Lovely and sweet. I thought that Puck adding little comments to his papers and recipes was just perfect.

That was insanely awesome. Oh my god, I love this fic. How Puck doesn't lose any of his cool point or badassness yet still manages to be sweet. How he's the only one to get through to Rachel and help her calm down and be happy without being any less awesome than she is. Great fic.

Arghhhhhhhh...

OHMYGODTHISISSOSWEET! All those mementos and what each one of them represented were very romantic. I felt a pang in the chest when Puck tries to deal with the rejection he's expecting from Rachel, acting like he doesn't care that much. His explanation why he backed off their "revenge sex" project touched my heart, and was so happy when she confessed that she really wanted to be with him, even more when whe discover at the end that they make it endgame.

Awww! I think that was the most incredibly sweet oneshot I've ever read :D

ok r there real guys out there like puck was in this story cuz if so sign me up for two..lmao.. mel

Aww... That was adorable. Loved it!

Kate

The focus of this story is, frankly, adorable and creepy at the same time. I say adorable because the thought of someone liking me that much kind of makes my heart race, and it's about a thousand times better because it features my favorite couple. I adore the idea of Puck creating a box of memories - it's better than a journal, so he doesn't have to write down feelings or acknowledge them, but at the same time he has tangible objects which all mean something to him and he has the memories in his head attached to them. Rachel's the only one who realizes the full significance of what others would simply see as an odd collection of random things. I just love that idea.

(It's creepy because it's only cute when the affection is reciprocated. If you don't like the other person, then it's just stalking. I can't help thinking of that no matter how cute the ending is.)

That being said, I still enjoyed the story a lot.

Great job!

This story just goes to show: if you find the guy hot, intense attention is romantic. If you don't find him hot, it's creepy. Really well-written.

This was so sweet. Still in character. I love puckeleberry.

Okay that may have been the cutest story I've read yet. That was so freaking adorable. Have I mentioned yet how much I love your stories? Because I do. Very much. :D

Literally. BEST one shot of Puk and Rachel. EVER!

Puck is all gooey inside. Like a burnt marshmallow!

Great story. I love the idea of Puck keeping all those mementos of Rachel and actually caring. )

i like it