Reviews for The Black Rose
CharlieBoneFan chapter 61 . 9/23/2015
Amazing. It was a great story. And I'm glad Raoul is out of the picture...wow that was mean of me to say but I don't care.
Wynni chapter 43 . 4/14/2015
Okay, nice save on all counts. Well done.

Now get our lovie outta there already!
Wynni chapter 42 . 4/14/2015
How the heck is Erik getting out of this one?

and how the heck is he gonna justify playing dead the EXACT same way she lost her father?

boy is in for a thumping when he gets back.
Wynni chapter 41 . 4/14/2015
Ooooh, did you open a can of worms about 'Love never Dies'
Firstly, you know its a bad plot when you have to assassinate the character of HOW many people to make your story work?
1. Madame Giry would never whore her daughter out
2. Meg completely annihilated out of all recognition . I don't even know where to begin
3. Raoul also out of character, by a LOT.

so when three of your five principles are unrecognizable as themselves, how can it be a good story? I don't care for it, just as I consider stories that have a 'monster' Raoul or dead Raoul an insult the writer is basically saying Erik could never win Christine's heart on his own merit.
and I can't agree with that.
which has me worried about where this particular Raoul is going. I'm guessing his 'family' is French Mafia? Christine was a means to an end, and it was his family after Erik and that killed her dad?
MissyH316 chapter 61 . 3/25/2015
Nice ending - and well-deserved for all the good guys! Thanks for sharing!
MissyH316 chapter 58 . 3/25/2015
Yay! I thought he fell back down the staircase - but he fell over and off the roof, eh? No matter - the end result is the main thing!

And of course Christine can rightfully claim she acted in self-defense; I'm sure she didn't mean to kill Raoul - that was an accident - but I'm sure they're both relieved he's gone! Well, we ALL are! :-)
MissyH316 chapter 54 . 3/25/2015
LOCKS, people! USE THEM! This can't be good!
MissyH316 chapter 49 . 3/25/2015
All good! :-D
MissyH316 chapter 48 . 3/25/2015
This better not be a dream! HOORAY! Good thing Erik is made of tough stuff!
MissyH316 chapter 47 . 3/25/2015
ME!
MissyH316 chapter 46 . 3/25/2015
Of COURSE Raoul won't listen! How can Christine want to have anything do DO with that disgusting piece of Fop-Trash? Good grief!
MissyH316 chapter 44 . 3/25/2015
I'm willing to HOST the "Hate the Fop" party! Yech, he's evil!
MissyH316 chapter 43 . 3/25/2015
Of course Erik's alive and thank God. But I think Raoul needs to take a very long walk off of a very short plank. :-( Didn't see that coming about Raoul's family having past criminal, Mafia-sounding ties to Erik in the past, but it's believeable.
MissyH316 chapter 40 . 3/25/2015
Well, very sad but not unexpected - but I'm sure everything will work out in the end. It BETTER, anyway, or there could be a Punjab lasso in the author's future! (JK! lol)
MissyH316 chapter 39 . 3/25/2015
Encore! ;-)
461 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »