Mmmmm...this was another cute one shot that I love!

Really liked this story. It would be good as a longer story. Perhaps a sequel?

i love it! great stroy!

D'awww!

Haha, I LOVED the Rachel & Santanna friendship stuff in here. So funny and great!

And of course, the Puck/Rachel loooove ;)

Wonderful, as usual!

loved it !

This was hilarious and sweet and imo very IC for everyone (aside from Rachel's sadly blind spot when it comes to her image of Finn, but I'm all for creative license in righting that one _). I lovedn all their voices! Thanks for sharing!

Woah, tons of Finn bashing in this one, but I have to admit that sometimes he deserves it: I don't know why people keeps looking at him like he's a little victim and perfect when he can be a tool, especially with Rachel. Loved the flashback to Rachel's birthday, even more because they were skating, reminding me of this sweet and very well-known moment between the Puckleberry fans: watch?vemavqH-LW_4

Hahaha, Santana is always amusing as an ally for both of them. Oh, yeah, Puck is the freaking crack for making Rachel cum without even taking her clothes off, and it was sweet to see how much he knew about Rachel

"Is today I hate Finn day or something?" Puck asked the two girls and they only looked slightly guilty. "Finally!" he said plopping down next to Rachel and pulling his guitar into his lap. "I've been waiting for this day for fucking ever."

Genius

Another great story!

LMAO jus great .. mel

awwwwwww

That was so good. I love Puckelberry. :) It was sexy, but cute at the same time. :)

really fun read!

I like this story! Very good!

Fantastic one-shot. I loved how Rachel and Santana just blatantly bash Finn and actually compared sexual notes. Lol. I also loved Puck and Sam's reaction to the whole conversation. It was hilarious. I love I hate Finn day. )