Poor Goyle. No, the nice Potter is your enemy. You poor, poor child!

They think that a werewolf is a /party animal/. Need anything more be said.

...Anyone? No one? I thought it was quite funny!

Looking forward to the attack on Scabbers, courtesy of our favourite half-kneazle!

! Please continue with this wonderful series again someday. I still eagerly and hopefully await a new chapter in this saga. I know you seem to have switched to Merlin (Those fics are just as brilliant) but please don't forget this series. Its been so long :(

I'm re-reading this for the first time in... uff, a couple of years now? I've also read and enjoyed your Merlin story, and am really really happy you're still writing. Part of me hopes you'll come back to this at some point, but even if you don't, you still have written four books of something really interesting for this story alone, and I want to thank you for that.

So - onto speculation, I hope you enjoy reading my guesses. A lot of this is stuff I didn't pick up on the first times reading through, and hey, maybe some of it will prove to be true.
-The prophecies mention both the Spider and the Bee and a riddle surrounding thrm - the Bee is most probably Dumbledore ("give the Bee's name" in Rowena's prophecies) buuuut stuff is kind of phrased as if the Spider and the Bee aren't the same.
So either:
A) something massively changed about Dumbledore, making him not the same person anymore - this might have to do with the Elder wand and/or the Grindelwald duell, maybe?
Or
B) the person we know as Dumbledore and who thinks of himself as Dumbledore isn't actually Dumbledore. The most likely person to basically have swapped overtaken Dumbledore I can think of... well, it's Grindelwald, again. Who would undoubtedly go and pursue his own vision of the world while using Dumbledore's reputation as a smokescreen.
Of course, the truth might also be somewhere between A and B.
Or this might all be a red herring or me being led down the conspiracy theory path by Dumbledore having two different names in the prophecy
- the lost selkies are almost certainly something different than merpeople, as implied by the lost.
- Mark's wand - mistletoe also implies sacrifice, IIRC. Which is very, very disconcerning. I'm rather worried Mark won't survive this, even if he's developing into more and more of an arrogant git.

I hope you continue writing, and more importantly, have fun writing. Because both this story and your Merlin story are really enjoyable to me, I also hope you continue writing fanfic in fandoms I know, but - well, that's more me hoping I get to continue reading good fanfic by you.

Still waiting for book V

Hermione's middle name is Jean not Jane

Wow that potion is horrible. I was thinking 'Who would invent such a horrible potion!" then i remembered...wizards can be sooooo horrible. Urgh.

The Elder Wand perhaps? Nevs form is certainly different. I like it though!

Hmmm so is this a Harry/Hermione pairing? I actually really like that one. Sooooo much better than the ones in the books. Ugh Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione are AWFUL!

Honestly, I'm happy the Hufflepuffs won.
Still sad the Slytherins did not though.

Poor birb!

You didn’t mention Canada, so...

I’m assuming the werewolves there are fine.

You know, a convicted criminal is a person who has been convicted in the first place. For that to happen, they need to be tried first.

Considering that Sirius never had a trial and Tyr wasn't caught in the first place to be produced in court for a trial. In fact, there only was one arrest warrant made out in Tyr's name for his supposed involvement in the kidnappings - even though it wasn't really rescinded when the true identity of the kidnapper was known. So that doesn't equal conviction. Hence, I don't think either can be labelled as convicted criminals to begin with.

dude, it is a warning.
what else can it be?