| Reviews for Purely Coincidental |
|---|
psychoanalyst chapter 13 . 7/7 I think the rating needs to be changed to T. But it's a cute story. |
psychoanalyst chapter 1 . 7/7 real talk: i just finished an M-rated fanfic, and i just need fluff. but i will review, bc you worked on this. i will prob skip the m-parts. |
8BraveHeart8 chapter 13 . 11/28/2018 This is a very beautiful SyaoSaku love story. They met beautifully... In a unique beautiful way! Unfortunately, the last chapter was a big dissapointment. They deserve a wedding, and even one date as official couple. Their kissing scene wasn't beautiful at all, it was honestly disgusting, you've wasted time describing how Sakura stinks and that's gross! The dream confession and the kiss in the car was so much better but it also turned out to be another disappointment because it was just a stupid dream. You've, once again, wasted time and put so much effort in writing that irrelevant dream but you didn't even put effort in writing the proposal scene, making it an another irrelevant thing. UNBELIEVABLE. You should have at least shown us their wedding. They didn't really spend time together as official couple even once. It was rush and the ending was nothing but a narration. It was an obvious lazy ending. The most pathetic ending I've ever read. You've narrated everything, as in the whole ending, even the proposal. Proposal is a very important part of romance or love story. It shouldn't be just a narration. In story, SHOWING IS MUCH MORE IMPORTANT THAN TELLING. Syaoran and Sakura deserve better. Plus, another stupid thing is that you've rated it as M but there's not even lime in it. lol. If they made love inside that theater it would have been better. |
candy chapter 13 . 11/15/2018 what the!-!? and yet, there was already the possiblity of ending it this way, just like the general atmosphere of the whole story- brief and concise. :D thnks for sharing. Brava. |
cadnty chapter 10 . 11/15/2018 the characterizations are entirely awesome and beautiful. a thousand 'thumbs-up' for this work. salud |
candy chapter 4 . 11/15/2018 this is absolutely beautiful. :) |
Guest chapter 2 . 11/15/2018 Wow. This is too engrossing. I cant help but continue on. |
Guest chapter 13 . 6/26/2017 Wow, this is one of the most beautiful and romantic fanfics I have ever read. It's really amazing. |
Tisay chapter 13 . 5/29/2017 Great ground story. Ending was rushed and disatisfyin tho |
letmewanderhere chapter 12 . 10/6/2016 I read it and then started again from the beginning. |
Wings13 chapter 13 . 3/22/2015 The first several chapters of this story was absolutely amazing and seemed to be building up to a fantastic ending, but then it seemed like you were rushing to finish. Hopefully you can redo this story and put in as much creativity in the ending as you did starting out. Otherwise, this fanfic was great and very cute. |
bookwurm247 chapter 3 . 3/11/2015 He's so awkward! _ |
mrs. zala chapter 13 . 2/4/2014 hmmhmm.. i like this story. too bad you didn't give an explanation why sakura are too.. paranoid about relationship. her hesitate was too odd. hahaha as for the conflict, if you ever decide to write something like this again.. give more conflict. what i see is the conflict comes from around syaoran and sakura. even though there are many possible rivals.. too bad. but what's done is done. so... oya! you need to make a concrete line in each scene. sometimes, i'm getting confused when you just change the scene 'abruptly' without proper sentence. just a comment. oya! this is CLEARLY rated T, not M. there's no sexual things inside beside kissing. until next time, mrs. zala |
mrs. zala chapter 1 . 2/4/2014 you know what? when i first reading the summary, i thought sakura is a ghost. hahaha. it turns out it wasn't. silly me. i'm looking forward for the next chapter! until next time, mrs. zala |
Shuuwai chapter 13 . 10/17/2013 It seem way too rushed... since it was like a huge jump and it would of been awesome to see their official dates :P But loved it (: well minus the last chapter :o |