This is amazing

I've read this story multiple times since when it was first releasing and it's still my absolute favorite fanfiction of all time - arguably one of my favorite stories I've read as well. Thank you so much for gifting us with this story.

Ive read this like 8 times now, and honestly it just feels just as fresh and wonderful as the first time. Ive eagerly been waiting for an updated chapter, will our wonderful CattyJay ever respond to our pleas? Please update this gorgeous story. The stories evoked from that wonderful mind need to be shared!

love this fic

only on the third chapter and im obsessed

Afrer all these years this is still my favorite fanfic. I've read this when I was a teen now I'm in my 20's (rereading it again). I've read many fanfics from different fandoms but this gem. This is everything. This is sooo well written. All these emotions I felt while reading it I can't describe it. This is my favorite book ever. Thank you for this. I think I've read this for five or six times now. Will always be a fan. Back then we don't always have internet so what I do is that I print it then I read it at school. Thanm you Catty Jay for this amazing book you've written.

I know you probably won't see this, but thank you so much for this story. The only word I can think of to describe how emotionally real and how breathtakingly beautiful this story is isHaunting. This story will haunt me forever any time I read another romance story I'll subconsciously compare it to this one.

I've read thousands of fanfics in my lifetime, and it's so rare I've ever found a story that I would call art.
Even rarer that I've said as follows; This fanfiction stands on its own not only in that it can be enjoyed in full with no knowledge of the source material, but it surpasses the source material. This runs so many circles around Glee it's hilarious. Fuck, it runs circles around nearly every romance story I've ever read, watched, or heard of.

I rarely take the time to comment on the stories I read, because so few move me to. This story fucking moved me.

Performance in a Leading Role by MadLori (Sherlock fanfic, Film industry AU, Johnlock pairing)

Wild Heart by Bexteron (Xena: Warrior Princess fanfic, Tarzan AU, Xena/Gabrielle pairing)

You don't Wear Pigtails and We don't Use Inkwells by Sissy_Bloke (Glee fanfic, Trans!Quinn, Faberry pairing)

Live By the Sword by WhooshFC (Wonder Woman fanfic, Antiope/Menalippe pairing)

Time Heals All Wounds by BrightSilverKitty (Harry Potter fanfic, Time Travel AU, Bellamione pairing)

Tunnel Rats by J_Nerd (Ghostbusters fanfic, Beautythe Beast TV series AU, Holtzbert pairing)

And now As if We Never Said Goodbye rockets with ease to the top of that list. Number one on The Greatest Fanfics I've ever read.

Thank you for sharing this with us.

PS I kinda hate you because you've totally ruined dating for me now lol nothing stacks up XD

This is by far one of the best love stories ive read. Ive read many books, many fictions and novels and none can scratch what youve done here in 19 chapters. Please could you continue this and finish it ! Your mind is wonderful and we need more from you

BEST CHAPTER EVERRRRR

This is one of the best fanfictions I've ever read. Or even one of the best romance novels.

Can't like won't deny this fic had me deep in my feelings for a solid 20 chapters. Thanks for this

This was so fulfilling. I felt like I traveled with them. And experienced love and heartbreak. and a craving for a new life one head never lived

This. This behemoth of a beautiful, visual story has captivated me from the onset. Absolutely well done. This has also inspired me to reevaluate myself and my life, and for that I sincerely thank you.

I'm applying to law school in the fall but I'm going to defer it for a year once accepted. After I graduate in May next year, I plan on taking a gap year to travel. This story was inspiring and held much more than romance. Thank you, and once again excellent work here.

I used to read this fic back in 2011 as you posted and today I decided to revisit it and oh my God, it's still as marvelous as I remembered. Thank you so much for writing this!

i just finished reading part, and i want to say something. Thank you.
Thank you for making feel things in my heart that i have never thought they existed before.
Thank you for making me live an adventure, without even leaving my room. Thank you for letting me realize that its time to find love.
Thank you for this wonderful, pure perfection story.
This story, will forever stay in my heart.