I actually thought it was his dad at first

Can this please please please have a sequel where they meet officially? Possibly after Bryan's been going in about the really good teenage mechanic? Please?

Let's see... Um, "Luscious black curls and broad shoulders, and gorgeous eyes" made me 50% certain, "Westerville" had me 75-99% positive, and "eyebrows" was strike three, I knew who it was.

I got the brother thing the second Blaine called, it's brilliant (Blaine is bound to have a really hot older brother).

Answer: The minute he showed up.

To answer you question. The give-away for me was, "He had luscious black curls and..." Hurray for Glee Spoilers! _

LOL! Kurt apparently just has a thing for Anderson boys...*snicker*