| Reviews for Return to the Shadows |
|---|
Dante6321 chapter 25 . 12/13/2018 God... That hurts... so much... Congrats! You just made a 19 year old weeping his heart out. But seriously this is a masterpiece and should be adapted to a movie or something. Hope to see more of your work, darling! |
aj chapter 26 . 10/14/2016 GOD BLESS UFO ENDING |
aj chapter 25 . 10/14/2016 1) Thanks for this entire fic, I am crying a lot 2) where's UFO ending |
zhulik chapter 26 . 9/3/2014 last chapter is perfect. thank you ) |
sweetiepiemarnie chapter 26 . 6/3/2011 YAYWTF. I love your writing style. I've read all your other fics, and I just finished this one. I really like how you link each SH game and characters together- Harry and Cheryl SH 1 meet James Sunderland SH 2. Cheryl -now Heather, SH3- meets Henry SH4 through the hole in his bathroom. And so on in the Spaceship. I liked the alternate Harry and Cheryl/Heather LOL I still can't grip the spaceship concept, but at least they're all together. :) I'd love to see more of this arc soon! |
LadyGoddessofAnubis chapter 26 . 5/7/2011 :3 The UFO ending is cannon cuz it doesn't make me cry. . This was gorgeous and touching, and as I said, it made me cry a few times. XP And I love the way you write Alex, that was cute with the 'Bogeyman'. This is a definite favorite and I'll be searching through your other stories. :3 |
BenMirror chapter 26 . 3/5/2011 HOLY FUCKING SHIT HOLY SHIT THE UFO ENDING But seriously, this was captivating. Like a movie |
BenMirror chapter 1 . 3/5/2011 I started crying at the first sentence, I'm not gonna lie. |
suavebadass chapter 26 . 1/1/2011 I've just recently been getting into SH fanfiction after being a fan of SH for years and I am SO HAPPY that I found this story and it's two predecessors afters years of ignoring FFNet. The way you flesh out the characters is absolutely amazing. And you posted multiple endings including a UFO one! You are incredible, seriously. I even created PDFS for this trilogy so I can print and save for later reading, I NEVER have done this for a fic before! This story has set the bar for all other James/Harry fic I read now. I've subscribe to your Author Alerts, I'm watching you on DA. I can't wait to see what SH fic you have in store for the future :) |
TheOneShotGirl chapter 26 . 12/24/2010 The UFO Ending is the ONLY TRUE ENDING! No, but really that was beautiful. Seriouly had me tearing up at parts. |
Yoshata chapter 26 . 12/15/2010 I know I already left a comment on your DA page, but I gotta leave one here, too, since I mainly read this story on . This was a very awesome and amusing UFO ending. I still love how you had all the protagonists together. It's perfect! Travis driving the ship is a nice touch. I have to say him being jealous of James for having Harry was a fun surprise. Heh heh! Great job. |
Miggs chapter 25 . 12/13/2010 Seriously wanted to bawl reading this! Seriously! Do you enjoy making girls cry? But you redeemed yourself with Chap. 26! |
Ivory Tears chapter 26 . 12/11/2010 This is my favorite chapter. I effing loved it! It made me so happy how you had everyone on the ship! Even crazy Heather from Shattered Memories, which I still haven't played. *lol* I was surprised the dog didn't make a guest appearance. ;) Y'know I wonder if they'll ever have any more female protagonists? It seems a bit one sided, and I only noticed when James sat at the table. *lol* Anywho, the UFO ending was perfect, thank you so much for adding it. :) |
Not at home chapter 26 . 12/11/2010 I dunno...it's okay, but the way you talked about it on your DA I was expecting it to tie in to the rest of your main storyline better. I'm looking through it again to see if I missed something, but I just ended up feeling kinda disappointed. Especially since you missed the opportunity to hint about what sort of post SH4 events would get Henry onboard (besides the absence of Eileen.) |
RustyPaperclip chapter 25 . 11/29/2010 I'm so sad that the fic is over. I enjoyed it immensely. And before I say anything else, I gotta say 'Henry, you .s.' Glad that you gave him a special appearance. I love both endings. And I think it's great that you have alternate endings. It's very true to the games. I think... Chapter 24 is canon. Because the heaviness, the gloomy, hopeless feeling of Silent Hill is represented in that ending. I like that Harry and James still had tender moments before everything ends. The same goes for Chapter 25. I love happy endings, well, positive endings rather, as much as the next person but I think Chapter 24 fits your story. I think so, anyway. And I now understand why you asked me about Maria. It's kinda nice that she appeared again before it all ends. All in all, you did an excellent job. And I thank you for writing such a great piece of work. -Rusty |