Hm, I expected something other than a flat out letter but I am also pleased with all of this. It turned out great. (However, I have also read the reviews and nearly choked at the idea of Dave purposefully reading the last part out. Which is now all I can imagine.) Thank you, though. It's a good piece.
I do like how it's all balanced out between all four, men if it is a touch bit biased towards John. (With good reason.)

Cutest thing I've ever read. I absolutely love this :)

may i please write a fanfic based on this?

This is great. And made more amusing by the fact that Dave probably read that last part out loud in front of everyone.

one word- D'aaaaaawwwwwwww! 333

This is just way too adorable.