This is one that I hope you can lay out some sweets to trap your muse so you can continue this story. Honestly, leaving a who-dun-it without an ending? Arg!
I hope sweet little Luna wasn't the one. That would be just the kind of twist some authors would far two have died. Both Slytherins. So is it Sytherins, pure bloods, or people that are part of something that hasn't come to light? Pansy had a weird potion, Gemma sold potion ingredients. Hhmmm...what is the connection? I may never know. Sigh.

Interesting beginning. Harry Potter/Sam Spade! Or, - I think she was killed with the Candlestick, in the Lounge, by Prof. Peacock!

Nice story. Harry’s a bit of a wolf, eh?

Thanks for posting, hope you come back to it some day.

Great Story hope you get around to finishing it.

Wish this was continued :(

I somehow accidentally managed to read chapter 12 first. Don't know how I managed to click to the last chapter on accident but I must have.

And yet somehow I wasn't even slightly lost reading it. You really are a good writer.

Awaiting the next chapter!

Please finish this story. I love how well written this is, with beautifully clear characterizations and world-building. You know exactly how rare that is in fanfiction. And the mystery is just too good. I'm genuinely thinking about it, going over to see if you dropped any hints.

Finds out friend is betraying his other friend... Does nothing proving he has the moral compass of a toad.

Amazingly well written. You should be proud, you made Harry a very relatable and compelling character. I identified strongly with Harry's romantic troubles an search for some permanence.

Finish the story

Nice, however Luna is a bit out of character and I would prefer it if you didnt make her so pretty and blushing. Great story keep it up

Hope you continue this, it’s really good.

extremely tight story, The Big H is a suspect, easy to use PolyJ to get to victims, could uae new floo experiment that didnt pan out to put victim is a void where they lose their magic or life (vacumn?) too sudden to show typical signs of death. both victims could have done bad things ro H ahe never discussed.
It could also be L if payback for Malfoy Manor ( she could make a special no signature wand, ose PolyJ) Well dont know if this one is abandoned but nice read, good cop story, so so on detective side, but outstanding view of how post War relationships would be so fleating and hard to make up for the loss of innocence. Harry's comment about how he wished he did more on girl relationship side while at Hogwarts was key insight. Nice Write!

Will there be any more of this fic?