emotional

I am fucking crying. I'm a mess and my mother is concerned for my sanity...I love fics that show Lucifer or Gabriel loving Castiel and him being their favorite. I loved it.

woooo that was intense

I loved seeing Lucifer's loving side, although I think it would be best story wise if Gas didn't get his wings back.

I liked this, but I'm a little confused. Did Cas get his wings back, or did Lucifer just heal him enough to take the pain away? Everything else was good, I just couldn't figure that part out.

awwwww super cute! -

heart breaking but a happy ending that left me smiling

Dear Maknatuna,

I really like this, especially having Lucifer come in for a cameo. It really does sound like something he would say/do. Good stuff!
-Samuel

Horrific but sweet.

Just a great fic, I love ones where lucifer is good and cas sacrifices his grace

Yay good lucifer!

Wow! This was...sad and suspenseful and low key and beautiful. Big surprise. I was hooked from the very first sentence. I HATE ALISTAIR! Dean's pleading for Castiel to not appear and then to leave, to not sacrifice more for Dean was well done. When Cas begin ripping his wings out, I mentally screamed NOOOOO! And then Lucifer arriving? YES! This is by far my favorite version of Morning Star. Hating humanity, but loving his brethren and being gentle and bright and wonderful to his youngest brother was AWESOME! It started as such a sad Dean in danger and Cas saving him piece and became a story revolving around, sacrifice, family, love for your brother and new beginnings. FANTASTIC JOB MY DEAR FRIEND. HUGS AND KISSES, ELIZABETH

awww, poor Cas. I have a big wing kink and it kinda hurt to read Cas ripping his wings out...

i had to read this when i saw the title. imagine my surprise- i had read this sometime back when i did not have an account here. i couldn't stop thinking of the scenes of Castiel's sacrifice for days. i made it a point to review next time. thank goodness i found it again :) i got goosebumps reading the part where Castiel is actually going through the terrible actions... you paint a pretty vivid and bone-chilling scene you know? :O
the last line is pure awesomeness!

I really loved the part where Lucifer appeared, didn't expect that one :)