, but others? when brandon heard of her abduction, he forgot his journey to catelyn (i never knew if to marry her or to bring her to winterfell and marry her there) and headed to the capitol without thinking and threatened to rhaegar to kill him, heir of the realm. and ned with his sense for justice? but you know, id read if you wanted to continue. despite its mistakes, its very readable. |
tsevca chapter 2 . 1/30/2014 again: i forgot it at the last chapter - septas are something like nuns, belong to the faith of seven. sansa keeps both religions and catelyn keeps the new gods, so girls are raised by one. but there wasnt even a sept at winterfell in this time. no wine in bottles. i dont know if howland reed was already a lord at his time, but he definitely wasnt old as you wrote. hes of the same age as stark siblings. horseriding is actually very common with woman. only too old or too ill dont if theyre noble. lyanna was just unusually fast. and where is benjen? |
tsevca chapter 1 . 1/30/2014 i liked it. some of your ideas would be amazing if real, but since you wrote thats how you think it happened, there are some things you have wrong. rhaegar and elia had been married for 3 years at the time of this tourney and rhaenys was already born. soon after the tourney, aegon was concieved. your reason for choosing elia as rhaegars wife doesnt fit, too. martells are powerful in dorne, but the whole westeros? if that was it, hed choose cersei, but he rebuffed her and sent lord baratheon to look for rhaegars wife in essos. after he didnt found a good match and died, aerys chose elia. it seems to me, his subjects werent good enough, but when some of them had to be, at least it was a princess. lyannas eyes were grey, she had all typical stark features. melee is actually one time deal. they put all the contestants together and they fight until one is left - the winner. rhaegar was good, very, but he was unhorsed few times, usually by someone of his friends in kingsguard. and from what we know about aerys... him jousting? princes dont have numbers. just like his title is prince of dragonstone or lord of dragonstone. not lord prince. if htey encountred publicly so many times and so noticibly, some would have already mention it. and rhaegar calling eddard ned? he barely knows him. |
A fan chapter 3 . 1/8/2014 You have to update! I love this! |
josephpabon30 chapter 1 . 11/28/2013 Please finish this story I love it so much I keep rereading the same three chapters and am sad that I can't finish it |
Guest chapter 3 . 11/27/2013 I hope you add more this is an amazing story please continue |
xenocanaan chapter 3 . 8/2/2013 I love Lyanna and Rhaegar! Hope you post the next chapter soon! |
Nola chapter 2 . 7/17/2013 please update this as soon as possible! I love it! |
ancapd chapter 3 . 7/9/2013 This is so beautiful! Please, you have to continue it! |
Plejade chapter 3 . 6/11/2013 I really enjoy reading your story, so I hope it will be continued soon :) |
StrugglingForWords chapter 3 . 6/1/2013 I think this is an extremely well written novella and I hope you continue because I can't wait to see what happens next. I'm looking forward to your next update |
Guest chapter 3 . 4/24/2013 You're a really good writer :] |
Lyanna Arwen Narsilia chapter 3 . 2/23/2013 This is amazing please update soon I love it :P |
Guest chapter 3 . 2/11/2013 This is fab! I really like this pairing and think you write beautifully. How many chapters do you see this being? Hope to see another update soon please! |