This story is really good! Can'y wait for you to update :)

Oh my god! You updated! I can't believe you updated! Great chapter, I've missed this one!

Love your pacing and writing style! I'm so glad you haven't paired Sirius with anyone especially McKinnon. I like the tension that you portrayed between Sirius and James and the romance that's brewing despite himself between James and Lily. Really sweet. Can't wait for the next update!

Hey!
I really like your story so far!

Alicia :)

Why do I get the feeling that Lily IS Melissa?

Ohhh I really like this story! Update soon I'm curious :)

I loved it! Pls update ASAP

This is an interesting story as it sounds like James has had a number of other serious love interests besides Lily. It's great to see them as friends and I wonder what Melissa is really like? Has James idealized her, as she does seem a little too over the top? But I suppose James is a romantic himself! Interested to see how things develop.

You have a very easy-to-read writing style, and I can't wait for the next chapter!

Updates soon! :)

What if Melissa is really Lily?! And she just changed her look so James wouldn't know?! Bahhh..I can't take it. Onward to the next chapter I go.

Another chapter! I love this story and how it's progressing so far, and I almost burst out laughing at a few points. Also, can I just mention: "He quickly flipped to page 394." Thank you for that reference :)
Wonderful chapter, and update soon!

Lily is James's secret girlfriend isnt she?

God, I love this story soo much! Am I the only one who wonders how Lily knew Melissa's name? I don't remember James telling her the name of his girlfriend? Maybe I missed something? Oh well, it doesn't really matter I guess, I'll find out sooner or later. I can't wait to see more of this story, so update as soon as possible!

Haha this chapter was hilarious! Keep it up :D