| Reviews for Sand and Silk |
|---|
fanfictioner22 chapter 18 . 10/14/2016 This fiction started as something promising and exciting to end up in... something. While I understood by the way the story was going and the relationship between the characters, the ending wasn't going to be a happily ever after. I don't hate bad endings, don't misunderstand in any way, however the ending no the last three chapters were lazy. The fiction was pushed, rushed to the finish line, dragging the reader. Sand and Silk needs a few chapters more, scenes from Arthur's eyes and how he craved to have Alfred back, Laine and Asai's relationship, Matthew frantically searching his brother and how he escaped himself, the relationship between Arthur and Francis didn't get the attention it deserved, however, these might be left to the imagination of the reader, however, Alfred's twisted feelings, is something the writer had to give to the reader. He learned that his gentle master was killed for him, he learned that his brother, his blood was dead and he was attached to the man connecting the demise of both. As a reader, and writer myself, I expected the internal battle of Alfred and how he slowly started to fight for Arthur's attention more than his morals. There were other plot points that were never mentioned again, like Alfred being literate. The only reason was because it was plot convenient, Alfred had the ability to read and write was for him to be purchased and get Arthur's attention, after that this was never brought again. And the little fact that was was bought without the permission of the overseer. Here, I expected that someone was messing with the house expenses or why would it be mentioned if not to use, to hint for something in the future chapters? No matter how much enjoyed this story, liked the smutty parts, the lazy, rushed ending made me cringe. I believe, the writer could have delivered this ending perfectly with a few more paragraphs depicting Alfred's thoughts and feelings, accepting his brother's and Francis' death. I hope your future endings will be well executed. |
blulious chapter 18 . 4/17/2016 Brought my physical copy! :D I'm so hype for this! After many years of following the story! |
Guest chapter 18 . 4/17/2016 Ahhhhh! It's finally here now I have to figure out how I'm going to get a hardcover copy. ;) |
Oliver with Imaginary-Friends chapter 16 . 1/29/2016 Why di you end it like this!? NOOOO! WHY!? It was great, then... then everything went down... |
Vydrah chapter 17 . 12/27/2015 I really hope you ll find the artits you re looking for cause it's really amazing! Well now I m exited about it too |
roneta chapter 17 . 12/27/2015 I know a great artist I hope you like her work ;) she's amazing and even have done a book for college. Here are fb and da links. Hope you like her style as I think her style would suite the story ;) evenicai/ ?rnrd150848 |
01blackcat02 chapter 17 . 12/26/2015 Do you mind if I post this announcement on tumblr? You might have a wider reach to different artists. Or if you already made a post I can reblog it. I'm glad you decided to do this, supper excited :) |
Guest chapter 17 . 12/26/2015 Not an artist but I'm really excited you decided to do this! Might have to see if any of my friends that are better at art are willing to help. c: |
SomeoneKnew chapter 11 . 12/19/2015 Where's the quote? I don't see it. |
HashieStix chapter 16 . 11/20/2015 I fucking hate the ending. Doesn't mean the rest of your story was truly outstanding when making me gasp in surprise from sudden changes in events I never expected at 12 am in a school night. |
Guest chapter 16 . 10/15/2015 Okay...I loved this story it's so well written and rich, but what's up with the ending? I feel like I missed a chapter of something before the epilouge. It was way too sudden for a such a great story. I don't feel that Al would so quickly forgiven Arthur about Matthew, maybe had the story devopled him to be even more smitten by Arthur, almost so that it was insane, then he would have. That could have also helped you lead into the ending you seemed to be aiming for, one where the reader can tell how unhealthy and bad a stockholm syndrome relationship is. Which leads me to: Besides that part of the ending issue, I love how you stated that the relationship could never end happily, it's something rarely admitted in fics involving Stockholm syndrome. It makes them seem unrealistic, so I'm really glad you strayed away from that! So this is becoming its own novel now, so I hope you know that despite all of the critique I threw at you, I really did enjoy reading this story and can't wait to see if you have any other stuff! Thanks! |
SheWhoLeavesCrappyReviews chapter 16 . 9/27/2015 This has got to be one of the most heartbreaking stories I've read in this fandom... Alfred's my favorite character, but I can't decide whether I feel more sorry for him for being reduced to this pathetic state or for Matthew for being killed just because he was being a loving brother. Seriously, this last chapter made me want to scream in frustration. You tagged it wrong! There is no comfort in this story, only pain! Oh great, now I want to cry. |
the freelance dreamer chapter 16 . 9/21/2015 What an intense tale! I feel sorry for francis, and even aurthur , to an extent. but wow, i definitely did not see that coming! |
HeXeR476 chapter 16 . 8/22/2015 Whats with your ending? It left too many questions left hanging for me. |
Lunar Iris chapter 16 . 7/22/2015 I cannot believe that it is over. It seemed so sudden; though I knew it was coming eventually. There is such a change in the feeling between the last two chapters, it was startling. I remember you mentioning Stockholm syndrome some time ago, so I guess I should have seen that ending coming. I still didn't expect quite what you delivered. I still feel my heart breaking for them. *sniffles* |