I’m reading this for the first time after recently having started exploring the much underrated RemusxSirius pairing. I still have quite a few chapters to go but just had to say that how much I’m enjoying your writing style, character development, and storyline! Love how you’re developing the attraction between the two while keeping in mind the delicate nature of it all.

Aaarhhg this story is real old, but for what it's worth: it's fan-tas-tic! WOW
I hope you read this and realise people are still reading even after so many years

I have so many words for the love i have for this story. This story spoke to my soul. First, I loved your note at the very beginning outlining the chapters with smut. I knew right then I was going to love this story. I absolutely adored the idea that Sirius's love sprouted from friendship and his need to protect Remus. Every sex scene between Remus and Sirius turned me on (TMI? IDC). I was so impressed with your dedication to the description of the Marauders transforming into their animagus forms for the first time. The entire quest to rescue Remus was both unexpected and absolutley delightful. i reall felt like you captured each of their personalities and quirks perfectly.

I'm 8 years late but om this was such a good story, you probably don't write fanfiction anymore but I jut love the characterization so much and Remus is such a soft boi abt how much it hurts him that he killed innocent muggles i love it so much. Just oml *claps*

Great fic, it was nice to see the dwell in their heads if they should be together - I specially liked they way it began when something broke. Really cute. And realistic. But I'll admit I wished Mary would just vanish, lol. But their love is great 3

I really like the thought that went into this fic, and really enjoyed it but what happened to Remus was heartbreaking! I'm so glad it had a happy ending (then I remember canon and I'm sad again)

ahhh this fanfic is amazing!

Fucking loved this fic. Devoured it in like 2 days cause I couldn’t put it down. The plot line with Remus getting captured totally came out of nowhere for me (totally thought this was going to be just another hang out at hogwarts fic) and it was super exciting! Thanks for all the love you put into writing it. Also it was very very very hot. Like, yum. I also thought the balance was great with how central James and Peter were while keeping the story focused on WolfStar -I think that can be tricky.
Cheers!
Margaret (I was just too lazy to log in, but this will eventually go on my Favorites)

OMFG JUST FINISHED AND JUST WOW I LOVE IT

i love how you described the process of becoming an Animagus! the potions and the spells together, really fascinating!

I'm crying, honestly,i have tears...i hope this gets a happy ending,atleast i hope remus is alive

thank you for writing this lovely story. It was a true representation of both the Marauders adventures as well as the wolfstar ship :)
I just wanted to let you know that even years after you wrote this there are still new people discovering and appreciating your work!

I absolutely love this story, and the fact that it fits into canon. BTW, technically, both Remus could have been bisexual and Sirius gay without it violating canon, but I'm not really that hung up/invested on the details :)

The inventiveness of Kate and Greyback's werewolf civilization is amazing. These elements add a lot to the plot, and I think they make it much more realistic. I could totally see this being a great HP Prequel.

There is only one (very small) thing I think could improve the story, and that is that I wish that after the incident (Snape finding out about Remus' condition), we could have seen a bit more of the forgiving process. It surprises me that Remus was so easily willing to remain friends with Sirius. Other (Fanfic) versions of this have the Marauders feuding over it for months, and considering how Remus' worst fear is that he will hurt someone else (his boggart is a full moon), I would have thought he'd be incredibly upset with Sirius. But I completely recognize that this incident is not really the main focus of your story - which has incredibly lovely fluff and great character development regardless.

We aren’t practicing?! MADE ME FUCKING WHEEZEEEEE MY BABAS

The moony Wormtail Padfoot and prongs but... FUCKING WEEPING