This is absolutely amazing! I know these are one shots but damn they are awesome and you should totally continue them

I am so in love with Finn and Rachel's lives in New York... So much love!

OK. Seriously. Let's start with the least important thing but the most brilliant: Finn as a firefighter. He makes such complete sense. He's giant, athletic, and has a huge heart. That was sheer genius, my friend.

Now, as for the story, it was ALSO sheer genius. You know I love the song, so I'll ignore that and move right to your beautiful writing. It's amazing how you can not tell us everything about what happened and yet I feel like I was there just the same. I loved your pacing, with the repetition of the "it doesn't matter" clauses. AND, I love seeing grown up Finn/Rachel/Puck, with little pieces of them from before that made their characters, but growth and maturity that would come from age and experience.

Excellent job!