| Reviews for Apple Tree |
|---|
Sony Boy chapter 1 . 7/12/2012 I loved this fic and added it to my community and while I was going over it I just had to read it again. I can't believe I didn't review. I loved the idea, the implications and the depth that it gaved all four. Six if you count Prime and Jazz. Sam for his green-thumb and how in a naive way he's mature. Mikaela in her knowledger of her background and how she compared to Sam and the acceptance of what makes him him. Bee in his interest to learn about and from Sam and Earth and the idea on how everything has a purpose. Ratchett in his subtle prejudice/ignorance and slight enlightenment. Even if on the fringe both Prime's reaction to Bee and Sam's conversation and acts on how to protect Earth; as well as Jazz's personality an love of music/noise being how Bee learned, remembered and improvised from that and the camouflage coloring. Everything was lovely. |
Desiree1717 chapter 1 . 1/12/2012 I really like this. |
Guest chapter 1 . 7/10/2011 Beautiful story with complex emotions and thinking. Topped with a wonderful explanation at the end. Awesome! :) |
Cedarleaf chapter 1 . 6/13/2011 Ho shoy. Dude, /awesome/ concept. I love the concept of humans and transformers having a shared origin like that. You have just the coolest ideas. And Bee's right, Ratchet needs to come down from his high horse and get his hands /dirt/y for a change. His comment though about seashells and ratios reminded me of two other Transformers fics called "Seashells" and "Beautiful Day" by Aspirare. Check 'em out if you like. |
Shadir chapter 1 . 3/1/2011 Very beautiful. |
JazzNProwl's sparklingAriaFyre chapter 1 . 2/23/2011 Nice. I enjoyed it. |
femme4jack chapter 1 . 2/23/2011 I hadn't read this one before! What a wonderful image of Bee wanting to learn something, enjoy something just for the sake of doing it, and the subtle prejudice on Ratchet's part (that it was fine for humans to learn all about Cybertronian physiology but why would he learn anything about how they grew food) was fascinating. I love the idea of Sam as a gardener, bringing extra food to the pantry. Gives his character more depth, and is a fascinating way for him to inherit his parents interest in growing things in his own unique way. And, of course, the connection with it all to the Allspark, the idea that the Allspark brought life to Earth is really fascinating! I'd love to see what they discover in that jungle. |
mooncrossed chapter 1 . 2/23/2011 It makes sense that Sam would be into gardening. The idea of Cybertron and Earth actually being related on a deeper level is pretty cool. Nice one-shot! |
CuriousDreamWeaver chapter 1 . 2/22/2011 Very nice. I thought that you had a really interesting plot and your characterisation (not to mention your choice of included characters) was well done. _~ CDW |
Harm Marie chapter 1 . 2/22/2011 I really liked this. |