| Reviews for In The Ashes |
|---|
cherigiesinger chapter 44 . 1/3 I really love this story, of all the fanfiction I have read, I think this has been the best with so much depth. I hope you return one day to continue writing it. |
Guest chapter 44 . 12/29/2019 I spent a weekend in this alternate world of yours and it was loads of fun. There are many, many stories I've enjoyed on this site, but yours is the first I've taken time to "review." (Yes, I am one of those horrid, selfish people who typically just enjoys...this is mainly because I usually overthink practically everything and I always feel I ought to do in-depth chapter-by-chapter reviews and then I am exhausted by the whole notion before I've even begun. I digress.) The safe house in America was an interesting idea and you executed it well. The characters are lively and intelligent. What I enjoyed most was the movement. From the first chapter, the action was quick and intriguing. I always wanted to know what was coming next. Some of the interaction between Hermione and Severus was different from what I personally envision (yes, I am a HGSS shipper), but it still worked. It was like a smoosh-up of Mr. Rochester and Jane and Buffy and Spike, with Hermione and Severus' basic personalities mixed in. As I am fond of all these characters, your interpretation worked for me. The intimate scenes were written smoothly. Obviously, I would love for you to take time to finish your work. I note that your last update was around the time of the last presidential election. As someone who is still horrified and shocked by the outcome, I can only hope that despair did not stop you from continuing with this piece. I look forward to someday reading about Ronald Crump's ousting and Moldyvort's demise. I also hope that you are cancer-free and overall well. If you are unable to ever continue this work, then I must say you still did a bang-up job and at least you left our heroes looking as though they will win the day. Thank you for sharing your words. -TG |
muumi2three chapter 25 . 11/11/2019 Why on earth would Hermione call Severus a minx? That's so uncalled-for. He's not a girl in the least. |
k.m.minnich chapter 44 . 9/13/2019 i hope there are updates one day! |
CRoseSing chapter 44 . 6/2/2019 I love your story! BAMF Hermione is my favorite, and you did her so well. She’s strong and vulnerable, commanding, yet not bossy. If you ever decided to come back to this, I’d be thrilled to see the end of the war and whether the guns work! Either way, I’m glad you shared your imagination and time in this work! |
Guest chapter 44 . 11/10/2018 I enjoyed this. I do hope you will up the only thing i have a problem with is Remus being quite out of Character otherwise i love everything. I always thiught Hermione would have been a much better leader had anyone been willing to listen and she had the all information required. |
KylieKyotie chapter 1 . 9/9/2018 I really enjoyed this story. I would love to read a few wrap-up chapters with an awesome final battle and an epilogue if you get back to this someday. I have you favorited - so fingers crossed ; ) |
AquiViva chapter 12 . 8/30/2018 I like the battle plans! |
AquiViva chapter 10 . 8/30/2018 I've always had the headcanon that Snape would be a good cook. Comes with being a potions master. He'd experiment and everything. Lol at him stealing her knickers and his obvious way of fixing the problem. Great work. |
AquiViva chapter 9 . 8/30/2018 Oh Narcissa. Cars aren't too scary. |
AquiViva chapter 7 . 8/30/2018 Hahaha Snape is totally a goth. |
AquiViva chapter 6 . 8/30/2018 Oh man. To be able to buy a house with cash in an afternoon. The previous owners must have dropped their jaws. XD |
AquiViva chapter 5 . 8/30/2018 I like that her codename is Pearl. It fits well. |
AquiViva chapter 4 . 8/30/2018 Asshole Spanish government. |
AquiViva chapter 3 . 8/30/2018 Poor Hermione. |