gave me roller coaster feelings. from angsty-bittersweet-sweet-to funny in one chapter :D

Oh my Gawd this is like one of my favorite stories ever. I don't why. I just love it.

This was great, really great, especially the very ending!

Very good-reminds me of a fic I read a while back (that's... much younger than this one, mwahaha). I'm a bit late to the party, but I guess it's better late than never, right?

So... my only major complaint is the use of whiggleys (or approximation symbols [~] for those who want to be politically correct) to denote flashbacks. In my opinion, italics would have been much better suited.

But, yeah, since this is so old, I'm going to avoid overanalyzing it and everything like I normally would and just say:

Nice job.

-d

Well done.

Very good. I'm not really one for reading slash but this was a good story and the ending was hilarious. Loved it. Strider came in very quickly and with hardly any explanation but i think you carried it off quite well.

Okay, I left a review below complaining about the annoying things stopping me from reading the story, which I understand were not your fault, and now they're gone, and I've read the story, I would like to CONGRATULATE YOU
Oh wow! I absolutely love this story! I loved the scene where Frodo's crying and then tells sam how he feels, it was so,, *sniff* emotional. Man those too are so perfect for eachother.
But I didn't really like the Epilogue, it was so different from the rest of it, with the hole Oh, shit thing, it was kind of spoiled, and the present tense thing also. But otherwise, I'm definately adding to my favourite story list!

What the hell is with the annoying â? things. I couldn't even read the story because they were giving me a headache. Please get rid of them.

Ok, the first 20 lines were promising, especially the prison cell peeked my curiousity, but then the â

This is brilliant. Thank you for writing about such an important topic with such incredible heart. Loved the ending, too:)

Well... That was sad... but sweet... And well written -

Ooh, that really *was* perfect... especially the end 'Ohhhh, shhhhit' heh heh, perfect.

very very good! write more!

Very nicely done! I liked the flashbacks and I especially loved the epilogue. Very very funny. The only mistake I found was the use of the word "Autumnal". There's no need here, as an adjective, to use the "-al" ending. "Autumn day" would be perfectly correct.

~C-chan, a human grammar text

I've always thought it so that the Shire isn't very open minded when it comes to Frodo/Sam. - and that is such a delicious starting point for a fic.