Reviews for Return to the Shadows
Dante6321 chapter 25 . 12/13/2018
God...
That hurts... so much...
Congrats! You just made a 19 year old weeping his heart out.
But seriously this is a masterpiece and should be adapted to a movie or something. Hope to see more of your work, darling!
aj chapter 26 . 10/14/2016
GOD BLESS UFO ENDING
aj chapter 25 . 10/14/2016
1) Thanks for this entire fic, I am crying a lot 2) where's UFO ending
zhulik chapter 26 . 9/3/2014
last chapter is perfect. thank you )
sweetiepiemarnie chapter 26 . 6/3/2011
YAYWTF.

I love your writing style.

I've read all your other fics, and I just finished this one. I really like how you link each SH game and characters together-

Harry and Cheryl SH 1 meet James Sunderland SH 2. Cheryl -now Heather, SH3- meets Henry SH4 through the hole in his bathroom.

And so on in the Spaceship. I liked the alternate Harry and Cheryl/Heather

LOL

I still can't grip the spaceship concept, but at least they're all together. :)

I'd love to see more of this arc soon!
LadyGoddessofAnubis chapter 26 . 5/7/2011
:3 The UFO ending is cannon cuz it doesn't make me cry. . This was gorgeous and touching, and as I said, it made me cry a few times. XP And I love the way you write Alex, that was cute with the 'Bogeyman'. This is a definite favorite and I'll be searching through your other stories. :3
BenMirror chapter 26 . 3/5/2011
HOLY FUCKING SHIT HOLY SHIT THE UFO ENDING

But seriously, this was captivating. Like a movie
BenMirror chapter 1 . 3/5/2011
I started crying at the first sentence, I'm not gonna lie.
suavebadass chapter 26 . 1/1/2011
I've just recently been getting into SH fanfiction after being a fan of SH for years and I am SO HAPPY that I found this story and it's two predecessors afters years of ignoring FFNet. The way you flesh out the characters is absolutely amazing. And you posted multiple endings including a UFO one! You are incredible, seriously. I even created PDFS for this trilogy so I can print and save for later reading, I NEVER have done this for a fic before!

This story has set the bar for all other James/Harry fic I read now.

I've subscribe to your Author Alerts, I'm watching you on DA. I can't wait to see what SH fic you have in store for the future :)
TheOneShotGirl chapter 26 . 12/24/2010
The UFO Ending is the ONLY TRUE ENDING!

No, but really that was beautiful. Seriouly had me tearing up at parts.
Yoshata chapter 26 . 12/15/2010
I know I already left a comment on your DA page, but I gotta leave one here, too, since I mainly read this story on .

This was a very awesome and amusing UFO ending. I still love how you had all the protagonists together. It's perfect!

Travis driving the ship is a nice touch. I have to say him being jealous of James for having Harry was a fun surprise. Heh heh!

Great job.
Miggs chapter 25 . 12/13/2010
Seriously wanted to bawl reading this! Seriously! Do you enjoy making girls cry?

But you redeemed yourself with Chap. 26!
Ivory Tears chapter 26 . 12/11/2010
This is my favorite chapter. I effing loved it! It made me so happy how you had everyone on the ship! Even crazy Heather from Shattered Memories, which I still haven't played. *lol* I was surprised the dog didn't make a guest appearance. ;) Y'know I wonder if they'll ever have any more female protagonists? It seems a bit one sided, and I only noticed when James sat at the table. *lol* Anywho, the UFO ending was perfect, thank you so much for adding it. :)
Not at home chapter 26 . 12/11/2010
I dunno...it's okay, but the way you talked about it on your DA I was expecting it to tie in to the rest of your main storyline better. I'm looking through it again to see if I missed something, but I just ended up feeling kinda disappointed.

Especially since you missed the opportunity to hint about what sort of post SH4 events would get Henry onboard (besides the absence of Eileen.)
RustyPaperclip chapter 25 . 11/29/2010
I'm so sad that the fic is over. I enjoyed it immensely. And before I say anything else, I gotta say 'Henry, you .s.' Glad that you gave him a special appearance.

I love both endings. And I think it's great that you have alternate endings. It's very true to the games. I think... Chapter 24 is canon. Because the heaviness, the gloomy, hopeless feeling of Silent Hill is represented in that ending. I like that Harry and James still had tender moments before everything ends. The same goes for Chapter 25. I love happy endings, well, positive endings rather, as much as the next person but I think Chapter 24 fits your story. I think so, anyway. And I now understand why you asked me about Maria. It's kinda nice that she appeared again before it all ends.

All in all, you did an excellent job. And I thank you for writing such a great piece of work.

-Rusty
66 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »