I have a couple of questions. Right now it is 2019. Why is the car hovering? Is Bella 15?

So bella won't be a vampire?

Oh, God! The cafeteria scene with Emmett had me cracking up! I was merely chuckling until he tried to cover up with his hand (I love that type of comedy). I imagine Jasper would have been practically rolling on the floor between his own humor of the situation plus getting blasted from all sides by that of all the other students. :D

I think they should 'decide' to do a full blown Halloween wedding just to freak Alice out (a little payback for all the times she manipulated Bella to get her way and kept her visions from Edward). :D Actually, when I was in high school, my best friend's mother was getting married and she and her husband had a Halloween wedding... complete with costumes for the guests as well as the wedding party (even at 16 I thought it was tacky... and strange for a couple pushing middle age).

I've been thinking witch all along, but I loved Emmett's theory (I cracked up!). Glad to see the scar came up (the other scars would depend on what she is now, but I figured the bite one would be the one most likely to still be there since even vampire venom can't remove it).

There is one identifying factor that was not mentioned when Edward was comparing Marie to Bella - and it is a rather indisputable one - look at her hand for the scar from James' bite. Who else besides Bella would have a scar from a vampire bite on her hand yet NOT be a vampire?

Very unique twist on the original story. I really enjoyed it, very creative. Thanks for writing and sharing with us.

I am very curious to know when Bella’s daughter turns 16 and Bella loses her powers because her daughter is coming of age, will she THEN be able to become a Vampire since she is no longer immortal and no longer has her witch powers? Or will she just have boys and therefore never pass down her powers and never NOT be immortal?

I have a theory... Renee (Rebecca) is a witch and she has cast a spell on Bella because she was so despondent over Edward leaving. Charlie (William) is still a bit upset with Edward, but Renee knows they are destined to be together and is thereforpleased that he Cullens are back. I think Renee may know something about the Cullens’ being vampires too. It’s probably more complicated than that, but you get the gist of it. I can’t wait to find out if I’m right! Reading on...

Great story and I'm not sure which ending I like better. Very ingenious. I also love how you wove canon elements throughout your story.

although i did love both endings i gotta say the first 1 was my fav. cuz i just could't imagine them being human just to turn around n end up dying idk why but vampire they all stay alive and togther ..

Interesting twist in the alternate ending. Liked it a lot.

just a question. in the A/N's, you said B's first ime didn't hurt because she's not human, but didn't she loose her innocence in Chicago, or did the time jumps change repair all that, making her younger and virginal again? Magic is amazing, just wondering. Loving the story. I've read several of yours repeatedly, just never this one. Glad i am.

Mmm not to sure which ending I prefer. I kind of like both of them.

Thanks for sharing.