love it

You are terribly cruel to leave us like this. But-I must say, your writing is amazing.

i love barney and robin 2gthr and btw i h8 imogen she is like a total b...h

Still the queen of the HIMYM fan fiction. this is just pure loveliness. I can't wait to find out Robin's answer..keeping my fingers crossed for a yes. Now if only the shows creators could take a hint and put them together again on the show:)

can't wait for another update!

This story is AWESOME! Gah, I just love it! My story is up so if you would read and review you could make my day ;) Sad to see this story closing up shop :( Write more barney/robin please!

First of all, thanks for checking out my story, your opinion really means a lot :) and second of all... That was soooo romantic, I LOVED it, please post up your continuation soon, can't wait!

awwwwwwwwwww

I'm so sorry I haven't been able to review in the past few days because I'm in China and I've been in Beijing for a while where we had an internet connection but then visited Luoyang and Xi'an (Ancient capitals of China) and there was no chance to actually connect to the internet. I was so excited to see several updates when I returned.

Imogen... errrgh. She has to go. I'm still convinced it's Starla, I'll actually be incredibly disappointed if it isn't. And the awkward thing about the professor just reminded me of The Wedding Bride, when Ted talks about baggage. I've actually found myself quite invested in the stories of Marshall and Lily and surprisingly, Ted (who is one of my favorite characters but I often find myself more interested in the Marshmallow and Lilypad or Barney and Robin side of the story) rather than the Robin and Barney part. Not to say that Robin and Barney isn't great in this story, I don't really love giant time skips but I'm definitely excited now that he's proposing. Not to suggest that they don't end up together, but she should say no. Not to stretch your story even farther, but it would definitely keep me even more invested in the Robin and Barney plot in this story.

Can't wait for 'Something in the Way' and as for baby name suggestions, first of all I've always wanted a little girl for Marshall and Lily, and I really like the names Ramona or Quinn.

This was great! Loved how you incorporated the song so much in the story, and how you gave us a glimpse of each side of the stories! Looking forward to your next story!

*crowd goes awwww*

xD

That was hilarious how he just couldn't get the moment.

But hey, being Barney, he's awesome, so it doesn't matter right?

And wow. I'm almost begging for Ted to dump Imogen at this point. I just can't get to liking her.

Marshall will probably win the flamethrower.

Good work~

awwwwww

will she say yes?

will ted kick Imogen to the curve?

I feel so sorry for imogen, not that I know what happened to her but I still think they should breakup cuz they just don't seem compatible. Just quickly going to say yay for Marshall finally being appreciated! Now for the Barney/robin mwahaha... The names wrong and the hockey fight -as I like to say *take palm,place on face* but when it happened it really was the perfect moment, sweet an perfect! Decided what the name for the continuation is? And just wondering, would u be able to check out my HIMYM story? I would really love your opinion because you are one of the best writers ever!

Oh my gosh, loved Barney's attempts at proposals, and then finally just going with the right moment! Amazing, and looking forward to your next story.

Imogen needs to relax

First of all I absolutely LOVED where you put the song, it was so sweet and romantic and perfect (YAY! :)), the description you gave of Barney really set an image to the reader! The rose and candy story was too funny, all that chaos and then he rips it on the door: SOOO laughworthy! Imogen's freakout...maybe it'll get Ted to finally look at her in terms of 'could I really be married to this the rest of my life?' My favorite Beatles song that hasn't already been used amazingly in your writing has to be 'all my loving' (plus it's in the movie hard days night..loved that movie) it would be really cool to see that song used! For baby names... I think and like the idea that the kid'll be a boy, because in 'last cigarette ever' Ted said Marshall's was the day his son was born and I think no matter what the gender was he would react the same because its his first child, so my vote is for boy! Maybe name it Jason after Jason segal or if it's a girl, Alyson after Alyson hannigan. It also be a nice memento to name the kid Marvin after his dad. Personal preferences are Brielle, Anya, (for girls.) Alaric, and Avery (for boys) just throwing those out there! Can't wait for the final chapter and the next story! Maybe do the hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy style trilogy and call it a trilogy when there are nine stories, I know I would read nine or more of them cuz I wouldn't be able to get enough of the awesomeness! Woah me...tangent-city... Anyways please update really soon! Pretty please with cherries on top!