good very good. love it. makes all sorts of sense. truely love it

words cannot describe how much i LOOOOVVVVEEEE this ficcc! whole idea was adorable and sirius's reaction had me rolling on the ground laughing :) i could picture this happening and being reason for snape's additude towards harry. so yep... love love love it. :D

That was thought provoking - it really would've been cool if it was Snape who thought of Harry's name. D

Oh no, oh no, this is just too cute for me to handle! *squees* This story made me feel all warm inside, now why is that?

I really liked this. But imagine if Sev never suggested Harry? It would be, "Elvendork Potter and the Socerer's/Philosopher's Stone!" Harry has a better ring to it.

Ahhhhhhh, that's adorkable! Really, it's very good and I had a very similar conversation between me and a guy friend I have... Sorry, brain malfunction, I was thinking.

But, very good and I can totally see that have happened.

The diary bit was very teenager-y, an aspect I think canon lacks sometimes. (ie. lack of swearing)

Good, though.

I enjoyed it.

Awh, that's so cute (: I thought it was sweet that he'd name his duaghter after Lily, but I was a little surprised that he'd name his kid Harry. It was a really sweet oneshot though (: I especially loved the last line.

Very good and sweet. Definently potrayed Lily and Sev correctly. Loved it!