Reviews for The Rise and Fall of the Stag and the Doe
CourtneyTyler chapter 95 . 9/21
So. It's been about a week and I still haven't recovered.

You gave all these characters the story they deserved. Marlene, Dorcas and especially Peter. Their development was perfect. I was in love with all of them and their deaths broke me. I love that Lily got friends who were as strong and interesting as her. I really loved Marlene.

I loved the little things like them dancing together often (which was hinted at movie in movie cannon with the photo), the pocket watch.

One thing I would have liked was a reason why Dorcas hated Emmelane. Even if it was tiny or petty. Maybe if it tied into her bogarts story.

The ending felt a little rushed, you skipped over a whole year, which I would have loved to have seen more from. Honestly I would have just loved more of the story. But, the fact that the story was completed gave me the closure I needed. It ended perfectly. Remus' last look at Harry, the letter.

I am actually destroyed when I think about the Marauders Era and how they all ended, but I like to think, even though they had a tragic end, theyre were just too happy to live happily ever after.

Thank you. I look forward to rereading this again and reading some of your other work. You are incredibly talented and thank you again for sharing it. I'm sorry I didn't review every single chapter. I was too busy binging it all!
CourtneyTyler chapter 95 . 9/15
And I am done. So many tears. Hopefully I'll be able to review when I stop crying.
But in case I don't, thank you so much for sharing this. It was incredible. Honestly one of my favorite fics ever. And thank you for finishing it, although the ending is heartbreaking, I really feel like it's complete, and it gave me the closure I needed. I really feel like I know and understand the Marauders and the original Order now.
CourtneyTyler chapter 83 . 9/14
Oh no. I'm preparing myself for all the tears in the last part. This fic has had me so emotional already.
CourtneyTyler chapter 21 . 9/10
Why do I love Marlene and James friendship so much. I love James in this chapter. Also I love Marlene. Except for some reason I have a problem with the fact she's beautiful. The fact that her, Dorcas, Lily and (weeps) Mary are beautiful is a little too much. Like can we have one achievable realistic looking girl. But to be honest if she was average looking I'd have probably been annoyed by that too.

Loved the chapter.
CourtneyTyler chapter 20 . 9/10
Was the strawberry bracelet charmed to protect her or something? I was a bit confused about that bit... But otherwise great chapter! Was meant to have an early nigh tonight but nope! Story got way to good to put down!
CourtneyTyler chapter 15 . 9/10
Nooo! Mary... That was so unexpected.
CourtneyTyler chapter 2 . 9/9
Ooh boy. Here we go. Just finished chapter two and I am hooked! I read a few of the reviews and have high expectations and they have been meet so far! I've come after reading TLAT and Im looking forward to actually reading a. Complete story. Can't wait to see it all. play out.
Allie chapter 95 . 9/8
What an amazing story. I didn’t want the end to come because I knew what was going to happen. You’ve written this so well and you should be so proud of yourself. Thankyou for taking the time to write this
BupDoheny chapter 95 . 8/27
God this is heart wrenching. The last few chapters have been down right depressing, but it's not awful. I love your writing, tho in between there are some bits and pieces that I don't feel quite right but that's just me nitpicking. The songs and the bits of lyrics I find fitting. Tho subtle but they really helped set the theme for each chapter and elevated the story. I really love the characters and I think Peter Pettigrew had the backstory he deserved despite the lack of appearance in the last few chapters. I've gone through a handful of Marauders fanfic but not until the end that I realized this is the closure I've been looking for. Thank you for the story and those wonderful songs.
Guest chapter 2 . 8/21
I didn't think the first chapter could get any more interesting or well written but this one is amazing!
earthbibble chapter 7 . 8/17
Ahh I’m reading this rn and Lily is kinda annoying me a lot LOL every time she has proof that ppl aren’t who she thinks she is, she represses it cause she’s rlly self-righteous right now! Hopefully she’ll get better?
Cmontress29 chapter 95 . 8/3
Well this was just beautiful. All of it
camryngrace0125 chapter 29 . 7/15
this is my quarantine fanfic read and let me tell you i’ve blown through these chapters. AND i just looked up your tumblr. this is beautiful. everything i never knew i needed.
JakeSaba chapter 95 . 7/7
I really love this fanfic. It’s one of my favorites. You’re such good writer. Congrats ️
V-Vine chapter 1 . 7/1
So what does the letter at the end means?When is it write?Have Sirius read it?
1,759 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »