Very accomplished and entertaining story, Thankyou for sharing.

Love secret history, great book. Dark stuff here, poor bastard. Also amazed at Logans patience living underground.

You know your guns, and your medicine. Hope I never meet you in a dark alley!

Love the snow blind line, " lazy cruel", a chilling description!

Oh Min, you are a genius. I so hope you know that, and what youve given the world with your stories. Climb the wind is heart-breaking, gut-wrenching beautiful. I cried so hard for Scotts pain, in almost every chapter. And for Logan and Hank, when Scott was raped and Logan had to watch, and when Hank had to tend to the horrific injuries of his friend. I cried when they all lost their home. I cried when Jean saved them. I cried when they went to the beach, against all odds being able to getting on with their lives.
Thank you. Your stories did deeply move me. Storytelling is poerful, indeed.

it was the standard I held not only fanfiction by but all published fiction too.

Sorry about the abrupt ending - your ability to capture an atmosphere with words is second to none, I loved this piece to bits and I look forward to the stories you write in future.

Beautiful, awe inspiring. I first read this years ago when i was quite young, it creates the same impact even now as it did then, so thank you and congratulations, you're truly a gifted writer. It's a privilege to read something of this quality where the author is ''borrowing'' characters and I can only express how much I enjoyed this interpretation by saying this story stayed with me, and for years it was the standard I held not only fanfiction by but all published fiction.

Jesus Christ. This fic. I want to write a glowing review, but I can't find the words?

Why does this only have the four reviews, it deserves like. Fifty thousand, times infinity. Or something.

... as you can see I have nothing remotely constructive to say except that this was a fantastic read. Scott, Jean and Scott/Jean doesn't always do it for me, but this was amazing and I loved it.

Curiously, I have to wonder: you mentioned in the first chapter that this is a part of a series of fics in a particular universe. Are the others available on some other site or archive? FFnet's removed the option of putting outgoing links on the author profiles, so :(

Unless I'm losing my mind, there is at least one chapter left out. I swear I remember reading all the gory battle details. What's going on?

I read the summary and thought.."Okay...interesting and familiar. It reminds me of a favorite Scott Summers I read quite a few years back on another site...wonder if the writer was inspired by that?" Then I glanced at the author name at the top and did a face palm.

Right. *laughs*

Finally I can let you know how much I absolutely *adored* that story. I enjoy humor most of all, but pathos, hurt/comfort are close seconds plus your writing is a gem and that while I was severely disappointed, I fully understood your reasons for dropping Xmen writing after that godawful Xmen III travesty of a movie.

So wonderful to see you posting here. :)

Okay, so referring to my previous review, I missed the part in your profile about nothing new coming up. Deep sigh...I do understand. You're are still in a core group of really awesome X-Men fan fictioners who are my heroes, mentors and inspiration. Between you and RhiannonUK, I'd have never gotten where I am today and understand how much further I need to go. Respectfully, MLC

Holy wow, lady! I almost fell off my chair seeing this. I've read this numerous times and can't wait to read it again. What provoked you to dabble back with FFN? You will seriously put the rest of us to shame [or spur a crop of higher quality offerings-fingers crossed. Any chance of any new Logan-centered X-Men stuff? Well, I'll settle for Scott as long as 'my man', gets some decent page time. Regards, MLC.